Seinfeld Mafia! Town Wins! Game Over!

by **The Weird One** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:15 pm

unvote vote ga7

by **CrabNebula** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:24 pm

unvote vote ga7

I just wiki'd the Doorman episode and you are right, he was being an all around asshat to Jerry.

by **ga7** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:39 pm

Look, vig is no huge loss for town but still, you're lynching me on a silly assumption. On the context of throwing out etc, it makes sense to me that this character is a vig. Besides if you're gonna lynch all the characters that have been a prick to Jerry at one time or another I'm sure we'll be screwed at the end with such a misuse of this investigative power :roll:

Btw, why was Nes' character survivor eh? Putting setting above anything works in some games, but I'm pretty sure this one won't be so easy.

by **nagerous** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:55 pm

unvote vote firth until he claims.

by **nagerous** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 2:56 pm

sorry ignore that last post, I made a mistake unvote

by **dustn64** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 3:14 pm

ga7 wrote:-I got roleblocked but Dustn didn't tell me about it (Dustn, could we know how you handle the roleblocks please?)

I will only say you got roleblocked if I need to give you info. such as, a cop investigated someone I will send the "you have been roleblocked." I could tell everyone that has a night action that they have been roleblocked if you would like me to, not a big problem.

by **nagerous** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 3:16 pm

nah I think the way you're doing it now is best.

by **ga7** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 3:42 pm

Thanks for the precision. Either way is fine since Firth claimed right away, which was probably not the best idea but no reason to distrust him on that.

by **Hitman079** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 4:13 pm

i don't think i'm ready to jump on this bandwagon yet

by **The Weird One** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 4:46 pm

aww. . .c'mon. It's fun.

by **dustn64** on Sun Dec 09, 2007 8:12 pm

Vote Count

Ga7- Jnd, Cena, Firth, TWO, Crab (5)

LoVo- Kiwi (1)

red = most votes

14 Alive! 8 To Lynch! Post!

by **lord voldemort** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 7:27 am

yo sorry bout the inactivity, been having some net probs..
i think its more than likely gaga is 3rd party, so im thinking sk. i dont see the doorman being town as he isnt in the 'in crowd'

having said that voate gag

by **nagerous** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 7:41 am

It was a normal day in New York. Jerry, George, and Elaine were leaving the coffee shop and heading back to Jerry’s apartment to be met by Kramer at the Door. “The keys Jerry, the keys!” He said franticly. Jerry eventually found out what had happened; that someone stole all of the keys to the building from everyone. With the building in chaos they decided that they only way to keep the mafia out of their apartments was to kick someone out everyday until the culprits were caught. Some thought this as a way to kick out the people they hated and forget about the thieves, but some were destined on finding the mafia for punishment.

A lot of this is so far been based on what characters you guys think are scum and what ones are "in the crowd". The doorman may well not be part of the main group but is he really going to be a member of the mafia that have stolen all the keys. Sure he could be the SK but I don't think he would target firth for the night-one kill if he was the SK especially since this is someone he said he was suspicious of.

by **CrabNebula** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 7:51 am

nagerous wrote:It was a normal day in New York. Jerry, George, and Elaine were leaving the coffee shop and heading back to Jerry’s apartment to be met by Kramer at the Door. “The keys Jerry, the keys!” He said franticly. Jerry eventually found out what had happened; that someone stole all of the keys to the building from everyone. With the building in chaos they decided that they only way to keep the mafia out of their apartments was to kick someone out everyday until the culprits were caught. Some thought this as a way to kick out the people they hated and forget about the thieves, but some were destined on finding the mafia for punishment.

A lot of this is so far been based on what characters you guys think are scum and what ones are "in the crowd". The doorman may well not be part of the main group but is he really going to be a member of the mafia that have stolen all the keys. Sure he could be the SK but I don't think he would target firth for the night-one kill if he was the SK especially since this is someone he said he was suspicious of.

I think many agree here that he cannot be mafia. But he claimed to be town-big which means he is lying and the only reason he would do it is if he was SK.

by **CrabNebula** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 7:51 am

An interesting thing that just occured to me is, he is the Doorman, thus besides the apartment door always. It must be very easy for him to steal the keys, no?

by **lord voldemort** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 7:57 am

CrabNebula wrote:An interesting thing that just occured to me is, he is the Doorman, thus besides the apartment door always. It must be very easy for him to steal the keys, no?

good point, my vote is staying on frenchie, i just dont beleive the pro-town role

by **nagerous** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 8:40 am

Hmmm... I'm just unsure about voting the claimed vig. Looks like there are precious few other leads at the moment unfortunately.

by **nagerous** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 8:44 am

This is a strictly opinionated post

Pro-towners:

Fireedud
Crab
Jnd
Firth
Nag
Hitman

Everyone else I don't know, Ga7 might well be SK and he would probs be a good lynch today. I am also suspicious of cena for vote hopping and bandwagoning.

by **ga7** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 12:00 pm

Crab, that logic is weird. The doorman being a building employee, it would be amazingly stupid for him to steal the keys to start with

As for me being potential SK, why is there no vig counterclaim then? I highly doubt there would be 2 vigs in this game.

by **lord voldemort** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 12:08 pm

ga7 wrote:Crab, that logic is weird. The doorman being a building employee, it would be amazingly stupid for him to steal the keys to start with As for me being potential SK, why is there no vig counterclaim then? I highly doubt there would be 2 vigs in this game.

good point about that, whichmakes me think u may be vig...

unvote for now

by **CrabNebula** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:00 pm

ga7 wrote:Crab, that logic is weird. The doorman being a building employee, it would be amazingly stupid for him to steal the keys to start with As for me being potential SK, why is there no vig counterclaim then? I highly doubt there would be 2 vigs in this game.

But wouldn't he steal it to annoy Jerry and put him into trouble?

Now that I think about it, a Vig/Sk doesn't fit into the theme. People are not killed here, but thrown out of the apartment. As such, one person cannot throw out another one alone. Something's not right with the current situation, I can sense it...

by **CrabNebula** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:02 pm

I'll keep the vote until someone comes up with something better.

by **ga7** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:10 pm

ga7 wrote:I have the ability to lock people out of the building (ie NK).

That's as close to a direct PM quote as I can get, so... I guess there's a little consistency problem if you really want to dig that deep into the setting, but doesn't mean much to me, I think the powers make sense. Vig is such a classic role, I don't really see why it wouldn't be included either way...
From what I understood about the character (didn't bother checking it) he annoyed Jerry. Fine, but then he could be Jerry's lyncher, and I think we already dealt with that

Will reread later.

by **dustn64** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:10 pm

Vote Count

Ga7- Jnd, Cena, Firth, TWO, Crab (5)

LoVo- Kiwi (1)

red = most votes

14 Alive! 8 To Lynch! Post! Go! Now!

by **cena-rules** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:16 pm

nagerous wrote:This is a strictly opinionated post

Pro-towners:

Fireedud
Crab
Jnd
Firth
Nag
Hitman

Everyone else I don't know, Ga7 might well be SK and he would probs be a good lynch today. I am also suspicious of cena for vote hopping and bandwagoning.

woah I changed my vote from josh to someone who had a role named to him which could be bad. Bandwagoning? I got fastposted first time and this time I had a reason

Seinfeld Mafia! Town Wins! Game Over!

Would you like a deadline?

Who is online