The Thing TOWN WINS!

[Votanic]

Interesting! Well, if you don't know who I think is The Thing, then you haven't really been paying attention.

---

I just woke up and am on my way back from the wedding with a massive head. When the wee bairn is tugged in tonight, I'll get my head around this. I have a lot to say.

Still waiting... a full day later. Must have been some party.

[Ragian]

You need to stop skimming. I'm getting annoyed with the passive aggressive voice. You're not a child. You can wait.

[swang918]

I'm doubting Sonic again and I'm not sure if it's with good reason, so I'm just laying it out here.

D1, Sonic doesn't hammer Dega. Gets some shit for it because Tonic was all for uniting but wasnt willing to vote for dega.
D2, Tonic hammers Ragian. Still wants to unite town but:

Im not playing defensive. What you see is what you get. Nothing to hide.

BT me or BT Traf or BT whoever you want.

Saying we need to be united is counter productive it seems.

I don't have a problem with you wanting town to be united. Cool. Easy thing to say but it's true. Just remind me, who were the hold outs on the Dega BT day 1? I seem to remember a very active player whose User name starts with S being a prominent one. It feels to me that you more want town to be united with you than just wanting town to be united.

Is Town!Tonic overreacting to this to fix his behaviour, or is Scum!Tonic just 'uniting town' while drinking and explicitly saying in the tick mafia that you shouldnt drink & mafia?

I also dont like how he isnt pushing me for my post towards him, but I've mentioned that before.

Why is it scummy for sonic to not push you? Sonic does a lot of things but omgusing has not been one of them. With the recent exception of votanic.

Also where in the tick did he say you shouldn't drink and mafia?

[Extreme Ways]

I'm doubting Sonic again and I'm not sure if it's with good reason, so I'm just laying it out here.

D1, Sonic doesn't hammer Dega. Gets some shit for it because Tonic was all for uniting but wasnt willing to vote for dega.
D2, Tonic hammers Ragian. Still wants to unite town but:

Im not playing defensive. What you see is what you get. Nothing to hide.

BT me or BT Traf or BT whoever you want.

Saying we need to be united is counter productive it seems.

I don't have a problem with you wanting town to be united. Cool. Easy thing to say but it's true. Just remind me, who were the hold outs on the Dega BT day 1? I seem to remember a very active player whose User name starts with S being a prominent one. It feels to me that you more want town to be united with you than just wanting town to be united.

Is Town!Tonic overreacting to this to fix his behaviour, or is Scum!Tonic just 'uniting town' while drinking and explicitly saying in the tick mafia that you shouldnt drink & mafia?

I also dont like how he isnt pushing me for my post towards him, but I've mentioned that before.

Why is it scummy for sonic to not push you? Sonic does a lot of things but omgusing has not been one of them. With the recent exception of votanic.

Also where in the tick did he say you shouldn't drink and mafia?

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=240040&p=5299937&hilit=drunk+drink#p5299937

I feel like Sonic should push me because Sonic says I could've stopped him at any time because apparently I was online all evening. I wasn't in the thread. Either he's lying about me being active, or I'm lying about my activity. Best case he is assuming I would have been around and using it as a defense tactic.

I find it weird that he ignores that.

[Votanic]

You need to stop skimming. I'm getting annoyed with the passive aggressive voice. You're not a child. You can wait.

I'm the one being passive-aggressive? Me?

Your negative BT is the only real news in town.
So, I'm waiting (not skimming) for you to make your official announcement. We are all waiting.

...and yeah, if you're announcement is just going to be that I'm the Thing because I talked about the flavor of the game, then I'll say it again, your off on the wrong track, and that is not helping town.

In other news: Sonic is continuing to be a source of largely self-made controversy. I'm glad to see some other players taking the lead on that, for a change.

[swang918]

I'm doubting Sonic again and I'm not sure if it's with good reason, so I'm just laying it out here.

D1, Sonic doesn't hammer Dega. Gets some shit for it because Tonic was all for uniting but wasnt willing to vote for dega.
D2, Tonic hammers Ragian. Still wants to unite town but:

Im not playing defensive. What you see is what you get. Nothing to hide.

BT me or BT Traf or BT whoever you want.

Saying we need to be united is counter productive it seems.

I don't have a problem with you wanting town to be united. Cool. Easy thing to say but it's true. Just remind me, who were the hold outs on the Dega BT day 1? I seem to remember a very active player whose User name starts with S being a prominent one. It feels to me that you more want town to be united with you than just wanting town to be united.

Is Town!Tonic overreacting to this to fix his behaviour, or is Scum!Tonic just 'uniting town' while drinking and explicitly saying in the tick mafia that you shouldnt drink & mafia?

I also dont like how he isnt pushing me for my post towards him, but I've mentioned that before.

Why is it scummy for sonic to not push you? Sonic does a lot of things but omgusing has not been one of them. With the recent exception of votanic.

