Terrain War Mafia ~ Continue game in Brood War Mafia

[Aimless]

I am pretty certain that mandalorian and aimless are mafia and if they are not mafia they must be masons or something.

Or, errr, you know, we just happen to agree that ranck turning up as a Battle Cruiser Pilot makes DN's claim look extremely suspicious. Not all players who agree with something are causally linked; indeed, mafia usually do their damnedest not to let a link like this be made.

[Anarkistsdream]

I am going to have to withhold my vote for now... I have a few small suspicions, but until I see things work out a bit more, I can't honestly vote with any confidence.

[nagerous]

these are a collection of quotes, it is quite messy but I am just using it as evidence as to why I have my suspicions over these players

So, Vote: Anarkistsdream. I don't suspect you, but as the bandwagon du jour I'd like to hear you give a defense, if only just to get things rolling today.

aimless jumped on anarkists quickly and before pyro55 very quickly



I was cross when domination wasn't lynched because I thought if he is lying about his townie role then we had clear leads over who was mafia

[6]dominationnation - aimless, got tonkaed, madalorian2298, nagerous, anarkistsdream, wisse

Note both aimless and mandalorian here agree that domination should be killed

Vote: IGS

Mainly for being one of those who failed to hammer yesterday.

Also, that it proved so hard to lynch DN might be an indication that he is in fact scum, but I'd rather target those who didn't vote yesterday.

I see what you mean, but I will stay stubbornly by voting DN.

vote dominationnation for the reasons that I mentioned yesterday.

this one is funny, scum debating over who to lynch

Okay, let's finish what we started yesterday.

Unvote

Vote: dominationnation

bringing up something that happened on the first day? all he did was slip up slightly by advocating no lynch and the only reason your voting him today is because no-one else has acted scummy, because no-one is scummy apart from you and your scum mates!!


I understand your point that its a mistake for mafia to tie in to each other and talk like that but I personally am not convinced. I wanted to lay a trap to see if one of you would defend the other and my trap worked. However, I am not going to press on this anymore and if we lynch domination today and he comes up scum I will drop all my accusations and with a heavy heart today I will vote domination but if he is town I wil have my eye on you guys

[dominationnation]

I like your theory nagerous but wont we save time lynchiung the scum if we go straight to the source UNVOTE (if needed) VOTE AIMLESS

[nagerous]

I would like to clarify the only reason I am voting domination because my views are purely theory and knowing his role and whether he is lying or not will help me work out what is going a lot clearer, as stated I haven't heard of starcraft so I am not sure how easy it would have been to forge a fake role or whether that is just mandalorian propaganda

[dominationnation]

I to have never heard of starcraft so I couldnt have just made up a role that happened to be a real townie role

[nagerous]

I guess unvote vote aimless I just hope the town trust me

[Aimless]

aimless jumped on anarkists quickly and before pyro55 very quickly

Yeah. I do that. It's kind of my mafia style.

As I recall, I jumped on someone on my very first post of my very first game of mafia ever.

I was cross when domination wasn't lynched because I thought if he is lying about his townie role then we had clear leads over who was mafia

Right. And this is exactly the same reason I think he should be lynched today. I still think he's lying about his townie role, and the bit with ranck only further reinforced my suspicions.

this one is funny, scum debating over who to lynch

Ha, ha. What would make it more funny is if we were both actually scum.

bringing up something that happened on the first day? all he did was slip up slightly by advocating no lynch and the only reason your voting him today is because no-one else has acted scummy, because no-one is scummy apart from you and your scum mates!!


I understand your point that its a mistake for mafia to tie in to each other and talk like that but I personally am not convinced. I wanted to lay a trap to see if one of you would defend the other and my trap worked. However, I am not going to press on this anymore and if we lynch domination today and he comes up scum I will drop all my accusations and with a heavy heart today I will vote domination but if he is town I wil have my eye on you guys

Okay, the trap thing is a good idea; however, you misplayed it a bit. When you attack someone in a game like this, they will naturally tend to defend themselves. Thus, if you attack two people you suspect are scum, a defense by one will tend to look like a defense of both, thus subjectively reinforcing the perception of a link where no such link exists. It's generally better to just focus your attacks against a single player, and see who else jumps out of the woodwork.

[nagerous]

nice defence my instinct still says you are scum though and I know you are notoriously hard to lynch when you are mafia, whilst domination appears to me just to be making silly mistakes. I feel I have said all I can on the issue and it is up to town to decide, whatever they decide I will vote either way because the worst thing in my view is a no lynch now because that just confuses things for the town further, especially with the merger coming soon.

[mandalorian2298]

First off here is a link for the kids who never played Starcraft.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starcraft I blame the educational policy of many nations who choose to teach children history, art and all the other uninportant stuff, but allow them to ignore the essential art of Computer Gaming.

