First you say this.
dagreatbroomhead wrote:wicked wrote:I have nothing to hide... I'm Andre Taylor, owner of the Rock Ridge Inn. Regular vanilla townie (nice term btw broomie!), which I'm finding a little anticlimatic after being mafia the last two games..lol. My inn was burned by the infected scum, so I'm pretty ed about that!

FOOL! Weather you are mafia or town, claiming without provocation is FOOLISH! Think about it, If you are a mafia, you can claim what you like, almost like covering your tracks. If you are town, you either A, narrow the scope of finding a power role or reveal yourself as a power role depending on what type of person you are, I don’t even want to talk about this right now, because it will turn into a WIFOM debate. (wine in front of me-watch the princess bride. Great movie) so in conclusion, foolish.
You are basically saying wicked was stupid.
dagreatbroomhead wrote:Machiavelli wrote:I dont know how saying our names will hlep but if we are putting it out there, I am Lawrence Scott Moret, a healthy townie.
again, this is the most pointless claim ever. Everyone will say they are town no matter what, and since there is no common theme(like a movie) names mean nothing.
Then when I post nearly as much info, you say it is meaningless. I agree that what I posted doesn’t help the town a lot, but it doesn’t hurt the town at all, so I don’t see why it’s a big deal. The more we talk, the more info we have.
dagreatbroomhead wrote: Yes, the spam makes it longer to read through, but does help catch mafia.
I completely agree with that quote.
dagreatbroomhead wrote: Okay, in regards to everyone who just posted their name and 2 sentences about their character. None of that is helpful. Seriously, for the future, that needs to stop.

How can you say that it isn’t helpful, when you had just said that even spam helps us catch mafia. I personally don’t even think this counts as spam.
And why would we ever need to stop posting anything?!?
Except for role claims (and direct mod quotes) I don’t think that anything should go unsaid.
dagreatbroomhead wrote:Machiavelli wrote:A good mafia member will not just jump on bandwagons. You have a good point.
A good towniewill not jump on bandwagons either.
Nice circular logic dude, that means no good player will ever bee the third or forth to vote. Impossible.
I always thought that bandwagoning was voting quickly, without hearing all the facts and without everyone getting to tell their side of the story. I have never heard of anyone considering it bandwagoning just for being the third person to vote. If you use my definition of bandwagoning in my quote, then it does make sense.