The Tick Mafia - JUSTICE PREVAILS!

[Ragian]

To be honest, I initiated the vote on Raz for two reasons: 1) I wanted him to participate. 2) I wanted to see who'd jump on this, admittedly, inadequate case. (It's seldomly a good idea to hunt deadweight. They rarely defend themselves.) I think one vote has stood out so far, but I need to deal with this first:

I will not flip scum. [...]
I will give you all a soft claim.

I am a character that has an evil double. This person (whom I know) is out to get me lynched to meet his win conditions.

Your call now, lynch me and eat the egg on your face or look at the ones that are diverting attention towards me.

Why don't you just give us this person's name, so we can weigh your words against that person's? At worst, we lynch you, and if you indeed flip town, we lynch your evil twin D3. One townie for one scum; I'd take that trade any day. You will still win with town if you're dead town. You should be very willing to do this.

[Ragian]

Humm...or we could do it the other way around if the game stops with you being lynched by that dude, but for now, just mention your evil twin.

[Razorvich]

Nah I'm not falling for this.. I wont disclose anything else at this stage, as I said it only benifits scum.

To be honest, I initiated the vote on Raz for two reasons: 1) I wanted him to participate. 2) I wanted to see who'd jump on this, admittedly, inadequate case. (It's seldomly a good idea to hunt deadweight. They rarely defend themselves.) I think one vote has stood out so far, but I need to deal with this first:

I will not flip scum. [...]
I will give you all a soft claim.

I am a character that has an evil double. This person (whom I know) is out to get me lynched to meet his win conditions.

Your call now, lynch me and eat the egg on your face or look at the ones that are diverting attention towards me.

Why don't you just give us this person's name, so we can weigh your words against that person's? At worst, we lynch you, and if you indeed flip town, we lynch your evil twin D3. One townie for one scum; I'd take that trade any day. You will still win with town if you're dead town. You should be very willing to do this.

[strike wolf]

Feels sketchy, Raz. Can you not even give us something better than it would be bad for town? Why do you believe that revealing your evil twin is bad for town?

As expected Son!c continues to try to tunnel Loose.

[Razorvich]

You might think is sketchy, but thats all I got at this stage.. and I am now suspecting that others have objectives too.

It would be bad for town because if I am gone their numbers will be 1 less

Feels sketchy, Raz. Can you not even give us something better than it would be bad for town? Why do you believe that revealing your evil twin is bad for town?

As expected Son!c continues to try to tunnel Loose.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

DDS - why are you trying to stop me playing what I believe is a scum revealing strategy?

Also, DO NOT TRADE REVEALS, THIS IS STUPID!

Charle, ty for joining, can you tell us a full list of Town, neut and scum in more detail please?

And what do you think of my belief that BLENDING IN is what scum do?
Maybe watch Traitors UK, Traitors USA or Traitors Australia on BBC Iplayer - you will see that is Scum behaviour.
(Actually all of you should watch one of those series)
Then call me stupid if you want.

And therefore masterblender Swang is Scum - I'm not changing my vote.

Why do you think its a scum revealing strategy? I have also said its mafia that gets info. Unless u elavorate I still see you as not helping town. Even tho I am one of those who has said its unlikely for your power to be mafia

[TrafalgarLaw01]

You might think is sketchy, but thats all I got at this stage.. and I am now suspecting that others have objectives too.

It would be bad for town because if I am gone their numbers will be 1 less

Feels sketchy, Raz. Can you not even give us something better than it would be bad for town? Why do you believe that revealing your evil twin is bad for town?

As expected Son!c continues to try to tunnel Loose.

If I unerstand you said you know who is the player that is after you? But you don't want to say in case someone like Loose who is looking for specific roles finds out?

[SoN!c]

Feels sketchy, Raz. Can you not even give us something better than it would be bad for town? Why do you believe that revealing your evil twin is bad for town?

As expected Son!c continues to try to tunnel Loose.

Yes absolutely! Im on Loose. Because im a superhero who needs to save town. Busting scum relying on my intellect is my job!. But if 5 or 6 of you guys say stop it i'll stop. No problem.

Loose being a 3rd party who needs to find a specific target (like the cop) is my idea. And his voting ability going from 0 to 2 after receiving 3 votes is something to check out. No?

DDS said he had a good idea about who Raz and his evil Doppelganger is. I can't see any reason why it would be bad for town if we find out? DDS can name his idea about "the evil twin" while not giving info on Raz?

I would like to know what EW thinks on this new twist. Im happy he unvoted Raz (as Raz was 1 vote away before Loose could make it 10)

[DukeHazzard]

2 pages after one night... lots to read and lots happened.

