Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[for dummies]

Unvote well those past 6 pages were very interesting.

Posted: 24 May 2007 19:10

The Archery Contest - Why Can't We All Just Get Along?

"Realizing his mistake, Sir Guy turned to flee. Somehow, he'd now made enemies with both sides. His only hope was to get away, and let things cool down for a moment.

He ran through the village, ducking into the inn where he had been staying, making his way up to his room to collect his things. As he opened the door, a flash caught in the corner of his eye; for the briefest second, he thought he saw a giant wielding a staff. Then he saw nothing at all."

got tonkaed, Sir Guy of Gisbourne (Vigilante), has been beaten to death!

Posted: 24 May 2007 19:12

Sweet f*cking christ.... It's a damn bloodbath....

All right, will the person who's Little John please step forward and identify yourself?

Fos Incandenza. 2 minuets after the death he posts and names the killer. it could be coincidence but it feels to me like this happened.

-Tonka kills Ak and his role is revelaed 18:54
-Inc sees this and sends day vig into aim, he wants a power role out of the way.
-Aim kills Tonka 19:10
-Inc posts about death of tonka, trying to be funny but unwittingly revealing his role. 19:12

Thoughts?

[spinwizard]

woah mad, what is the sherifs role?

[AK_iceman]

GT, you fucking idiot!

Thanks for not letting me post a defense, or claim. I had 1 goddamn vote on me, and that was from dominationnation who I don't even take seriously... Jesus...

Good luck townies, it'll be a lot harder now that I never had a chance to share my investigations.

[Aimless]

woah mad, what is the sherifs role?

Ack, sorry. It's listed on the first page, but I forgot to include it in the death scene. The Sheriff was a cop.

[Aegnor]

GT, you fucking idiot!

Thanks for not letting me post a defense, or claim. I had 1 goddamn vote on me, and that was from dominationnation who I don't even take seriously... Jesus...

Good luck townies, it'll be a lot harder now that I never had a chance to share my investigations.

It's ok, we'll just have to read through your posts to figure it out. Did you hear it people? Start reading Ak's posts.

[Aegnor]

:shock:

Ummm... that's odd....

Vote - Selin

Thats pretty damning evidence man, but I would still like to hear you're side of it.

*Cough * You guys thing AK had the pleasure of investigating Selin?

[Aegnor]

Vote-moz

I have a theory on why the night phase lasted so long, and I'm 80% sure I'm correct.

Hmm this has already been discussed, and AK even admitted he was wrong with his theory. On the other hand, do you think he had the chance to investigate MOZ?

FOS MOZ for now

[for dummies]

nah. if he had investigated moz and he had come up scum. AK would never have backed off of him like that.

[for dummies]

again maybe he investigated selin. but probably not. if he had come up mafia then ak would have pushed harder. if he hadn't come up mafia then he would never have voted for selin.

[Incandenza]

The Archery Contest - Why Can't We All Just Get Along?

"Realizing his mistake, Sir Guy turned to flee. Somehow, he'd now made enemies with both sides. His only hope was to get away, and let things cool down for a moment.

He ran through the village, ducking into the inn where he had been staying, making his way up to his room to collect his things. As he opened the door, a flash caught in the corner of his eye; for the briefest second, he thought he saw a giant wielding a staff. Then he saw nothing at all."

got tonkaed, Sir Guy of Gisbourne (Vigilante), has been beaten to death!

Posted: 24 May 2007 19:12

Sweet f*cking christ.... It's a damn bloodbath....

All right, will the person who's Little John please step forward and identify yourself?

Fos Incandenza. 2 minuets after the death he posts and names the killer. it could be coincidence but it feels to me like this happened.

-Tonka kills Ak and his role is revelaed 18:54
-Inc sees this and sends day vig into aim, he wants a power role out of the way.
-Aim kills Tonka 19:10
-Inc posts about death of tonka, trying to be funny but unwittingly revealing his role. 19:12

Thoughts?

So I bolded a bit of Aimless' post for a reason, as there's only one giant wielding a staff in the robin hood canon, and that's... wait for it... Little John, for crying out loud. I was super into the robin hood stuff as a kid, and even saw the costner movie when it was in theaters. Trust me, whoever killed tonka (unless it was a mod event type thing) was little john. More to the point, little john would almost certainly not have participated in the archery contest...

And hmmmm, who's been absent a lot but posted right during this whole rondelay, who was clearly online between the time tonka was outed as the vig and was himself killed? That's right, folks, colaalone! (the timing works for a few other people as well, namely willis and moz, but cola's been super duper submarining for a long time)

FOS cola

[Aegnor]

Well, if I was masons with Auto it would be 'are', not 'were'.

