autoload's 19 Player Mafia Game #1 --- Days 2-3 --

[vgmmaster]

jus th i would point ot vgmmaster has been browsing this forum for a while and hasn't posted anything

I'm a slow reader so 16 pages can take a while for me.

Player who have yet to give a single vote in 2 (game) days:

Fircoal, Incandenza, vgmmaster, HoussamTheGreat

I would like to know why you 4 have yet to vote anyone?

Well, the main reason I didn't vote for Nyvek is I didn't believe in the whole thing that was going on with him. I wasn't too sure on what to make of the whole situation, and near the end of the day, it looked like people were bandwagoning against her just to get day 1 over with. (38 pages). Plus, I'm not that aggressive of a player and try to look things over logically. Unless I see something that immediately puts up a red flag, I'm not a big voter.

MB i can't believe you're not on board with this. it's so obvious.

MB is not with you supercram because he is mafia also, he is trying to protect RD.

this is why he pointed out my mistake, look at his posts he knows exactly what the mafia would do here, he even told us this is wy he is doing the opposite

I'm not exactly sure on everybody's experience level (new to mafia games concerning this forum), but I'm suspecting Roger Dodger is more or less a newb/noob and is melting under pressure. For supercram, he may be protecting him but it's hard to make out in my opinion. (Reading 16+ pages makes you not remember everything). If they are both mafia (hypothetically speaking), would it be better to vote out Supercram? I'm getting the vibe that he is at least partially more experienced then Roger Dodger is.

I cant let this slide with us being down 4 players already.

fIrst up i AM certain wicked wAs not killeD by the mafia last night, the Other kill was. CanT say why yet but i knOw this is tRue.

which means we have a vigilante, one thing NO MORE STABS IN THE DARK WHOEVER YOU ARE.

So you're a Doctor as well? I call bullshit. The Doc has already been killed. If we're right about the Mafia being people who have played with Mach and Wicked before, then they would spot this like I did, a mile away. So that tells me that you weren't too scared to post, why, because you are mafia. You also did it, so that if/when the town starts to believe that you might be mafia, you point them to that post and make us believe you are the second doctor, and will go along with stuff that you say here.

And the last time somebody used code here in a mafia game, it turned out that player was mafia (AK). Only would mafia uses code in a game in my opinion.

unvote RD for now

vote Trestain

MB, you haven't done anything to prove scummy, but this post does strike me as odd. Is there any reason you bolded certain letters in this post? Although I do trust you and I think you're trying your best to lynch a mafia member, I wonder if this post is you trying to get somebody lynched. And if he is the doctor (and you're mafia), then you'd want him dead, which explains why you (or was it somebody else?) who keeps saying he'll be dead today/tonight/tomorrow.

My new list of possible mafia

XenHu
SenFive
Trestain
RD

and possibly, RK

I've seen this done before, and while I don't know if P Gizzle is or isn't mafia, I do suspect him making this list. I remember when someone else did this (in another game), that person was actually found out to be mafia when he was later lynched that day. Not a strong suspicion here, but it is possible I think.

--------------

So far, I have a few suspicions and I'll go ahead and mention them.

Pinky FOS Trestain and RD: One (or both) of you are lying when you mention that you are both doctors. While I believe there is a possibility of a nurse existing in this game, it's obvious one of you are lying if not both of you.

Very Small FOS Master Bush: The only reason I have any suspicion against you is the fact that I believe you manipulated Trestain's post at your convience. If you can prove to me that I'm wrong in my accusation, please do so.

More Small FOS P Gizzle: Not much to go off here, but making a list of who you think is mafia seems a little scummy to me.

TOS Supercram: For protecting one of the "claimed" doctors.

I'm unsure on who to vote for though as there are several canidates who appear to be a good lynch or even worthwhile on an investigation.

[trestain]

right im off for the night see you all tomorrow.

[Wisse]

right im off for the night see you all tomorrow.

i go to sleep too

(no we are not multi's )

[Senfive]

Why is everyone going for Roger dodger? So she is noob and keeps changing her vote. This is what the Mafia are laughing at us for. I am going to Repost who is the most Scummy. Please don't ignore it like you all have.

No Lynch was the best option on day 1. No one listened to me. Doc dead at our hands, another townie dead, and the Red Unknown Wicked. We gave them 2 townies at the price of no mafia. How on earth did we get anywhere by throwing darts?

i was thinkin the same thing MB, but the way you've helped us, you are almost definitely town....but i've been wrong before....


who's left with experience? plus, remember our theories, MB?

maybe Xen Hu and Senfive, i haven't seen Senfive post in forever

SEnfive, and Xenhu don't seem to post a lot, and when Senfive does, it seems to be junk.

LOAD OF CRAP!!! I go to sleep at 2 in the afternoon. This thread goes up 5 and half hours later. I wake up at 1 in the morning and find 10 pages to read. Thats Scummy to you. why do you want to know who is experinced or not? You know as well as I know that I have been trying to root out scum. Thanks RK for the seeing that. I now trust you.

k. that's weird that they would kill Wicked, and Ob(whatever) because they were both very suspicious....

