Re-Inquisition Mafia - Heretics win!

[wicked]

I think we need to call an end to this day with no more lynchings.... and just pray we survive the night with only one kill.

[nagerous]

I think we need to call an end to this day with no more lynchings.... and just pray we survive the night with only one kill.

I disagree, n8 is already lynched. Xen is -1. I find it strange that you suddenly say we should make no more lynches. We will just end up repeating the spectacle the next day. Xen being lynched will provide the town more information in regards to voting patterns and him being alive is hardly going to bring more benefits to the town. I will give him time to roleclaim but if he doesn't respond soon I will hammer.

[ga7]

Nah, Wickie always said there should be only one lynch. The thing is, another lynch is the right move only if one of them are scum. Tons of vote info isn't really a good enough reason for lynching both IMO. But it could be justified if XC pops up again and doesn't claim.

[Syzygy]

I realize this statement could land me in a pot of boiling water... but I might be inclined to trust wicked, autoload, Koesen and n8freeman more than anyone else because of their votes on Mandalorian.

Yes, mafia can communicate at night and decide to target one of their number to avoid suspicion. But, seeing as this is day one, they haven't had a chance to do so yet.

[wicked]

I think we need to call an end to this day with no more lynchings.... and just pray we survive the night with only one kill.

I disagree, n8 is already lynched. Xen is -1. I find it strange that you suddenly say we should make no more lynches. We will just end up repeating the spectacle the next day. Xen being lynched will provide the town more information in regards to voting patterns and him being alive is hardly going to bring more benefits to the town. I will give him time to roleclaim but if he doesn't respond soon I will hammer.

Bull-fuckin-shit. No suddenly about it, I've said from the beginning one lynch per day. Yes, we repeat this crap "tomorrow"... it's a mafia game, we will repeat this every day until the end. I know you've played this game before, so why are you acting so stupid? Just b/c he's at lynch-1 is NO reason to lynch him. Get a clue, or you're next to go.

No one but mafia knows crap on day one, the more voting records we have on different days, the more info we'll have. Anyone who's pushing to lynch Xen too is either scum or should have their head examined.

[wicked]

I will give him time to roleclaim but if he doesn't respond soon I will hammer.

QFS (quoted for scumminess.. or stupidity)

[autoload]

Get a clue, or you're next to go.

I love when people say this because 90% of the time it never happens.

[Koesen]

I realize this statement could land me in a pot of boiling water... but I might be inclined to trust wicked, autoload, Koesen and n8freeman more than anyone else because of their votes on Mandalorian.

Yes, mafia can communicate at night and decide to target one of their number to avoid suspicion. But, seeing as this is day one, they haven't had a chance to do so yet.

Don't worry, I won't boil you for it

As for people complaining I denounce too many people:

1) I already explained I see multiple lynchings as a special strength for town in this game. I accept that on Day One, we may need to be more careful, but I disagree with Wucket's position that we should never lynch more than one. That would be giving up town's special strength, while you can be damn sure mafia is not going to give up theirs.

2) Serbia denounced as many people as I did. I'm not saying he is scum, but I don't see why multiple denunciations are only suspicious if they come from me.

3) Three of the people I denounced were never in any serious danger of dying. The fourth one is still alive.

4) I didn't denounce anybody after the two surprise deaths. In fact, so far nobody died because of me.

[wicked]

Multiple lynchings only give us "special strength" if we KNOW WHO THE SCUM ARE... else we're just killing off ourselves. Sure there may be instances where it'll help us to get rid of two likely scum in one day, but NOT DAY ONE.

[Koesen]

No need for the capitals, Wucket. I already said I accept that on Day One we need to be more careful. You, however, repeatedly said you never want to go beyond one lynch a day.

[wicked]

I didn't think I had said never, but as we rarely KNOW who more than one scum are at a time, other than getting lucky hits with power roles, I doubt we'd ever need to do more than one a day. If N8 is town, we're down 4 townies in one day, not good. the fact that he didnt' roleclaim shows he either doesn't care, doesn't know how to play or is scum.

[Koesen]

Three, not four, unless XenCobra died without me noticing it.

I do agree it's strange neither of them roleclaimed at lynch -1. I would have, but then I'm a noob

[ga7]

I realize this statement could land me in a pot of boiling water... but I might be inclined to trust wicked, autoload, Koesen and n8freeman more than anyone else because of their votes on Mandalorian.

Yes, mafia can communicate at night and decide to target one of their number to avoid suspicion. But, seeing as this is day one, they haven't had a chance to do so yet.

But Mandy wasn't scum?? WTF?
FOS people posting after and not pointing that out, maybe 'cause it supposedly clears them with BS

[Koesen]

I didn't think I had said never

I've specifically said let's take it slow and only denounce one person a day.

[wicked]

exactly, I didn't say "only ever do one a day"... quit harping over the little details sheesh.

[Koesen]

I'm merely pointing out a contradiction. "only one person a day" means only one person a day. Not "only one person today and tomorrow we'll see what happens".

[Syzygy]

I realize this statement could land me in a pot of boiling water... but I might be inclined to trust wicked, autoload, Koesen and n8freeman more than anyone else because of their votes on Mandalorian.

Yes, mafia can communicate at night and decide to target one of their number to avoid suspicion. But, seeing as this is day one, they haven't had a chance to do so yet.

But Mandy wasn't scum?? WTF?
FOS people posting after and not pointing that out, maybe 'cause it supposedly clears them with BS

Erm... yeah. Ignore me.

[autoload]

No need for the capitals, Wucket. I already said I accept that on Day One we need to be more careful. You, however, repeatedly said you never want to go beyond one lynch a day.

I already found out about Kose's dislike of CAPITALS.

That said I am happy with who we denounced and my vote goes to the denounce no more people today camp.

[autoload]

I realize this statement could land me in a pot of boiling water... but I might be inclined to trust wicked, autoload, Koesen and n8freeman more than anyone else because of their votes on Mandalorian.

Yes, mafia can communicate at night and decide to target one of their number to avoid suspicion. But, seeing as this is day one, they haven't had a chance to do so yet.

But Mandy wasn't scum?? WTF?
FOS people posting after and not pointing that out, maybe 'cause it supposedly clears them with BS

I thought the same thing, but I was so confused by the message I didn't know what to say.

[wicked]

I already found out about Kose's dislike of CAPITALS.

Yeah I also get the impression he's pretty anal about his name too, eh KOZY?

[n8freeman]

ya got me

how many games do u have to play to not be a noob?

im in pokemon mafia, was in batman, rorf mafia game i was in, also i play mafia all the time IRL


also i saved the towns ass in batman mafia by killing a cult recruiter day four, when they became cult. and then i killed the other cult

i single handedly saved town from a cult menace, noobish mistake right?

[kwanton]

It doesn't matter how many games you've played. It's how well your playing. In this game you were acting like a noob so people called you a noob. It's just that people usually gain experience by playing more games. Hell, I still consider myself a noob. My strategy is close my eyes, type random shit, and hope it makes sense

[wicked]

N8, why didn't you claim???

And that goes for Xen too... someone still might get an itchy finger and denounce you Xen... I'd be in here trying to save my butt if I were you.

[willis]

n8, It was mainly the fact that you mainly posted after people called you out that made me think you were scum.


Yay, I was right for once

[Koesen]

ya got me

Is that an admission of guilt?