Metsfanmax wrote:I didn't get the impression that he was a night cop. When I was quoting the post in which I made the mistake, he was only referred to as a "cop" and so when I had the idea about forcing him to investigate I momentarily forgot he was a day cop. Notice that my correction was posted literally in the same minute, so there's no way to argue that I didn't understand he was a day cop.
you thought his investigation power was still unused. When Strike erroneously tells you he already investigated Benga, you take it at face value.
I didn't take it at face value. My post, "Wait, then I missed that. Which post is this?", was skeptical of his claim, but I wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt in case either I did somehow miss DY saying he investigated Benga, or something else strange was happening. Note that it's precisely
because I asked about this that we found out for sure that DY investigated IB and not Benga. I've been pushing hard the whole time to clear up this shit with DoomYoshi instead of obfuscate it, so your argument that I'm trying to distract people is absurd.
Did I say distracting? No, I said distracted (though both are kinda true
). The fact you changed your take quickly (and it's not like people didn't set you straight first) is irrelevant when it's quite obvious you did some heavy skimming managing not once, not twice but three times to not read Doom's post. This one, btw:
DoomYoshi wrote:I am the day-cop, in the post where I quoted IB, I wrote that he is innocent. Because people tend to miss things like that, I directed you to that post in my next one. When I flipped day-cop, someone was supposed to look for the clues. Clearly, nobody would have been able to.
Remind me why people are voting for me again? Oh, right, no reason at all.
vote flores
Now, if you claim to have him on ignore list, I would understand, but it's gonna be tough to play mafia like that
You say clear shit up, I say reluctant to unvote the claimed cop AND trying to direct his investigation which seems way more scummy than anything else. I mean, this post:
Metsfanmax wrote:Iron Butterfly wrote:His claim seems solid.
In a 15 player game with a possible third party group, it's not nearly enough to clear him as town. He could be using a fakeclaim name.
Screams of bad intent to me. Did you even check Frederick Abberline's claim before making this post? Or is it as Neb said, disbelieve first, think later?
Newguy, the fact your argument makes more sense than any of Mets' defense speaks by itself. Yes, it might be bad to get another town role out but so far only Doom's relevant and he claimed himself without much sense. I'd rather have another claim because it could be a fake one, rather than wait for a cop to spoonfeed town. That's not how town can hope to catch a godfather-type scum, for instance... (the thought just occured to me that it would be pretty funny for Jack to be investigative-proof
).
Strike, I feel you came full circle in your post and made it clearer than I why we can't rely only on cop investigations lol
