Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[derfderf34]

ill be gone all weekend... bye...

[kwanton]

Bye Joker!......erm....I mean derf.....


FOS:Derf for leaving and being joker (lol just the second reason really)

[cmckinney]

hey guys, sorry I couldn't get to a computer sooner.

The person I hid with last night was Serbia.

And the reason why i didn't reveal who I was gonna hid with last night was because the mafia would have known who I was gonna hide with, and kill them. Thus killing me.

I also find it very weird that the mafia groups have no way to communicate to each other (or at least thats what i got from looking over the thread) Whats the point of having multiple people in a mafia if they don't really do anything?

[nagerous]

Bye Joker!......erm....I mean derf.....


FOS:Derf for leaving and being joker (lol just the second reason really)

is this true?

[mandalorian2298]

Bye Joker!......erm....I mean derf.....


FOS:Derf for leaving and being joker (lol just the second reason really)

is this true?

OMG, I totally forgot to do this.

Nagerus, are pro-Gotham?

[cmckinney]

I am intersted in the daybreak scene (very nice btw Talapus ) where I am found in my cell having some sort of panic attack.

Question 1: Why was I hiding in my cell at 2 in the morning. I have a feeling that I might have been role-blocked. It's the only explanation as to why i was in my cell.

Question 2: Did the mafia target me, becuase ther was that crazy looking guy outside my cell, which happened to be the only locked.

[cmckinney]

Question 3: was the reason my cell remained locked the doctor's way of protecting me form beign killed?

[nagerous]

Bye Joker!......erm....I mean derf.....


FOS:Derf for leaving and being joker (lol just the second reason really)

is this true?

OMG, I totally forgot to do this.

Nagerus, are pro-Gotham?

YEAH

[nagerous]

and regarding your questions cmc, you will just have to speculate there is not going to be answers given I expect.

[gethine]

i guess there is a chance to get two scummy players today - if serbia who was acting a little scummy on the first day gets killed then we would know that cmc was lying about being a hider, being pro-gotham or where he hid. does this scan?

[kwanton]

i guess there is a chance to get two scummy players today - if serbia who was acting a little scummy on the first day gets killed then we would know that cmc was lying about being a hider, being pro-gotham or where he hid. does this scan?

No. There is no guarantee for anything. That's what I was trying to say. There are many ways to undermine CMK's ability. Even if he's telling the truth about his role we have to decide whether he is more of a liability than a help.

[kwanton]

Just a little clarification on my last post:

The hider role is supposed to be hidden(makes sense no?) Now that CMK is out in the open scum can easily manipulate us if we assume that CMK can definitively tell us someone's role.

[Koesen]

vote Kroesen for Freudian reasons, namely his 'murky' recognizing of the Pinguin. It looks to me like an unnecessary attempt to distance himself from the Pinguin role.

Is that all you have to go on? Just because I am not a Batman-geek who can instantly identify every character in every show ever made, I'm mafia?

And what does Freud have to do with it, anyway? Are you saying the Pinguin is my mother?

You're just trying to get even for the fishing trip game

[Koesen]

By the way, work and family life will keep me away from the computer for most of the weekend.

[The1exile]

anti gotham hider?

if he doesn't know who the mafia are already, then that'll be a bitch of a role.

It wouldn't be any more difficult than a pro-town hider...

Uh?

protown hider gets to pick people to hide behind and generally 3/5ths or more of the group will be town.

Scum hider gets maybe 30% of the people being scum that he can hide behind. = much more difficult role.

[mandalorian2298]

vote Kroesen for Freudian reasons, namely his 'murky' recognizing of the Pinguin. It looks to me like an unnecessary attempt to distance himself from the Pinguin role.

Is that all you have to go on? Just because I am not a Batman-geek who can instantly identify every character in every show ever made, I'm mafia?

And what does Freud have to do with it, anyway? Are you saying the Pinguin is my mother?

You're just trying to get even for the fishing trip game

1. I didn't get lynched in the Fishing Trip game. The Mafia Gods intervened by making the Mod go A-wall.

2. When I said Freudian, I was refering to the way people often reveal what they are sub-conciusly trying to hide by joking about it. (or at least that's how I remeber it. Highschool was a while ago. )

3. You DID identify Penguin. But you did so in the way that scream: "I am not sure if this guy is in the game, since I CERTANLY don't have that role! "

4. Yes, that is all I have to go on.

[The1exile]

2. When I said Freudian, I was refering to the way people often reveal what they are sub-conciusly trying to hide by joking about it. (or at least that's how I remeber it. Highschool was a while ago. )

Freudian slip is when you say one thing but mean your mother.

[jnd94]

I think that CMK's whole roleclaim is a bunch of bullshit, for many reasons. (1 He wasnt directly under suspicion when he did it. In fact, Im pretty sure I cleared his name, then he roleclaimed. That is somewhat odd. (2 Im pretty sure he is mafia and is just hiding behind his pals. Why are we believing every thing he says, or even believe if he even is a hider? He is a noob, but just becasue he pulls out a fancy role like that doesnty mean he actually has it. In NV3, if you remember, I was a noob and i said I was a mason, and ppl believed me becuase they didnt think i knew these roles yet.

FOS CMK

[MountainLion]

Wow, hell of a game Talapus. I love how you wrote last night's activities.

=D>
Very nice post, Talapus. I can see you put a lot of effort into that, and it would of taken a long time.

I just read through the whole thing, and I'm still suspicious of Moutainlion.
So..
Vote: Mountainlion. Basically your last post (Not really sure, as I can't remember as reading the whole thread was a mild mind-boggling) was a vote, with no reason. Why? All votes should have a reason, and I think you were just bandwagoning. Also, you almost, or made equal, to vote-jumps than Serbia did.