Yes, I meant AK.

-X

Did he share any of the investigations with you?
And can a cop also be a mason at the same time?

[for dummies]

hmmm i think not. aimless would not make a cop mason. I am not sure i believe xenhu's claim. And since we don't have Ak to back it up it is looking pretty nonsubstanshial right now.

[Incandenza]

hmmm i think not. aimless would not make a cop mason. I am not sure i believe xenhu's claim. And since we don't have Ak to back it up it is looking pretty nonsubstanshial right now.

Funny, I was just thinking that.... xen also fits into the 'online when all this shit went down' category...

xen, if you are a mason, you'd have been given a special character name. Care to share that with us?

[willis]

IMO AK was a mason mainly because when aimless posted him dead it was in orange not green.

[Incandenza]

again maybe he investigated selin. but probably not. if he had come up mafia then ak would have pushed harder. if he hadn't come up mafia then he would never have voted for selin.

It's possible that AK investigated selin and selin came up clean, which is why AK had that whole thing going after selin was outed as a contestant...

[for dummies]

that would also fit with my earlier theory of robin being a godfather. he shoots well and would come up clean from an investigation

[nagerous]

hmmm i think not. aimless would not make a cop mason. I am not sure i believe xenhu's claim. And since we don't have Ak to back it up it is looking pretty nonsubstanshial right now.

Funny, I was just thinking that.... xen also fits into the 'online when all this shit went down' category...

xen, if you are a mason, you'd have been given a special character name. Care to share that with us?

no I think xen is clean, he is the one who supported AK and said he had trust if you notice got tonka said Xen why do you trust AK before he vigilante killed him. you (Incandenza) on the other hand appear to me very scummy. By asking for Xen's character name it is possible to out a power role. You talk about other people i.e cola being around when everything kicked off, but weren't you around too? you don't mention your name on the list you produced

[for dummies]

oh he was around. look at the top post on 131. i lay out a big case against him. right now we have a lot of suspects and he is definitly one of them

[nagerous]

OKAY, quick theory: Little John is a mafia with daykill powers. That means he's probably played by someone who's been posting over the last page or two... right now I'm looking at Xen and Cola...

this is the quote, you immediately spring to me as someone posting on the last page before and after

[pancakemix]

again maybe he investigated selin. but probably not. if he had come up mafia then ak would have pushed harder. if he hadn't come up mafia then he would never have voted for selin.

It's possible that AK investigated selin and selin came up clean, which is why AK had that whole thing going after selin was outed as a contestant...

Which would mean Godfather.

[for dummies]

duh. i just said that 4 posts ago. don't skim

[Incandenza]

hmmm i think not. aimless would not make a cop mason. I am not sure i believe xenhu's claim. And since we don't have Ak to back it up it is looking pretty nonsubstanshial right now.

Funny, I was just thinking that.... xen also fits into the 'online when all this shit went down' category...

xen, if you are a mason, you'd have been given a special character name. Care to share that with us?

no I think xen is clean, he is the one who supported AK and said he had trust if you notice got tonka said Xen why do you trust AK before he vigilante killed him. you (Incandenza) on the other hand appear to me very scummy. By asking for Xen's character name it is possible to out a power role. You talk about other people i.e cola being around when everything kicked off, but weren't you around too? you don't mention your name on the list you produced

1. xen already roleclaimed mason, so what's the harm in sharing his character name. Besides, I realize that xen trusted AK. You know who else trusts townies? mafia, because they're the ones that know who's scum and who isn't... so I'd like to know some more about xen, if you all please
2. of course I was around, and I don't blame you for putting me on a list of suspects
3. but you guys need to stop thinking that I'm scum just for having an immediate reaction and theory to go along with the events of today. Coming up with the Little John thing is not quite the scummy-lookin' stretch that you and FD are making it out to be

The selin/AK thing lends itself to two main hypotheses (assuming AK investigated him): selin is a godfather, or Aimless set him up... (I suppose there's a third possibility, that AK wasn't a sane cop, but it seems like that's information that would be been revealed upon his death)

[dominationnation]

guys you seem to be forgeting something. You are all yelling at selin for lyning but I think that he is something like a death miller. He doesnt even know what his role really is. I believe selin is completely inocent and was framed as was said before. I am also very confused by the whole days events so if someone could put up a chart of everything that happened today that would be great

[pancakemix]

Look, I've got a theory!

AK was the Sheriff of Nottingham, right? He may have had a special day power for today, like GT did. And that may have been to unmask one of the contestants. That contestant was, undoubtedly, Selin.

I think we should run with a policy of lynching all liars and Selin dies today. Thoughts?

[Aegnor]

I like pancakes theory. Let's get this over with

Vote Selin