pmchugh wrote:Reading back over the claims I actually think IB is unlikely to be mafia, perhaps cult though. Aage seems less genuine, his claim is lazy and is perhaps a last minute attempt to take down cult/townie since I was heaping so much pressure on IB anyway. I think it is notable that he did not counter claim until he was being voted quite heavily.
unvote for now.
Also IB I could respond as to what was scummy about your play, but I don't think now is the time for it.
He was prime suspect for being lynched and it was very strongly headed that way. Myself and other Town were forced to claim. It was then that I was counter claimed.
What is odd about Aaage and his claim is that he is less surprised and almost nonchalant about my claim of keymaker. But he is all over the fact that I claimed VT, that that is somehow more important the the fact I claimed his role.
Lets look at my history.
I am being not because of scummy play but because of:
1) My claim of VT, which has been a point of debate since the start of the game. Only certain people can be VT or someones role does not fit the flavor. I have recognized that since the start of the game.
2) The second reason I am being lynched is because of a numbers crunch. Someone puts a chart up with who has claimed and who has not. I don't understand how everyone who has claimed is clear especially with the acknowledgement that the Merv faction has no idea whatsoever if any of them have been recruited.
Understand this. With the counterclaim on me I can understand the suspicion. Normally I would take one for the team and just take the lynch. This game is different in that at this point of the game every body counts to counter Cult.
With Aaage not only was his counter claim weird in that he jumped on me claiming VT rather then me claiming his role, he also states he has not blocked anyone since he took over. As Town you will never know who you are blocking until they are dead so it is your job to block who you consider scum. As Mafia you know who is who so you block your ass off. the only reason I would think he did not block is because he can not and if he says he did and gives a list there is a very strong possibility he can be found out.
In conclusion.
I am relieved that some folks are at least looking at other possibilities and questioning Aage. If you guys cover all the bases and look at what is plausible and still lynch me...well fine. I'm just pissed at the moment that I am almost lynched because of my claim and charts based on who has claimed and who has not.
There are Cult out there who care only about lynching non cult and will do what they can to insure that. take your time to make a correct and rational decision.