A couple of players (freezie too I believe) voted for me because you say I voted for no reason, but that's not true. I had a reason which I posted (on the same page, page 22) not a few posts earlier. I simply didn't feel the need to repeat myself. Here it is:

please, somebody tell me what i said to receive 9 votes.

I told you why I voted you, you're kind of bothering me. And you haven't given me any reason not to vote you. And I have no idea who's who here, being just a townie, so anything we get is going to be helpful down the road. And I didnt' bandwagon on you, I was one of the first votes on you.

ok, Serbia is looking somewhat suspicious to me from this post.

Bold-I dont understand this, because he really hasnt done much, only has defended himself.

Italics He has defended himself pretty well, even though we havent really even given him any reasons why he looks scummy. Skim much?

Blue-Why roleclaim? We were waiting for cmkinney's roleclaim, and that one sort of is like the Pokemon game where Wisse roleclaimed after me. It doesnt help, and probably will only hurt you.

O, and Im not sure if i did already, but Unvote, FOS Serbia

JND you make a pretty good point here. If you look at Serbia's post carefully he sounds defensive even though he's not the one with votes on him.

Now if you didn't see that I would say you were skimming...did you skim?

I also had a vote on me on Day 1 for suggesting the hider say who they hide with before the night begins. I can only say that I'm not 100% familiar with how the Hider role works, so I made a mistake. I've been told I'm a good mafia player, but it doesn't mean I'm experienced. I've only completed 3 games where I was in them for most of the game.

I had a busy day at work. I'll post again when I get home in a couple hours...

[kwanton]

I think that CMK's whole roleclaim is a bunch of bullshit, for many reasons. (1 He wasnt directly under suspicion when he did it. In fact, Im pretty sure I cleared his name, then he roleclaimed. That is somewhat odd. (2 Im pretty sure he is mafia and is just hiding behind his pals. Why are we believing every thing he says, or even believe if he even is a hider? He is a noob, but just becasue he pulls out a fancy role like that doesnty mean he actually has it. In NV3, if you remember, I was a noob and i said I was a mason, and ppl believed me becuase they didnt think i knew these roles yet.

FOS CMK

Exactly. There are too many x factors when it comes to CMK's role. If he is telling the truth then it's not enough to merit a lynch by any means but if he's lying then the townies are royally screwed. Everyone just measure his usefullness against how badly he can screw us over.

[Talapus]

Vote Count:

(1)MountainLion – skittles!
(1)gethine - Anarkistsdream
(1)Serbia – jnd94
(2)Koesen – derfderf34, mandalorian2298


DEADLINE FOR DAY 2 IS TUESDAY JUNE 19TH AT 5AM PST!

[Talapus]

I'm glad you guys enjoy the story so far...trying my best

As for all the theories, they are good. I won't give any info on characters you see in photos though. Just realize, if I'm using it in the game...it's probably for a reason ! Carry on....

[MountainLion]

Reading the Talapus Night Log, I came up with some thoughts:

1. Did gimpy roleblock CMC? He "used the keys obtained by one of the guards to enter the security station."

2. Did a doctor protect CMC, keeping The Joker from killing him?

3. CMC seemed to get a lot of attention. It appears a number of power roles targeted him, and it was in a way that would suggest CMC is Pro-Gotham...mainly because the Joker wants to kill him.

4. Could The Joker and Riddler be scum buddies? The Riddler blocks him while The Joker goes for the kill? Could they be scum buddies with Serbia? Protecting Serbia by roleblocking and trying to kill CMC to keep him from hiding with Serbia, who after what happened on Day 1, was the most likely player that CMC would hide with?

5. Does the "concealed weapon" the Riddler reached for have any significance?

6. Why was Gordon wet when it did not rain? Maybe it was Mr. Freeze? Did he kill Gordon with an icicle (white light?) and then it melted during the 6 hours he was dead?

I tend to agree with Anark's view of this game. It's closest to what Talapus has told us...there are a lot of loonies in the Asylum, some connected, some not.

I like Mandy's Freudian reasons.

FOS kwanton because he did two things that could be scummy:

There is no guarantee for anything. That's what I was trying to say. There are many ways to undermine CMK's ability. Even if he's telling the truth about his role we have to decide whether he is more of a liability than a help.

1. With this post he suggests that we can't necessarily trust CMC. Look at #3 in my thoughts list above. I think CMC is Pro-Gotham and kwanton is possibly trying to get him lynched.

Bye Joker!......erm....I mean derf.....


FOS:Derf for leaving and being joker (lol just the second reason really)

2. With this one he suggests derf is The Joker. I really doubt The Joker would have such a small role. The Joker should have a strong (probably strongest) Anti-Gotham role. He tried to kill CMC last night, right? This game takes place in an Asylum. I tend to think that derf is simply a nobody nut job with no powers or significance. Maybe kwanton is The Joker or is trying to "protect" the Joker by trying to make people think derf is the Joker.

[MountainLion]

Also, you almost, or made equal, to vote-jumps than Serbia did.

Forgot about this part. I voted a lot simply because I was trying to get everyone involved. I should try to vote less though, I agree, but it was Day 1 and we have a lot of players, 25.

[Skoffin]

First I'd just like to say awesome job on the night scene Talapus. Even if it was a bit long =P
And how do you lot make so many pages of posts so quickly? I'm going through it all now

Vote: Gethine
for being Welsh

*smacks you* The welsh are awesome.