MAFIA - X-Men Legends [Game over -- Town wins!]

[Machiavelli]

I'm done for the night.

I hope most of you from previous games have learned to trust my beliefs.

[Senfive]

Senfive- tell me, what possible role could fircoal be?

The only roles worth a cop claiming for are a doctor or another cop.

Would it be so bad to know which one of these fircoal is?

Actually yeah it would. It is better unknown to all, then known to everyone where the Town can't protect him if he is one of those and gives the mafia 3 of our power roles. Also how am I know what he is? I could care less atm. I just know that fishing for townies roles is the wrong way for townies to win.

[AndyDufresne]

May I defer to my post on Page 39?

... The old 'Get the someone else to do your dirty work' so it can't be traced back to whomever ...

--Andy

[wicked]

here's one way to settle it, Fircoal, do you believe your role is more important than a cop's? yes or no. if you were in rojo's shoes, would you have outed yourself as a cop to save this role???

[AndyDufresne]

Hm, well I'm going to attempt to write up a nice big post. If I can get my thoughts organized.


--Andy

[AndyDufresne]

Hm, maybe not! Can't quite organize everything yet... need a little longer.


--Andy

[Fircoal]

here's one way to settle it, Fircoal, do you believe your role is more important than a cop's? yes or no. if you were in rojo's shoes, would you have outed yourself as a cop to save this role???

If I was Rojo, I'd wouldn't of said anything, about my role. I wasn't close to being lynched, and people barely suspected me, or that's how I remember it. I don't like my role is more important then a cop, but at this point revealing it may be a significant thing.

[sully800]

Andy is killing me with this suspense!

[wicked]

it's totally up to you Fircoal whether or not you divulge anything. don't let anyone pressure you. do what you think is best for the town.

[AK_iceman]

Vote Count

• [1] Fircoal -- (Puff)
• [1] red bull -- (dussle)
• [1] Lt.Mustard -- (autoload)
• [1] Puff -- (Fircoal)
• [1] dcowboys055 -- (moz976)
• [1] Machiavelli -- (Senfive)
  
• [15] Not Voting, Everyone Else

11 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch


Day Deadline: 14 Feb 2007 8:07 PM GMT.

IC!! Can we please get a prod for Lt Mustard?????

He has been prodded along with the other players that haven't posted in the last 48 hours.

[AndyDufresne]

I think any more role revealing today, seems rather pointless. Lets keep our cards close. If the town doesn't know, then the mafia can't either (or so I hope). Lets all learn at the PROPER time, or all together at the start of a day. Our ignorance hopefully also goes hand in hand with mafia ignorance. The mafia I think are relishing a little too much in all the roles coming out.

Speaking of which, we haven't had a daykill today. Perhaps this means we don't have a daykill vig, and indeed supercram may have passed over some stipulation of his role? And if we do, lets not come out and tell us who you are.


--Andy

[wicked]

that was your big post andy?

[AndyDufresne]

• When were you cleared, I honestly dont remember that ever coming out
  
  ...
  
• I'll pretend to believe that you are cleared

Mach, have you looked back a few pages. I vaguely recall something.


--Andy

[AndyDufresne]

No, I'm still organizing my big post ideas. I'm unsure whether to post it... also....


--Andy

[Senfive]

• When were you cleared, I honestly dont remember that ever coming out
  
  ...
  
• I'll pretend to believe that you are cleared

Mach, have you looked back a few pages. I vaguely recall something.


--Andy

Thanks Andy

--SenFive

[Master Bush]

***Voice from the grave***

You guys need 11 votes to lynch someone and you have 6 players with 1 vote each?

[reverend_kyle]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

[Fircoal]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

I think that maybe Red Bull is trying to do that, and maybe Puff is in on it too.

[reverend_kyle]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

I think that maybe Red Bull is trying to do that, and maybe Puff is in on it too.

well that would prove their innocence.

[Fircoal]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

I think that maybe Red Bull is trying to do that, and maybe Puff is in on it too.

well that would prove their innocence.

HUH???? How would there innocence be proven if they're mafia?

[reverend_kyle]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

I think that maybe Red Bull is trying to do that, and maybe Puff is in on it too.

well that would prove their innocence.

HUH???? How would there innocence be proven if they're mafia?

I figured they were trying to TRICK the mafia into getting you, when the mafia lynches you they'll find out you're a vanilla townie because they puffed up your role.


It could work opposite though, they could be mafia trying to puff you up to protect you and them

[Fircoal]

Does anyone think this fircoal business is just a clever ploy to get the mafia to lynch a vanilla townie?

I think that maybe Red Bull is trying to do that, and maybe Puff is in on it too.

well that would prove their innocence.

HUH???? How would there innocence be proven if they're mafia?

I figured they were trying to TRICK the mafia into getting you, when the mafia lynches you they'll find out you're a vanilla townie because they puffed up your role.


It could work opposite though, they could be mafia trying to puff you up to protect you and them

Oh, I see now.

[Kernal_Kronic]

What are the chance of there being 2 doctors? Coz the only role a person could think is better than a cop, it's a doctor...but in that case puff could be lying to try save his arse or the other 2 are in cahoots. Either way, it can't be good for the school for all our power role players to be throwing their roles out...

Can Lt.Mustard be replaced for lack of posting?

[trestain]

What are the chance of there being 2 doctors? Coz the only role a person could think is better than a cop, it's a doctor...but in that case puff could be lying to try save his arse or the other 2 are in cahoots. Either way, it can't be good for the school for all our power role players to be throwing their roles out...

Can Lt.Mustard be replaced for lack of posting?

In a game this large 2 docs is a possibility, It is also possible that the second doc is just a quacker. I was one of those in Auto's last game and didn't realise till near the end.

[Senfive]

What are the chance of there being 2 doctors? Coz the only role a person could think is better than a cop, it's a doctor...but in that case puff could be lying to try save his arse or the other 2 are in cahoots. Either way, it can't be good for the school for all our power role players to be throwing their roles out...

Can Lt.Mustard be replaced for lack of posting?

In a game this large 2 docs is a possibility, It is also possible that the second doc is just a quacker. I was one of those in Auto's last game and didn't realise till near the end.

I knew you were but was killed before I could bring it to light lol.