Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[Aimless]

so where are we now? Is the archery competition on the third real day or third game day?

The Archery competition will be held on the third game day. I'll make a big to-do about it when the time comes.

[Ehriggn]

so where are we now? Is the archery competition on the third real day or third game day?

The Archery competition will be held on the third game day. I'll make a big to-do about it when the time comes.

I'm really curious about how and why mandy is trying to get killed before day 3. he said somewhere it would benifit the town, but how? I'm not sure if I believe him.
a jester maybe?

[The1exile]

I have a theory. But I don't want to share it in case the mafia haven't thought of it.

I hope the town doesn't target him if I'm right, though.

[wicked]

I have a theory. But I don't want to share it in case the mafia haven't thought of it.

I hope the town doesn't target him if I'm right, though.

wow. insightful.

[XenHu]

I have a theory. But I don't want to share it in case the mafia haven't thought of it.

I hope the town doesn't target him if I'm right, though.

wow. insightful.

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Being that evidently some people are too dense or else too lazy to see what I said earlier I'll condense it again. I don't know who the heck anyone is in this game other than myself being that the moderator has saw fit to not give me insight to anything. As such, I was willing to go with someone else's vote on the condition that if they were wrong that I was going to vote to lynch them on the 2nd day. Mandi at one point claimed he was about 80% sure so I voted that guy, but when better evidence came up against an actual merry men from historical context that vote was one that I saw as better. At worst, it would prove that just b/c someone in historical context was a merry men isn't in this game while at best it would knock off the rhymes and a real life merry men. While the poet may have admitted to whom that he is, it is not like he had a plausible argument against being that guy. As such, I refuse to change my vote and if some of you do in fact choose to lynch me in your stupidity than at least I know that I went down fighting for the greater good of the crown as my part is a nobody not attatched to the scum of the merry men.

[XenHu]

Being that evidently some people are too dense or else too lazy to see what I said earlier I'll condense it again. I don't know who the heck anyone is in this game other than myself being that the moderator has saw fit to not give me insight to anything. As such, I was willing to go with someone else's vote on the condition that if they were wrong that I was going to vote to lynch them on the 2nd day. Mandi at one point claimed he was about 80% sure so I voted that guy, but when better evidence came up against an actual merry men from historical context that vote was one that I saw as better. At worst, it would prove that just b/c someone in historical context was a merry men isn't in this game while at best it would knock off the rhymes and a real life merry men. While the poet may have admitted to whom that he is, it is not like he had a plausible argument against being that guy. As such, I refuse to change my vote and if some of you do in fact choose to lynch me in your stupidity than at least I know that I went down fighting for the greater good of the crown as my part is a nobody not attatched to the scum of the merry men.

Riiight. Once I got through your wonderfully well-written defense, I realized what a load of bullshit this is.



From what I can gather, you're basically giving an excuse to bandwagon.

Would you care to explain this?:

don't know who the heck anyone is in this game other than myself being that the moderator has saw fit to not give me insight to anything. As such, I was willing to go with someone else's vote on the condition that if they were wrong that I was going to vote to lynch them on the 2nd day.

It sounds like you are blaming Aimless for not thinking.

Vote: LSU Tiger Josh

I'm not buying it.

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Nope, I just said Aimless saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are. To me the evidence that Mandi presented is clear and since you're voting on me i'm placing a FOS on everyone that has voted me Xenhu and Ehriggn

[XenHu]

Nope, I just said Aimless saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are. To me the evidence that Mandi presented is clear and since you're voting on me i'm placing a FOS on everyone that has voted me Xenhu and Ehriggn

What do you mean 'Saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are'? Either your claiming cop, in which case you'd be lying, because you wouldn't have had the chance to investigate anyone, or, Aimless made a new role.

Unless....

I'll get back to you with the rest of my thought. I want to hear your answer first.

-X

[Aegnor]

Nope, I just said Aimless saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are. To me the evidence that Mandi presented is clear and since you're voting on me i'm placing a FOS on everyone that has voted me Xenhu and Ehriggn

Not the brightest move LSU. In mafia games you should try to defend your case, rather than attacking those who present cases against you. It makes you look scummy.

[wicked]

Nope, I just said Aimless saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are.

So who are the scum then? Got names? Why would Aim give you insight?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

It was misworded. Aimless saw fit on not telling me who any individual characters are. He did answer my question on if the merry men are mafia so that is all I know. If I die than it's no big loss although it would be a wasted lynch even if it is a nonpower role.

[wicked]

Have you ever played mafia before LSU?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

yep

[LSU Tiger Josh]

As far as claiming cop goes, I wish then I would know at least if someone was a townie noble, or scum instead on a random guess with the condition of lynching the person starting the vote if they are wrong once they admit they are sure.

