Here's my updated chummy-to-scummy list with reasons and questions that you are encouraged to answer directly and with as much factual detail as possible:
joshzam: I'm Town. Obvious.
fusibaseball: He killed a Psycho Killer on N1. And I trust him. I'd like to know what he did on N2.
i-andrei: Asks good questions, shares info, voted halrob, and was framed by halrob. Mafia wouldn't try to frame Mafia. Not even halrob.
Ragian: Trusts all the people I trust and asks tough questions. Has proven himself an ally.
degaston: Good scumhunter with a good voting record.
Darin44: Voted halrob early. Says both his N1 and N2 actions revealed nothing that everyone doesn't already know, but I'd like to know exactly what that is! The coded message apparently fingers him as scum.
Dunk90: Erratic play, not sharing any info. Why do you think JMac sent you a message? What do you know about Dukasaur?
cdbridges: I hate his silence, but he did soft claim Defense Attorney.
TheJMac: Had some good points on D2 but has completely disappeared today. Voting after the halrob hammer is scummy.
pershy: Soft-claimed Hypnotist, but may be a Mesmer. Or he's lying and orchestrated the play with scumbuddy Dukasaur. Irrationally defends Pepe all the time. All. The. time.
General Bax: Never votes. Said that he chose not to perform an action on N1 without justification, and the information he learned N2 was already out in the thread. I'd like to know exactly what that is!
Maxleod: Many open questions. Says Pixar was not alone on N1 but hasn't offered any details. Did you perform a night action on Pixar N1? If so, what was your action? What was your N2 action? Hasn't provided Town with any useful info.
*Pixar*: Talking too much has caught himself in a web of lies. Claimed to be a Ghost that can send messages to people AND silence them if he is visited at night. Oh, and he can't be night killed. Sounds like multiple roles to me. Is he covering for some cats? Also claims to have not read his role. Lied about silencing people before admitting to it. Claims to send messages to people who cannot prove it because they are dead or silenced. Except he claims to have sent a D3 message to Dukasaur and yet not once does he ask Dukasaur to verify this! They even had a completely unrelated conversation afterwards and Pixar never asked him to verify his claim. And the whole thing about "23 have been dropped off, 24 remain alive" proving that he is a ghost rubbed me the wrong way because ghosts are not alive! He's obviously obfuscating.
Dukasaur: Didn't vote on D2 or D3 at all. Apparently trusts JMac absolutely, but for no apparent reason. Too many fishy connections.
actorday: Are you a Messenger of some sort? You were caught trying to send "Message 1" to Razor's wall and you refuse to respond to repeated questions about this. I think you're the Spy and were caught out.
PepeAtila: Flat-out refused to vote halrob on D2. This was after doing nothing on D1. And it has been noted that pershy is mysteriously defending him every chance he gets.
DukeHazzard: On D2, claimed to learn "Nothing I didn't already know" from his N1 action, but offered no details. This sounds like you learned something from N1. Town will not win without your details. But worse, on D3 he said, "I'm 0/2 on my night actions". So, did you learn something N1 or not? You're both sending mixed messages and providing zero details at the same time. Looks like fog to me.
I also believe that the Mod is offering MANY hints to us (and probably upsetting Mafia), though it's currently hard to tell which messages/notes are from players and which ones are coming directly from the Mod. There may have been mentions of Con Men, Cats, Painters, Anarchists, and Eavesdropper.
So, I'm happy to vote for Bax even if he's not the absolute bottom of my list. But I'd like people to respond to my post first.
"
