spiesr wrote:Yeah, saw that last night, then I went to bed. The more I look at it the more it all seems to fit. I will throw out a Vote on theHerkman.strike wolf wrote:To be honest I had forgotten about this specific rule and when herk mentioned the Punisher role I kind of discarded it as unlikely but considering this and herk's sudden mention of an obscure role that he seemed to go well out of his way to look up especially as an obscure role.Mr. Squirrel wrote:3. Be careful with your roleclaims. I'm not saying you can't roleclaim, just that theres a few surprises in this game.
This seems like a major oversimplification at best. If you follow that logic to the letter then town the night actions of town roleblockers would also be profitable to the mafia, creating some sort of paradox or something. Certainly some night action, like cop investigations, are by nature to the detriment of the mafia. Did you mean "all night phases" instead? That point could be argued. The mafia's ability to kill at night definitely seems to support that theory, although some setups contain a power role distribution that mitigates this advantage. As for how the mafia is supposed to win? If they are skilled enough and play their cards right a mafia group could be more successful during the day than the night.karelpietertje wrote:All night actions together should be profitable to the mobsters, or they could never win.
Wow, you are all wrong. I found where i got the link now. It's in the mafia terms thread in this forum. Under the WIFOM definition. I was browsing the website and read that early in the day. When I went back to do the post count and links I saw that Mr. S said that in his post and I thought I would throw that out there just in case. Quite obviously if everyone who claims ends up getting killed we then know there is a punisher in this game. But that isn't me. You are welcome however for my mentioning of it to the town. Do you have something against townies?