Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[jonty125]

Hippo, don't be like jonty and quote every single post... quote the ones that matter, because that was terrible...

Thanks for the compliment

Anyhow vote clever. For skimming, doom asked him to claim and he didn't. And for claiming on a whim, but I'm interested to here his full claim

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Omg I blocked u to find out if u were telling the truth that is why
It doesn't matter if you got info cause u could have been lieing about it! this was the only way to see if u were telling the truth in my eyes

And if i was mafia why would i come out and save you ...as its already been said "i could sit back and laugh while town kills you"

I am the ship cook role blocker

[jonty125]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

[ghostly447]

Mind telling me why, if clever were Mafia, he would come out and say he got roleblocked? Please tell me that. How about you guys think further into his actions. As Mafia he would have laughed his ass off while you guys hung our tracker. He came out to prove Isaiah's innocence. So therefore I must say that you two are taking this too far. He is the roleblocker and I would bet myself on that.

[jonty125]

Mind telling me why, if clever were Mafia, he would come out and say he got roleblocked? Please tell me that. How about you guys think further into his actions. As Mafia he would have laughed his ass off while you guys hung our tracker. He came out to prove Isaiah's innocence. So therefore I must say that you two are taking this too far. He is the roleblocker and I would bet myself on that.

Well clever didn't get roleblocked. But lets say this was the scenario: isaiah is mafia goon and claimed tracker, he needs to verify his actions so if another goon called himself a roleblocker then that covers it. Also if isaiah is town or mafia, he could be using it as a smokescreen to get the real roleblocker to step forward.

[ghostly447]

Mind telling me why, if clever were Mafia, he would come out and say he got roleblocked? Please tell me that. How about you guys think further into his actions. As Mafia he would have laughed his ass off while you guys hung our tracker. He came out to prove Isaiah's innocence. So therefore I must say that you two are taking this too far. He is the roleblocker and I would bet myself on that.

Well clever didn't get roleblocked. But lets say this was the scenario: isaiah is mafia goon and claimed tracker, he needs to verify his actions so if another goon called himself a roleblocker then that covers it. Also if isaiah is town or mafia, he could be using it as a smokescreen to get the real roleblocker to step forward.

I meant he roleblocked Isaiah. And if there is another roleblocker then they need to come forward. A roleblocker isn't all that important. Now here is the thing. Give another roleblocker 24 hours to step up. They aren't that important.. and I can promise that no Mafia will counterclaim. They have enough losses and wouldn't have any reason to get 1 person for 1 Mafia. I asked the roleblocker to come out to protect Isaiah. That in itself clears Isaiah and clever both. Isaiah because he was in fact roleblocked. And clever because he siding fact come out extremely fast. In this I feel I am also cleared from thought because there is no way there are 3 Mafia left. So therefore I feel no one is lying and we are wasting our time arguing amongst each other.

[jonty125]

Mind telling me why, if clever were Mafia, he would come out and say he got roleblocked? Please tell me that. How about you guys think further into his actions. As Mafia he would have laughed his ass off while you guys hung our tracker. He came out to prove Isaiah's innocence. So therefore I must say that you two are taking this too far. He is the roleblocker and I would bet myself on that.

Well clever didn't get roleblocked. But lets say this was the scenario: isaiah is mafia goon and claimed tracker, he needs to verify his actions so if another goon called himself a roleblocker then that covers it. Also if isaiah is town or mafia, he could be using it as a smokescreen to get the real roleblocker to step forward.

I meant he roleblocked Isaiah. And if there is another roleblocker then they need to come forward. A roleblocker isn't all that important. Now here is the thing. Give another roleblocker 24 hours to step up. They aren't that important.. and I can promise that no Mafia will counterclaim. They have enough losses and wouldn't have any reason to get 1 person for 1 Mafia. I asked the roleblocker to come out to protect Isaiah. That in itself clears Isaiah and clever both. Isaiah because he was in fact roleblocked. And clever because he siding fact come out extremely fast. In this I feel I am also cleared from thought because there is no way there are 3 Mafia left. So therefore I feel no one is lying and we are wasting our time arguing amongst each other.

