Mass Effect 1 - Thorian (Cult) Wins!

[madmitch]

fircoal is scum, if he would be town then DDS could easily modkill him
since he is scum he can't cause that would be probably the end of scum

sorry pal that makes no sense,only 2 scum died so far and we still have a 3rd party out there,the ony thing that you have on your side is the jail card but that might be a good con and you are actually 3rd party

[madmitch]

@ skoffin. what does caff and chu have to do with me? neither one is alive now and 1 was scum not sure what chu is yet , all I know is I am vanilla.

> replaces chu
> "not sure what chu is yet"
> claims vanilla
not sure what I said ,I replaced fircoat not chu, Pikachion died earlier

[Skittles!]

Chu is Fircoal's nickname.

[madmitch]

Shit no wonder I was getting confused about the posts ,thanks SKITTLES

[dakky21]

Benga's theory is probably possible. Why DDS kept prodding Chu and then replace him?

Mitch, this isn't your first game with Fircoal, actually you were in every game with him and you should have already know that his nickname is Chu.

I was on him before, I'll continue to be.

vote madmitch

[benga]

fircoal is scum, if he would be town then DDS could easily modkill him
since he is scum he can't cause that would be probably the end of scum

sorry pal that makes no sense,only 2 scum died so far and we still have a 3rd party out there,the ony thing that you have on your side is the jail card but that might be a good con and you are actually 3rd party

I never said there was no 3rd party anymore, I am just stating there could not be mod kill due you being scum

vote mitch

[DirtyDishSoap]

Vote count

(2) Sam - DY, MM
(4) Mitch - Skoffin, Skittles, Dakky, Benga

With 13 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

[lord voldemort]

I wont add a vote and at least give him a chance to claim before l-1 and a potential quick hammer.

I have every intention of voting for him though

[Ragian]

I told you loads of times that I'm at a festival. Skimming will occur. I'm still voting tails because he presented a case without backing it up with a vote. It had nothing to do with Skoffin other than she asked where my vote was, which I took to mean that I came off hypocritical. Can't have that.

Now, back to drinking and listening to metal.

[DoomYoshi]

chu might not mean fircoal to everyone. who did you try to bodyguard in your past life?

[benga]

I wont add a vote and at least give him a chance to claim before l-1 and a potential quick hammer.

I have every intention of voting for him though

he said vanilla

[DoomYoshi]

I was under the impression that this was a no-vanilla game, but I can't seem to find that stated anywhere.

[madmitch]

first I guarded Rags ,it was early in the game and he seemed a good choice,next it was Benga because of his jailer posts, but I am wondering if that is all a bluff? he did say at one time he blocked Thor then quickly said jailed him so I not sure if he slipped up ? I am Sparatus a Turian council member, mission make sure Shepard stops Saren (done) and any 3rd party,my ability vanilla

[dakky21]

I think mitch is saying truth, but why WHY ...why.... DY would you ask him about his past life..... I don't recall DDS made a rule about it, but he just replaced the inactive, his old role wasn't important anyway... Why ask... I don't see one valid point why ask....

chu might not mean fircoal to everyone. who did you try to bodyguard in your past life?

If i was the mod, I would modkill mitch for sharing that data. You knew he will tell who he did bodyguard so that's a so lame attempt.

UNVOTE. Vote DoomYoshi.

[dakky21]

To be clear:

Mitch, you are a "new player" as a replacement and you don't know anything about your past role in this game, only about the new role.

DoomYoshi asked about your "past" life and you said what have you done as old role.

Damage done. I'd punish both and still think DY did it on purpose to get mitch modkilled.

[madmitch]

I AM PRETTY SURE i AM ALLOWED TO SHARE THAT INFO IF ASKED

[dakky21]

I am pretty sure you are not. But that's up to the mod. I'd modkill you for sharing that info. Remember, you are dead as your past role. So you can't speak about it...

[madmitch]

okay Dakky , you are proberly right. if I need to be punished I accept it, sorry guys and mod

[strike wolf]

It's up to the mod. Though, personally as a mod I 've always stuck with if you feel they have valuable information that could unfairly influence the game then don't allow them to replace. Any information revealed because the mod let the player replace is on the mod. I will also say that this is why mafia/scum group and investigative roles are pretty much never allowed to replace back in but there's rarely any limit to any other kind of role. Further, i have in past games myself replaced back in after dying and revealed info with not so much as a warning from the mod. So no. I don't believe anyone should be modkilled for this.

Likewise voting or FOSing Doom for asking seems like a witch hunt to me but it's dakky and he wouldn't be town dakky without the occasional witch hunt.

Sparatus strikes me as a slightly better claim than Hackett but nothing to reverse course for. We have four days to discuss other suspects but in terms of lynch, I don't think we'll find much better.

[dakky21]

Look strike, I do believe Mitch is saying the truth UNLESS he got Sparatus as a fake role claim. It sounds better that Hackett, but you're right, it deservers the vote back to him.

UNVOTE. Vote Mitch.

But DY's provocations and questions will cause a "witch hunt" as you said.

[Skoffin]

I think vanilla is a pretty weak and typical claim, as for the name I don't know and I don't care yolo.

But I must agree with Dakky that it was highly inappropriate to discuss mitch's past life/actions, while I'm not surprised that mitch gave that info I am surprised that Doom asked when he should clearly know better. I don't think that is so much scummy on his part but very much taking advantage. While I normally agree it's on the mod we are also in a situation where there are barely any people available to replace in, especially at such short notice. Either way it should be very obvious to all established players that someone that replaces into a game they already died in is not supposed to have any 'knowledge' of their past life and not to give any info that they had behind the scenes. Honestly I'm surprised more people aren't supporting dakky in his outrage on that.

[madmitch]

well here we go again,does not look like I am going to be around much longer,can't defend my self any better than I did, understood why you went after fircoat for lack of posting but some off you won't even give me a chance.Dakky you keep saying you believe my claim but you still want to hang that is really scummy,and Strikewolf I can't believe you are taking Dakky side, I believe one of you maybe both are 3rd party.KEEP AN EYE ON WHO HUNG ME and when it turns out I was telling the truth go after them

[HotShot53]

This bandwagon on mitch was pretty fast... although I was also suspicious of fircoal, and the VT claim doesn't relieve much suspicion, I'm not ready to hammer yet. I also agree doom should have known better than to ask mitch about a past life... for that I will FOS him. Will have to re-read his other posts later to see if he deserves my vote

[dakky21]

But I must agree with Dakky that it was highly inappropriate to discuss mitch's past life/actions, while I'm not surprised that mitch gave that info I am surprised that Doom asked when he should clearly know better........

That's why I said they should both be punished, DY isn't a new-comer and Mitch isn't a newbie. He answered and that can help DY if he is scum and that means he now knows more then than the rest of us knows. I am really unsure between them now, but I'll still go with Mitch for now.

[lord voldemort]

I am inclined to believe Mitch given his flavor claim