I argee

ok, i'm fairly sure that most of the Nyvek bandwagon was not mafia, but hey, i could be wrong....i know im not...

WEll I think that they should be watched over. Mainly the 2-5th voters.

right now RK looks suspicious...

DA!

i think i know what the locked roles are. Backups....

in andy's last game there were backups incase the front runners were killed....that's what i think the locked roles are.

I don't think so, in Auto's last game he said who had a locked role.

Why only the 2-5th voters? is that because your partner in crime is 7th on the list?

10 Nyvek (Master Bush, Wisse, Kokunai, trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle, supercram, wicked)

My new list of possible mafia

XenHu
SenFive
Trestain
RD

and possibly, RK

Pointing fingers with your Scum buddy I see.

MB, why the early vote?

I have my reasons.

Here are votes 4-8 for Ny:

trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle

I bolded P Gizzle cause of all the finger pointing he has done tonight. But I dont think he's mafia.....yet.

MB calls you out.

ok, sorry for the finger pointing, im just eager to see what you guys think...

i liked the idea of using lists and logic to find mafia...in the last game i was in, i randomly guessed....

You quickly backpedal and get lost in the discusssion.

I dont think cram or gizzle are mafia, cause no mafia would come out pointing their finger so much.

I have to disagree with you MB.

Nyvek bangwagon(Master Bush, Wisse, Kokunai, trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle, supercram, Houssam)(I know I'm missing some)

someone in the bolded group needs to get lynched today. there may be other mafia, but one (or more) of these people is DEFINITELY mafia.

I argee, but WIsse, should definteley be added to the list. MAybe, rev too.

i now *almost* trust fircoal. because i know i am right, that there is mafia in there, and fircoal is not trying to steer the discussion away from it.

Incorrect Cram. Fircoal wanted only the 2-5th names so P Gizzle wasn't looked at. I don't trust either.

No worries cram....

And, you know, not to pass the they-haven't-posted-in-awhile baton, but there are a few people on those various lists (kokukai and senfive spring to mind, tho I'm sure there are at least a couple others) that still haven't contributed.

But given the constraints of biology and economics, I'm willing to wait a few hours for everyone to wake up/get out of school/knock off work/amble home from the methadone clinic/whatever... just to make sure we get it right.

Again sorry for being a mortal and needing to sleep sometime.

Oh and FOS Fircoal and P Gizzle

QFE

VOTE P Gizzle

[XenHu]

WTF?

What do you have on P.Gizzle?

Way to throw everyone off!

FOS: Senfive


-X

[XenHu]

Also notice how he(senfive) quickly dissapears from fourm...




-X

[supercram]

[quote="Roger Dodger"]oh and btw. i know i said i wouldn't but,
VOTE MASTERBUSH.

REASON. JUST BECAUSE.
quote]


scum.

[supercram]

FOS SenFive for blissfully ignoring what's going on right now

[vgmmaster]

Also notice how he(senfive) quickly dissapears from fourm...




-X

If he's scum, perhaps he's afraid suspicion is coming his way?

[for dummies]

Fos: Senfive this seems like a desperate mafia trying to save his sinking buddy

[Incandenza]

So, senfive, if I'm following you, you're thinking it's p gizzle and fircoal backing each other up as mafia.

That may be, but given the current circumstances, I don't think either of those dogs are gonna hunt until we sort out the RD/trestain thing...

And btw, I'd be obliged if instead of just reposting a long-ass post, you could whip up a quick summary with a couple QFEs. This thread is already long enough.

Not trying to be a dick. fwiw, I'm halfway convinced that you're townie, but just a bit too overzealous and random in your posting.

[XenHu]

If he's scum, perhaps he's afraid suspicion is coming his way?

Perhaps..





-X

[Incandenza]

Also notice how he(senfive) quickly dissapears from fourm...




-X

If he's scum, perhaps he's afraid suspicion is coming his way?

Perhaps, but there hasn't been much heat at all on senfive this round, and if he's really going to go off so full-throttle against PG and fircoal, either he's the noobiest mafia of all time (his less-than-sterling performance in the last game would potentially bear this out), or he's just dead convinced of his reasoning.

Or he's mafia and both RD and trestain are as well, and he's trying to draw the heat off them both. That's barely remotely possible, and probably not worth following up.

I understand people FOSing him, though.

[XenHu]

Right All,

I'm off for the night, have to go to work...

See you in the morning..


-X

[P Gizzle]

sorry guys, i had to go to school, so yeah.....


ok, i dunno what Senfive has against me, but now im sure it's RD......if not, it's trestrain....


VOTE ROGER DODGER

[Master Bush]

I cant let this slide with us being down 4 players already.

fIrst up i AM certain wicked wAs not killeD by the mafia last night, the Other kill was. CanT say why yet but i knOw this is tRue.

which means we have a vigilante, one thing NO MORE STABS IN THE DARK WHOEVER YOU ARE.

So you're a Doctor as well? I call bullshit. The Doc has already been killed. If we're right about the Mafia being people who have played with Mach and Wicked before, then they would spot this like I did, a mile away. So that tells me that you weren't too scared to post, why, because you are mafia. You also did it, so that if/when the town starts to believe that you might be mafia, you point them to that post and make us believe you are the second doctor, and will go along with stuff that you say here.