I would disagree with a roleblocker is not important.

[ghostly447]

I would say it's less important than say 2 people. 1 claimed roleblocker and 1 claimed tracker. So therefore I say it is right to have the roleblocker, if there is another, come out and say so. That way we can rap this up and kill clever. Therefore if he is telling the truth then town won't counterclaim. If they are Mafia they would be foolish to counterclaim. Lets rap this case up in my opinion. We have been well off so far. Lets keep it up.

[SPARTACUS1974]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

if his food is like my wife's he could block anyone lol
will read through and post

[jonty125]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

if his food is like my wife's he could block anyone lol
will read through and post

[SPARTACUS1974]

Mind telling me why, if clever were Mafia, he would come out and say he got roleblocked? Please tell me that. How about you guys think further into his actions. As Mafia he would have laughed his ass off while you guys hung our tracker. He came out to prove Isaiah's innocence. So therefore I must say that you two are taking this too far. He is the roleblocker and I would bet myself on that.

Well clever didn't get roleblocked. But lets say this was the scenario: isaiah is mafia goon and claimed tracker, he needs to verify his actions so if another goon called himself a roleblocker then that covers it. Also if isaiah is town or mafia, he could be using it as a smokescreen to get the real roleblocker to step forward.

I meant he roleblocked Isaiah. And if there is another roleblocker then they need to come forward. A roleblocker isn't all that important. Now here is the thing. Give another roleblocker 24 hours to step up. They aren't that important.. and I can promise that no Mafia will counterclaim. They have enough losses and wouldn't have any reason to get 1 person for 1 Mafia. I asked the roleblocker to come out to protect Isaiah. That in itself clears Isaiah and clever both. Isaiah because he was in fact roleblocked. And clever because he siding fact come out extremely fast. In this I feel I am also cleared from thought because there is no way there are 3 Mafia left. So therefore I feel no one is lying and we are wasting our time arguing amongst each other.

ok i have to stand up and bring order to this ship.
i also have a similar role i dont want to fully claim but i can role block as well as other things that can help town ,,i am bringing this to light due to if i was forced to claim at a later date it would look a bit scummy as i did not mention it now.

as my role is not called role blocker i believe that clever is telling the truth.

[jonty125]

ok i have to stand up and bring order to this ship.
i also have a similar role i dont want to fully claim but i can role block as well as other things that can help town ,,i am bringing this to light due to if i was forced to claim at a later date it would look a bit scummy as i did not mention it now.

as my role is not called role blocker i believe that clever is telling the truth.

See, I wouldn't of seen as it scummy if you'd kept your mouth shut. But I have a feeling I know your role but in case mafia haven't picked it up I'll keep quiet.

[DoomYoshi]

Clever, the problem with your plan is that people know when they are role locked. Big n00b mistake.

I believe clever for now. Basically, I don't think he is capable of the complex WFOM scenario that jonty proposed on his own. However, others in the mafia might have given it to him. Who is capable of such a complex plan that also includes such risk? I can't think of any player who is both new enough to take the plan and experienced enough to formulate it and then communicate it.

I still don't believe that clears Isaiah in the slightest though.

[Nebuchadnezer]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

Really? Are we going to make an argument that CLEVER is lying because "the ship's cook CAN'T be a role blocker." This is the type of argument that gets me the most upset in these games.

FOS jonty125 for even throwing this comment out there.

[jonty125]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

Really? Are we going to make an argument that CLEVER is lying because "the ship's cook CAN'T be a role blocker." This is the type of argument that gets me the most upset in these games.

FOS jonty125 for even throwing this comment out there.

I never said he wasn't but I was trying to find the link. I was hoping he would summarize the link from his role PM (like there is in mine)

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Clever, the problem with your plan is that people know when they are role locked. Big n00b mistake.

I believe clever for now. Basically, I don't think he is capable of the complex WFOM scenario that jonty proposed on his own. However, others in the mafia might have given it to him. Who is capable of such a complex plan that also includes such risk? I can't think of any player who is both new enough to take the plan and experienced enough to formulate it and then communicate it.