Nagerus, why would spinwizard bother to give townies aditional names based on units, if he was going to name two roles after the same unit?

[Anarkistsdream]

Nagerus, why would spinwizard bother to give townies aditional names based on units, if he was going to name two roles after the same unit?

To differentiate the two and make all characters unique.

However, I still don't know if I think you and Aimless are linked, or both scum...

I DO, however, think one of you is.

[mandalorian2298]

Nagerus, why would spinwizard bother to give townies aditional names based on units, if he was going to name two roles after the same unit?

To differentiate the two and make all characters unique.

However, I still don't know if I think you and Aimless are linked, or both scum...

I DO, however, think one of you is.

You just said it: "To...make all characters unique. Therefore, he must have given each person a name of different unit!

[Puff]

Vote Count

[3]dominationnation - mandy, IGS, aimless

[2]aimless - dominationnation, nagerous

[1]fircoal - wisse

[4]Not Voting - Fircoal, spinwizard, senfive, anarkistsdream

6 to lynch

The day will end on Tuesday May 28 at 7:00 PM EST

[Puff]

bump

[Senfive]

How have I not been killed yet? I thought Submarining would have me lynched by now. jeshhhh what do I have to do to get lynched in this game?

[dominationnation]

umm and with that UNVOTE VOTE SENFIVE

[Puff]

Vote Count

[3]dominationnation - mandy, IGS, aimless

[1]aimless - nagerous

[1]senfive - dominationnation

[1]fircoal - wisse

[4]Not Voting - Fircoal, spinwizard, senfive, anarkistsdream

6 to lynch

The day will end on Tuesday May 28 at 7:00 PM EST

[Fircoal]

First off here is a link for the kids who never played Starcraft.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starcraft I blame the educational policy of many nations who choose to teach children history, art and all the other uninportant stuff, but allow them to ignore the essential art of Computer Gaming.

Nagerus, why would spinwizard bother to give townies aditional names based on units, if he was going to name two roles after the same unit?

It's not that, I'm budy playing Pokemon games, and such.

[Fircoal]

[quote="Senfive"]How have I not been killed yet? I thought Submarining would have me lynched by now. jeshhhh what do I have to do to get lynched in this game?[/quote

Push hard for a Mandy lynch and use the word "Nightkill." Worked for me.

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

[mandalorian2298]

*Spam*[/quote

*Spam* and then....

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

So, you think that ranck AND domination have the battle cruiser pilot role, but one was a pilot with a beard and the other has a mustache. The guy obviusly lied about his role. I know why his scum-buddie arent voting for him, but I just can't figure out what's wrong with you townies!

[Fircoal]

*Spam*[/quote

*Spam* and then....

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

So, you think that ranck AND domination have the battle cruiser pilot role, but one was a pilot with a beard and the other has a mustache. The guy obviusly lied about his role. I know why his scum-buddie arent voting for him, but I just can't figure out what's wrong with you townies!

No they could be different people. I haven't played the game before, but you have, so is there only one battle pilot?

[mandalorian2298]

*Spam*[/quote

*Spam* and then....

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

So, you think that ranck AND domination have the battle cruiser pilot role, but one was a pilot with a beard and the other has a mustache. The guy obviusly lied about his role. I know why his scum-buddie arent voting for him, but I just can't figure out what's wrong with you townies!

No they could be different people. I haven't played the game before, but you have, so is there only one battle pilot?

Battle Cruiser is a unit name (the pilots aren't named in the game, although some characters sometime act as "super-units". But, domination would have given us the character's name, were that the case.)

[nagerous]

*Spam*[/quote

*Spam* and then....

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

So, you think that ranck AND domination have the battle cruiser pilot role, but one was a pilot with a beard and the other has a mustache. The guy obviusly lied about his role. I know why his scum-buddie arent voting for him, but I just can't figure out what's wrong with you townies!

No they could be different people. I haven't played the game before, but you have, so is there only one battle pilot?

Battle Cruiser is a unit name (the pilots aren't named in the game, although some characters sometime act as "super-units". But, domination would have given us the character's name, were that the case.)

pilots are named in this game my friend

[Fircoal]

*Spam*[/quote

*Spam* and then....

Also DN I think that you're scummy and there is a point that all roles are unique, but how can we tell if it's the roles, or the desprictions.

So, you think that ranck AND domination have the battle cruiser pilot role, but one was a pilot with a beard and the other has a mustache. The guy obviusly lied about his role. I know why his scum-buddie arent voting for him, but I just can't figure out what's wrong with you townies!

No they could be different people. I haven't played the game before, but you have, so is there only one battle pilot?

Battle Cruiser is a unit name (the pilots aren't named in the game, although some characters sometime act as "super-units". But, domination would have given us the character's name, were that the case.)

DN, what's your character name then?

[Wisse]

vote:dominationnation