[XenHu]

It was misworded. Aimless saw fit on not telling me who any individual characters are. He did answer my question on if the merry men are mafia so that is all I know. If I die than it's no big loss although it would be a wasted lynch even if it is a nonpower role.

WTF?!

Of course he answered your question. It was the same question everyone was asking!

I'd like to make two things clear, since apparently they weren't. One, yes, the Merry Men are the mafia, although, as always, your win condition trumps all other considerations. Two, remember that this is a game first and foremost, and accurate to the legends second.

My vote stands until you can make a defense that is slightly more coherent then those previously stated.

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I had asked it way before he posted it in here. It even had some people thinking that I was trying to confuse them by callign the merry men scum. Vote how you wish, but as such I will continue to FOS XENHU

[XenHu]

I had asked it way before he posted it in here. It even had some people thinking that I was trying to confuse them by callign the merry men scum. Vote how you wish, but as such I will continue to FOS XENHU

And now, instead of defending yourself(in a way that makes sense), you continue to point fingers at other people who accuse you.

That's not exactly the brightest thing to do.



-X

[Aegnor]

I had asked it way before he posted it in here. It even had some people thinking that I was trying to confuse them by callign the merry men scum. Vote how you wish, but as such I will continue to FOS XENHU

You were given the chance to defend yourself but you still stick with your OMGUS attitude.

FOS LSU

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I have nothing to defend. If a person is dumb enough to waste their vote on me then the town and nobles deserve to lose the game. Mandi has given the best evidence so far on the game, but yet people are too dense to vote on a real life merry men and would rather kill off a nobody that isn't in the merry men. The only ones that should be voting on me are members of the merry men being that I'm not with them. Nobles keep a FOS on anyone that votes here as these people would be considered enemies of the crown.

[got tonkaed]

alright now to the incredible skimming and submarining tonka post.....

So i missed about 10 pages, and this what ive felt like ive found since. Essentially the simplest scenario is that mandy is a noble and Aegnor is one of the merry men. Its also quite likely that Wicked is amongst the scum, because of the pretty good observation that, the only time wicked seems to not get anything, is when she is defending someone else, especially when its not usually rocket science. Selin fwiw could be either way, but he will probably live to fight another day. I think no matter what line we take, it would be easy to prove mandos alignment by lynching one of the people who are aligned opposite right now. Now i like lynching LSU for being an idiot as much as the next guy, dont get me wrong.

Having said that, Aegnor has looked bad in the last ten pages. Worse than auto did (which was kinda surprising). Basically aegnor for what ive seen has done very little if anything to respond to mandos accusations other than, hey thats not very nice that you accused me sir. If mando is proven right (at least in the short term) then he sets up his timetable for day 3. If he is proven incorrect then he probably gets nightkilled. I think considering the dynamic of this game so far, mando needs to be out there running the show. He has unearthed the majority of the content in the game thus far right or wrong.

Therefore im going to vote today in order to determine his alignment.

unvote Vote Aegnor as he has been the most scummy and this line sets us up best i feel to gain information going into day 2

[wicked]

please find me one example of me "not getting something" b/c I was scum. I seriously doubt one exists. and that's certainly not the case here. you try trying to keep up with a game going rapid-speed when you have a 101+ fever and see how intelligent YOU sound. the point I "didn't get" was why being a poet made him automatically scum in mandy's eyes when that would be way too fucking obvious and when we weren't sure the game was set up exactly as the story anyway. I'm always looking for other possibilities and explanations. Mandy's in a mad rush to lynch a power role... why wouldn't I question that?

[mandalorian2298]

please find me one example of me "not getting something" b/c I was scum. I seriously doubt one exists. and that's certainly not the case here. you try trying to keep up with a game going rapid-speed when you have a 101+ fever and see how intelligent YOU sound. the point I "didn't get" was why being a poet made him automatically scum in mandy's eyes when that would be way too fucking obvious and when we weren't sure the game was set up exactly as the story anyway. I'm always looking for other possibilities and explanations. Mandy's in a mad rush to lynch a power role... why wouldn't I question that?

Lol Wicked you are asking for an example of "you not getting something b/c you were scum"? Well, there is a certain game in wich tonka (pro-town), Aimless, you and I (all scum) died and in wich you (while you defended Aimless) were incredibly slow in understanding tonka's role claim. The fact that you are sick is the only reason why I didn't take your not understanding as a PROOF that you are scum, but it did make me a bit suspicius.

[wicked]

in reference to another game (so as not to confuse)...

oh I understood the role claim, and never claimed to "not get it".

[mandalorian2298]

in reference to another game (so as not to confuse)...

oh I understood the role claim, and never claimed to "not get it".

Wanna quote?