Also where in the tick did he say you shouldn't drink and mafia?

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=240040&p=5299937&hilit=drunk+drink#p5299937

I feel like Sonic should push me because Sonic says I could've stopped him at any time because apparently I was online all evening. I wasn't in the thread. Either he's lying about me being active, or I'm lying about my activity. Best case he is assuming I would have been around and using it as a defense tactic.

I find it weird that he ignores that.

I don't read either of those as scummy. I've left this thread open for hours and hours and if you asked me I would've said I wasn't following anything during those hours - so maybe he just figured out that activity level and talks about activity level aren't great indicators. Sonic also proved Bax lying about his activity level in the tick--made a really detailed post about it, then just dropped it (much to me and the other scums' detriment!). So I think those are just par for the course

[Ragian]

No. You were skimming. You even quoted the part where I said that I needed to tug in my boy before posting. And yes, you're being passive-aggressive. "Must have been some party..." Put a sock in it.

[Votanic]

No. You were skimming. You even quoted the part where I said that I needed to tug in my boy before posting. And yes, you're being passive-aggressive. "Must have been some party..." Put a sock in it.

Okay... now you're confusing me. What exactly does 'skimming' mean to you?
To me, skimming means reading something lightly or incompletely.
Does it mean something different in Danish? ..or when you play Mafia? ..or when you're nursing a hangover?
Please do explain.

[Ragian]

Lord almighty... A bulldozer couldn't power through such thick bricks.

---
Here's part one:

I liked the Ragian theory but that was in the scenario he was the random converted one..

With DDS changing that to only 1 Original Thing it would make no sense for a mod to hint a strong clue (or even draw attention) towards the only player we need to find (because when you do it's game over).

For that reason alone Ragian has to be town. And Strike confirmed the joke thing very quickly. If Strike was The Thing staying silent a bit longer on the matter would be the better play. Only today you can trust 2 players confirming each other.

So i think we have to place Ragian and Strike in the 40% town we need to find. Degaston made a good impression too.

Early doors D1, Son!c says that I have to be town. He backs up that position some 18 pages later:

Bottle of the Toscane is half empty. Right now i think BT Ragian (who i think is the recruit is best choice). So tik tok. Im gonna vote when the bottle is empty.

just chug it and drop the hammer!

What if we are being played? Something does not add up here.

And then, one hour later, making sure to state that this goes against his actual reads:

My mind says its Traf but it says also that we cant get 5 votes on Traf...

SO

BT Ragian

At best, this is bad play. In the vein of self-voting/volunteering to be BT'ed. Son!c even noted that I want Votanic's blood. It smells of "I can get two for the price of one if I just climb down from this tree without people noticing it." EW noticed it, and I also noticed.

Son!c has earned himself some scummy points. (And even admitted to changing play style, which is funny if you recall what are senior representative voiced in the beginning of the game.)

The key thing in cult games is change in behavior.

[SoN!c]

Yes bad play. True

But i was thinking you were the converted one.

And again nobody, nobody wanted to BT Traf..

So i voted for my guess on the converted one.

Missed

[Ragian]

My chummy list right now is: Strike Wolf. Throughout, he has posted reads, general points, and comments that indicate town. If I were The Thing, I'd defo convert him.

I don't like Dega's absence. He's making it difficult to analyse him. I'm on the fence with EW. I think his call to BT me is weird and somewhat uncharacteristic.

[Ragian]

Rag is playing aggressive, perhaps a tad too aggressive, but I dont think he is the recruiter. Rag is on 3, but I dont want to put him on L-1 just yet even if it's "just" a BT and not a lynch. Rag, do you have stuff to say/divert to?

As for Sonic, it's all WIFOM because The Thing might just as well convert a less strong voice because we're expecting him to convert a strong player. Perhaps it's all back to dega then.

I forgot this quote. Here's EW - a few posts after pointing fingers at people for wanting to follow any cleared player, which, as he admits, he did so himself D1 - saying that I'm not the recruiter. So him voting for me is basically him making sure that the recruiter is not tested today.

Scum points for EW (also see D1).

[Ragian]

Swang and Charle seem consistent in their "I'll just vote whoever without laying out grounds myself" play. I think this is abdictation of responsibility, but at least it's consistent.

I have absolutely zero read of traf. The only thing that rubbed me the wrong way with him was him saying that he deliberately stayed away from the wagon on me because others suspected him.

All three are on my watchlist, but I don't have anything damning on them.

[Ragian]

Anyway...

Letting a negative BT, whomever that turns out to be, decide the lynch does make sense.

However, I would like to hear the reasoning behind the lynch decision before jumping on the wagon.
Afterall, some players (at least one) do have a reputation for coming up with some screwball theories.

Lynch Votanic

[SoN!c]

Anyway...

Letting a negative BT, whomever that turns out to be, decide the lynch does make sense.