I still don't believe that clears Isaiah in the slightest though.

wait people know when they have been blocked?? Like even if there plain ole town?

[DoomYoshi]

Clever, the problem with your plan is that people know when they are role locked. Big n00b mistake.

I believe clever for now. Basically, I don't think he is capable of the complex WFOM scenario that jonty proposed on his own. However, others in the mafia might have given it to him. Who is capable of such a complex plan that also includes such risk? I can't think of any player who is both new enough to take the plan and experienced enough to formulate it and then communicate it.

I still don't believe that clears Isaiah in the slightest though.

wait people know when they have been blocked?? Like even if there plain ole town?

It depends on mod, but usually investigative roles ALWAYS know if they were roleblocked. Sometimes all roles are told unless they don't have an action.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Dang i didn't know that
Well i mean he claimed tracker and if he was any other power role he would have claimed that and not tracker or at least got counter claimed

i apologize i didn't know he was told he is role blocked

[DoomYoshi]

Dang i didn't know that
Well i mean he claimed tracker and if he was any other power role he would have claimed that and not tracker or at least got counter claimed

i apologize i didn't know he was told he is role blocked

That is usually something you should ask the mod: will people know if I roleblock them?

At the very worst, you won't get an answer.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

:'( sorry everyone

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Hmm, I'm interested to see how a ship's cook is roleblocker. I can understand the cabin boy being tracker

Really? Are we going to make an argument that CLEVER is lying because "the ship's cook CAN'T be a role blocker." This is the type of argument that gets me the most upset in these games.

FOS jonty125 for even throwing this comment out there.

I never said he wasn't but I was trying to find the link. I was hoping he would summarize the link from his role PM (like there is in mine)

ya I put powder in there food causing them to sleep through the night

[kiwi3]

Doom Yoshi wrote,

that wall of posts was less useful than you thought it was.

I too, am interested in this though. I had a minor note from day 1, and this just reminded me of it: kiwi, after bring called out for inactivity, seems to focus on calling out others for inactivity.

Not enough for a vote yet, I would just like some explanation for this.

If you sitting back and taking it all in is ok, why is it a problem when others do it kiwi?

Also, any particular reason you focused on Teegee?

.

in response to this. yes I am taking all this in. and actually trying to figure everything out. sorry for the laying low but it is hard to know who to believe and who not to...pretty confusing. I was floored by those that were found to be mafia.

[DoomYoshi]

Doom Yoshi wrote,

that wall of posts was less useful than you thought it was.

I too, am interested in this though. I had a minor note from day 1, and this just reminded me of it: kiwi, after bring called out for inactivity, seems to focus on calling out others for inactivity.

Not enough for a vote yet, I would just like some explanation for this.

If you sitting back and taking it all in is ok, why is it a problem when others do it kiwi?

Also, any particular reason you focused on Teegee?

.

in response to this. yes I am taking all this in. and actually trying to figure everything out. sorry for the laying low but it is hard to know who to believe and who not to...pretty confusing. I was floored by those that were found to be mafia.

That only half answers my question. Why did you focus on Teegee?

[Victor Sullivan]

Not really sure what to make of all this...

-Sully

[kiwi3]

DoomYoshi on Wed Mar 07, 2012 9:58 pm

kiwi3 wrote:Doom Yoshi wrote,

that wall of posts was less useful than you thought it was.

I too, am interested in this though. I had a minor note from day 1, and this just reminded me of it: kiwi, after bring called out for inactivity, seems to focus on calling out others for inactivity.

Not enough for a vote yet, I would just like some explanation for this.

If you sitting back and taking it all in is ok, why is it a problem when others do it kiwi?

Also, any particular reason you focused on Teegee?

.

in response to this. yes I am taking all this in. and actually trying to figure everything out. sorry for the laying low but it is hard to know who to believe and who not to...pretty confusing. I was floored by those that were found to be mafia.



That only half answers my question. Why did you focus on Teegee?

i wasn't fingerpointing at TeeGee for any particular reason. I believe I stated the name only because someone was calling out those who had suddenly quit being attentive in the game. I believe the prod was to encourage more activity.