And the last time somebody used code here in a mafia game, it turned out that player was mafia (AK). Only would mafia uses code in a game in my opinion.

unvote RD for now

vote Trestain

MB, you haven't done anything to prove scummy, but this post does strike me as odd. Is there any reason you bolded certain letters in this post? Although I do trust you and I think you're trying your best to lynch a mafia member, I wonder if this post is you trying to get somebody lynched. And if he is the doctor (and you're mafia), then you'd want him dead, which explains why you (or was it somebody else?) who keeps saying he'll be dead today/tonight/tomorrow.

Very Small FOS Master Bush: The only reason I have any suspicion against you is the fact that I believe you manipulated Trestain's post at your convience. If you can prove to me that I'm wrong in my accusation, please do so.

Take a look at the letters I bolded, and tell me what they have in common?

[reverend_kyle]

oh and btw. i know i said i wouldn't but,
VOTE MASTERBUSH.

REASON. JUST BECAUSE.
quote]


scum.

this makes me

vote rodger dodger just because.

[vgmmaster]

I cant let this slide with us being down 4 players already.

fIrst up i AM certain wicked wAs not killeD by the mafia last night, the Other kill was. CanT say why yet but i knOw this is tRue.

which means we have a vigilante, one thing NO MORE STABS IN THE DARK WHOEVER YOU ARE.

So you're a Doctor as well? I call bullshit. The Doc has already been killed. If we're right about the Mafia being people who have played with Mach and Wicked before, then they would spot this like I did, a mile away. So that tells me that you weren't too scared to post, why, because you are mafia. You also did it, so that if/when the town starts to believe that you might be mafia, you point them to that post and make us believe you are the second doctor, and will go along with stuff that you say here.

And the last time somebody used code here in a mafia game, it turned out that player was mafia (AK). Only would mafia uses code in a game in my opinion.

unvote RD for now

vote Trestain

MB, you haven't done anything to prove scummy, but this post does strike me as odd. Is there any reason you bolded certain letters in this post? Although I do trust you and I think you're trying your best to lynch a mafia member, I wonder if this post is you trying to get somebody lynched. And if he is the doctor (and you're mafia), then you'd want him dead, which explains why you (or was it somebody else?) who keeps saying he'll be dead today/tonight/tomorrow.

Very Small FOS Master Bush: The only reason I have any suspicion against you is the fact that I believe you manipulated Trestain's post at your convience. If you can prove to me that I'm wrong in my accusation, please do so.

Take a look at the letters I bolded, and tell me what they have in common?

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

[Master Bush]

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

That has to be a joke right? The TOR part? And you cant see why those letters were bolded by me? They are all uppercase letters. He was using code to tell people "I AM A DOCTOR"

[supercram]

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

LMFAO. OMFGWTFBBQ!!!11!!1

whew. that was fun. anyway, i'm pretty sure that rodger dodger is dead. i haven't counted the votes though.

[Master Bush]

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

LMFAO. OMFGWTFBBQ!!!11!!1

whew. that was fun. anyway, i'm pretty sure that rodger dodger is dead. i haven't counted the votes though.

She has 7 votes.

[Incandenza]

anyway, i'm pretty sure that rodger dodger is dead. i haven't counted the votes though.

I think the vote count is only at 7... one more.

But I've been rereading the thread, and MB was up in RD's shit pretty much from the beginning, and only wavered when trestain's 'code' popped up. And at this point, I rather trust MB, as he (and cram) have been contributing some of the smarter posts.

If we got this one wrong too, I'm going to jump off a bridge.

VOTE ROGER DODGER

So that's it. (fingers crossed)

The question now is: if there is a vigilante (not speculating who, of course), who should they go after?

[supercram]

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

LMFAO. OMFGWTFBBQ!!!11!!1

whew. that was fun. anyway, i'm pretty sure that rodger dodger is dead. i haven't counted the votes though.

She has 7 votes.

ok so she's not dead. and still you aren't voting. that makes me nervous.

unvote roger dodger

[vgmmaster]

I understand that the letters spell "I AM A DOC TOR" (Unsure on what TOR stands for). I'm just mentioning that something seems a little too "odd" with the bolding for a lack of better termanology.

That has to be a joke right? The TOR part? And you cant see why those letters were bolded by me? They are all uppercase letters. He was using code to tell people "I AM A DOCTOR"

At this moment in time, I really wish that there was an emote showing me slapping myself for having the worst blonde moment ever. However, there is none, so this emote will have to do.



I was using the abbreviated term DOC and for some reason, I didn't connect the TOR part in make the word doctor.

Anyways, I did check, and I saw his original post on page 10. I apologize for not believing you concerning his post Master Bush. That was my mistake (and my blonde moment).

[supercram]

The question now is: if there is a vigilante (not speculating who, of course), who should they go after?

go after someone who didn't vote for RD. if she is mafia. or else just hang out and wait a bit for more info.

if we're wrong on this, just lynch me because i obviously suck at mafia.