However, I would like to hear the reasoning behind the lynch decision before jumping on the wagon.
Afterall, some players (at least one) do have a reputation for coming up with some screwball theories.

Lynch Votanic

You get to choose that was the agreement.

And you can change your lynch vote anytime too. I'll keep following your vote

Best to name BT and lynch targets D3 too if you want. Without it the game is lost

Lynch Votanic

[Extreme Ways]

Anyway...

Letting a negative BT, whomever that turns out to be, decide the lynch does make sense.

However, I would like to hear the reasoning behind the lynch decision before jumping on the wagon.
Afterall, some players (at least one) do have a reputation for coming up with some screwball theories.

Lynch Votanic

You get to choose that was the agreement.

And you can change your lynch vote anytime too. I'll keep following your vote

Best to name BT and lynch targets D3 too if you want. Without it the game is lost

Lynch Votanic

I think he's already done that. Me, you. Maybe Traf. In which order is for Rag to decide.

I still think this line of play from you is scummy.

@Rag you're not entirely wrong. I voted to keep the pressure up, and indeed said that you were unlikely to be the recruiter for me. But I still think your play was off D2 compared to D1. To me, your D2 felt a lot more directly aggressive. In the post you quoted, I also said that I was holding my vote to give you an opportunity to address. Obviously Sonic and Votanic didnt think the same after Sonic unvoted and I voted.

I'm still not sure how much I lean into Sonic!Sonic and how much Scum!Sonic. For now, he's my most likely lynch candidate.
Vote Sonic

[SoN!c]

Votanic knew Ragian would wanna lynch him and he votes BT Ragian..weird

I was thinking Votanic was town but now Ragian tests negative and you all the sudden are not following Ragians vote? That puts a whole different picture on the board.

Why do you not follow Ragian like agreed? He is the BT negative D2..

I certainly can see EW (as original thing) recruiting Votanic. Because we said the thing most likely will convert the BT one or an experienced player...so recruiting Votanic would be a great EW choice (as the Thing)

[Extreme Ways]

Votanic knew Ragian would wanna lynch him and he votes BT Ragian..weird

I was thinking Votanic was town but now Ragian tests negative and you all the sudden are not following Ragians vote? That puts a whole different picture on the board.

Why do you not follow Ragian like agreed? He is the BT negative D2..

I certainly can see EW (as original thing) recruiting Votanic. Because we said the thing most likely will convert the BT one or an experienced player...so recruiting Votanic would be a great EW choice (as the Thing)

Because I think Ragian suspects Votanic for non-alignment indicative reasons.

[SoN!c]

Votanic knew Ragian would wanna lynch him and he votes BT Ragian..weird

I was thinking Votanic was town but now Ragian tests negative and you all the sudden are not following Ragians vote? That puts a whole different picture on the board.

Why do you not follow Ragian like agreed? He is the BT negative D2..

I certainly can see EW (as original thing) recruiting Votanic. Because we said the thing most likely will convert the BT one or an experienced player...so recruiting Votanic would be a great EW choice (as the Thing)

Because I think Ragian suspects Votanic for non-alignment indicative reasons.

Yada Yada

[Votanic]

Great job Ragian, you've taken your dumb vendetta against me all the way to a lynch vote...
...and look who is the first person to jump on your bandwagon...Sonic!!!

Hopefully you're feeling a little embarassed right now.

[SoN!c]

Great job Ragian, you've taken your dumb vendetta against me all the way to a lynch vote...
...and look who is the first person to jump on your bandwagon...Sonic!!!

Hopefully you're feeling a little embarassed right now.

Man, you and EW seem to defend each other like crazy.

Votanic: it was agreed we would follow the BT one if he tested negative

[Votanic]

Actually nobody fully agreed to that plan, except you, Sonic.
I actually said it was a good idea, if the reasoning behind the vote made sense. This clearly does not.

...and don't take my word for it.
Please, re-read everything Ragian actually had to say about me. It's all just flavor-hating and personal dislike, as far as I can see.

Best to name BT and lynch targets D3 too if you want. Without it the game is lost

And then here you go, piling it on deeper, still pushing your idea to pre-select all the BTs and lynches for the whole game.
Are you signing on for that too, Ragian? Have you got any names ready to add to Sonic's list? I mean, 'your' list.

What else can I say except... Lynch Sonic.

[DirtyDishSoap]

Lynch Vote:
(1) Ragian - Swang
(2) Votan - Sonic, Ragian
(2) Sonic - EW, Votan



With 9 alive, it takes 5 for majority!

[swang918]

Let me just pull my Ragian vote first
UNVOTE RAGIAN

But Ragian what is the case against votanic again? Extreme's reasoning makes sense that if votanic is scum then it makes no sense for him to vote BT on you since you made it very clear you were going to push for his lynching once you were cleared. And if he was scum he would know you were going to get cleared.

Other than votanic who is your second choice?

[Ragian]

I think I made three ish posts naming players. If you read those, you find whom I suspect.