I believe Raz's soft claim and I don't want Loose to be able to switch votes to hammer him, so unvote

I don't understand his reasoning about why he won't reveal who him evil twin is tho.

[Loose Canon]

DDS - why are you trying to stop me playing what I believe is a scum revealing strategy?

Also, DO NOT TRADE REVEALS, THIS IS STUPID!

Charle, ty for joining, can you tell us a full list of Town, neut and scum in more detail please?

And what do you think of my belief that BLENDING IN is what scum do?
Maybe watch Traitors UK, Traitors USA or Traitors Australia on BBC Iplayer - you will see that is Scum behaviour.
(Actually all of you should watch one of those series)
Then call me stupid if you want.

And therefore masterblender Swang is Scum - I'm not changing my vote.

Why do you think its a scum revealing strategy? I have also said its mafia that gets info. Unless u elavorate I still see you as not helping town. Even tho I am one of those who has said its unlikely for your power to be mafia

Because I believe Swang is Scum so strongly

[Loose Canon]

I'll tell you what, I can't believe there are no real world people here who don't have the odd cheeky gamble now and then.

I'll off to all and any takers;
I'll send you 500 Conquer Club Credits if Swang DOESN'T ultimately turn out to be Scum
If you'll send me 1250 Conquer Club Credits if Swang DOES ultimately turn out to be Scum

Any takers? - What about you guys who are currently voting for someone else? - What about you Swang?

[TrafalgarLaw01]

DDS - why are you trying to stop me playing what I believe is a scum revealing strategy?

Also, DO NOT TRADE REVEALS, THIS IS STUPID!

Charle, ty for joining, can you tell us a full list of Town, neut and scum in more detail please?

And what do you think of my belief that BLENDING IN is what scum do?
Maybe watch Traitors UK, Traitors USA or Traitors Australia on BBC Iplayer - you will see that is Scum behaviour.
(Actually all of you should watch one of those series)
Then call me stupid if you want.

And therefore masterblender Swang is Scum - I'm not changing my vote.

Why do you think its a scum revealing strategy? I have also said its mafia that gets info. Unless u elavorate I still see you as not helping town. Even tho I am one of those who has said its unlikely for your power to be mafia

Because I believe Swang is Scum so strongly

ok, but I believe you also have offered another player to trade claims

[fusibaseball]

Unvote, that's more posts and activity than we got the whole game.

I think Ragian may be throwing a Hail Mary to "war words" with Raz and take the 50/50 shot at lynching Raz over himself for the win. Or Raz himself is the evil doppelgänger and he's just spinning his role slightly to get an effective soft claim.

Also is it safe to assume that this doppelgänger is 3rd party then? I don't think a Mafia would have individually-aligned win condition and this doesn't seem like it can be Town.

[degaston]

Vote Count:

Razorvich : 5 (Ragian, *Pixar*, traffic133, DirtyDishSoap, PepeAtila)
swang918 : 2 (Loose Canon x 2)
*Pixar* : 1 (SoN!c)
Loose Canon : 0 ()

No Vote : 11 (Charle, Darin44, DukeHazzard, Extreme Ways, fusibaseball, General Bax, Maxleod, Razorvich, strike wolf, swang918, TrafalgarLaw01)

18 Alive, 10 votes needed to lynch

[swang918]

Razor is lying about something. Let's break down his claim. His claim has three parts:
1. There is someone whose win condition is to lynch Razor.
2. Razor knows who it is. and
3. Razor is town.
Ok so assume that all three are true aka Razor is telling the truth. That would mean that there is someone who is out to lynch him, a townie. What's that person's alignment? That person can't be town obviously. It's also not scum--doesn't make sense for a single scum to have an individual win condition of killing a specific villager. And also most likely not third party, because if he's 3p then that means we have a townie, Razor, who started the game knowing the identity, alignment, and mission of a 3p--which would be incredibly unfair to the 3p.
Therefore, it's impossible for Razor to be telling the truth about all 3 aspects of his claim.

Now he's probably not making up the whole role out of thin air.

If I had to guess, there are two 3ps, each of whose win condition is to lynch the other. Razor is one. Maybe Ragian for the other.

[SoN!c]

Razor is lying about something. Let's break down his claim. His claim has three parts:
1. There is someone whose win condition is to lynch Razor.
2. Razor knows who it is. and
3. Razor is town.
Ok so assume that all three are true aka Razor is telling the truth. That would mean that there is someone who is out to lynch him, a townie. What's that person's alignment? That person can't be town obviously. It's also not scum--doesn't make sense for a single scum to have an individual win condition of killing a specific villager. And also most likely not third party, because if he's 3p then that means we have a townie, Razor, who started the game knowing the identity, alignment, and mission of a 3p--which would be incredibly unfair to the 3p.
Therefore, it's impossible for Razor to be telling the truth about all 3 aspects of his claim.

