Storr wrote:Thing is, my role HAS been proven. I have brought someone back form the dead. He was town when he died, he is still town.
*sigh* Okay, let me walk you orl thru a cupple tings reeeeeeel sloooooow:
We can agree dat Marashu was 100% Town Insane Cop wen he died. Dat's wot he flipped, dat's wot he was AT DAT TIME. No kwestjun.
The kwestjun is: In dis game in witch the mods are not just been basterds but have aparently desided to go full cant, why wood we tink he has cum bak teh same, esp. in the ite of dis, witch I am geting tired of reposting:
If a game is not No Reveal but includes revival in some form, it is more likely that the revived player has secretly received a non-Town Role PM in the interim than that they are the same role as before.1. We shood consider dat Marashu is, at best, a 50/50 chanse to return teh same. Acording to dis quote, teh odds overall are less then 50/50.
2. You must have known dis. Theirfore teh vewy act of bringink bak Marashu itself looks scummy.
3. Wot is making me more suspishus is yore repeeted atempts to sweep dis under teh carpet and insist dat Marashu is teh same as befour. Seems to me dat a Town wood aknollege teh posibility dat Marashu is diferent now.
Mets kinda gets it, but he is rong, in teh lite of teh above quote, too say it is
unlikely dat Marashu is diferunt now. It is ackshually
likely.
metsfanmax wrote:Based on what? I'll admit that probably he is town, because having an effect to bring someone back and change their alignment is just unlikely. But can we be certain he's town? No, and despite all the shit that Aladdin is tossing around, you're making things worse too by responding to his paranoia with this crap.
Now, on to PTLowe's chek on Storr:
Rishaed wrote:Also for all you newbz who can't wrap their head around the fact that A. Storr is confirmed town because of the cop check from ptlowe. Get over it. Move on. Storr cannot be scum right now because unless Marashu is messing with us the cult recruiter is dead.
PTLowe flipped Town Cop, so his chek carrys a lot of weigt, BUT it is NOT watertite, as Storr (and now Rish??? - hmmm) wants us to beleeve. Why? Well, Godfather wood return Town to PTLowe, fer a start. Den there is teh posibility of busdriving. So, yes, PTLowe's chek does make Storr look considderably moor Townish, but def not 100%.
Agin, it is Storr's ackshuns dat make me suspishus of him - bringink back Marashu and den insisting he is teh same as befor he dyed, and pushing hard fer a massclaim dat just looks bad fer Town. And, agin, his reackshun dozent help his corze: He bangs on insessently about how he has been cop cheked, but refuses to acknowledge teh chek isent watertite.
@Rish: And why wood we tink Marashu isent messing wit us? I showed above (agin) dat teh chances are dat he is scum now. Agin, who benefits frum Marashu's assershun dat HotShot was a Cult recrooter? IB - becorse it lends creedence to IB's claim dat HS was danjerus to Town. Like IB says, sumtimes it is teh littul tings dat matter.