Now he's probably not making up the whole role out of thin air.

If I had to guess, there are two 3ps, each of whose win condition is to lynch the other. Razor is one. Maybe Ragian for the other.

How i got it there are 2 twins, or better said 1 townie (raz) and an 1 evil "clone" doppleganger - and both know the identity of the other from the start. Raz says he is the good townie and the evil twin is his clone who will win if town lynches fellow townie Raz. So the evil twin must be 3rd party .

And the doppleganger is not Loose

[SoN!c]

Im gonna follow Charle and believe Raz on this. Raz said his evil doppleganger will start to sing very soon.

And the first song on Raz throwing shades on Raz is made by Swang.

Makes me wonder?
What does Loose know on Swang that he is so sure Swang is scum? Because ever since the smokebomb event Loose went on Swang like a hornet.

[SoN!c]

Unvote Pixar Vote Swang

PS: Swang needs to be lynched asap. Swang is scum just like Loose said. Sorry Loose for not believing you. It's just because your always late it seems.. You are so slow and smelly. So unlike me, always supersonic

[Extreme Ways]

Town (this one is in order):
Me, duh
DDS
Fusi
Strike
Traf. Kind of coasting, but does say the good shit every now and then and is more than active enough. Also provided his list, so he's still in this tier.

Neutral:
Duke. I like Duke, but not enough to put him in Town tier. His unvote to prevent Loose from potentially hammering was good. It doesnt gve him a lot of town cred, but I didnt like seeing traf/strike/rag not unvoting
Charle. I like Charle, but not as much as the others.
BaxMax
swang918. I dont see why our crazies are so sure about him being scum. I quite like his latest post, even.
traffic133. Vote reason is scummy as hell, but I am inclined to believe that as mafia you would be more invested in this game so you're not in the scum section yet.
Pepe
Darin44
Pix. Just unclear with the L-2 thing and hard to read.

Not to be trusted, not necessarily scum:
Raz. It would help if he could explain why he cannot explain, "just trust me bro" is a bad defense.
Sonic. Mother of all chaos.
Loose. I've given up, at some point I cannot defend the person behind the posts and I'll have to assume that indeed some form of executioner is his role. We have to play around his double vote yet he doesnt seem to be willing to coordinate with town.
Ragian. Hard to read Raz's defense without looking towards Ragian, so you're here for now until we get more clarity out of Raz or lynch him.

[Extreme Ways]

That all being said, you obviously know more about your role than we do Raz. Including that you cannot mention your evil twin at all, or something. Why not? Would you get modkilled? Maybe you only know the existence of your brother, but not who it is? Give us something, brother.

I'm with Swang

[Extreme Ways]

show

EWBOP: I call strike out for not unvoting, but he never voted in the first place. This is wrong

[DirtyDishSoap]

Humm...or we could do it the other way around if the game stops with you being lynched by that dude, but for now, just mention your evil twin.

On my phone, hate replying this way but i want to point this out.
Its very unlikely the evil twin just wins. And even then, there's nothing implying as such.

This is dejavu moment where Fusi played this exact same tactic to avoid a lynch and *que dramatic music* BUM BUM BUM ended up being GF.

I do believe i know what evil twin he is talking about though.

@Loose, you're the most anti town roadblock thus far. Any discussion about you or your smoke bomb thing is just a distraction.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

show

EWBOP: I call strike out for not unvoting, but he never voted in the first place. This is wrong

I haven't voted either.

Anyway, I am looking for more info into possible roles that include a target but I really don't get why Raz can't or won't give more info. if he is townie and has someone after him that someone would be not townie.

[SoN!c]

Humm...or we could do it the other way around if the game stops with you being lynched by that dude, but for now, just mention your evil twin.

On my phone, hate replying this way but i want to point this out.
Its very unlikely the evil twin just wins. And even then, there's nothing implying as such.

This is dejavu moment where Fusi played this exact same tactic to avoid a lynch and *que dramatic music* BUM BUM BUM ended up being GF.

I do believe i know what evil twin he is talking about though.

@Loose, you're the most anti town roadblock thus far. Any discussion about you or your smoke bomb thing is just a distraction.

I know who the evil twin is. Im pretty sure you know it too. But then you know we can't say who he is or scum wins in three moves.

[Extreme Ways]

show

EWBOP: I call strike out for not unvoting, but he never voted in the first place. This is wrong

I haven't voted either.

Anyway, I am looking for more info into possible roles that include a target but I really don't get why Raz can't or won't give more info. if he is townie and has someone after him that someone would be not townie.

Jeez, I fucked up!