Post-Apocalyptic Mafia - Town Wins! [Archive]

[Fuzzylogic99]

Justin was a bad lynch, but in any game he would of been lynched bc of his actions atleast the games I played in.H e played the role poorly.

I can see what you talking about. We could of talk about some other possible lynch for day three etc than lynch Herk. Still it was a good lynch since
it hlp prove Illiad as having an investigatory role.I will take your point into consideration

Unvote jeraldo vote Violet

she seems to be submarining and have a role.Shes not the cop bc we know thats illiad and dont think she is an angel or doctor.I think she has a scum role

[aage]

Oh PLEASE let me replace into this game soon. :S

I have something to say to a few of you people....

Please turn to the mod for affairs like this and keep the whining out of the thread.

And finally
"Unless Liliad is scum and I doubt that you are a townie so voting for you would really bad."
Wut?

And finally
"Unless Liliad is scum, and I doubt that, you are a townie so voting for you would be really bad."
Is what I figured.


Fuzzy, your case on VioIet is awfully weak. "She's not a cop, I don't think she's a doc so she must be scum!!" What the hell?

[Fuzzylogic99]

scoff- illiad investigated you and found you as a townie

i invite illiad to investigate me bc she will find me a townie as well. I have nothing to hide

[Fuzzylogic99]

Okay let me clarify I think thats she has a role blocking role and she scum.Yes the reasoning is weak but voting for Jeraldo to end the day is weaker.
Its a gut instinct.

[Iliad]

scoff- illiad investigated you and found you as a townie

i invite illiad to investigate me bc she will find me a townie as well. I have nothing to hide

FOS fuzzy for skimming.

If you had read what I posted about my role, I can tell if someone is human. I do not know whether that person is a christian, swat guy, whether he likes to giggle or anything like that, just that he is not a abomination, werewolf, mutant, zombie etc.

Honestly I thought there were going to be more non-humans in this game, but perhaps they're hiding low for now.

Anyway, fuzzy seems like a much better lynch than an inactive drawn out from a hat.

[naxus]

unvote vote Fuzzy

Your reasoning is stretching and you agreeing to a bad idea(lynching a inactive) then voting for violet for scumaring is really bad. Your arguments seem to be all over the place and you are skimming.

[Mr. Squirrel]

no one stopped to consider leaving a possible vig to take him out (based on the setup it would be very weird to *not* have some sort of town shooter on our side)

Actually, I do believe that I made the suggestion but no one wanted to go with it.

Oh PLEASE let me replace into this game soon. :S

I have something to say to a few of you people....

Please turn to the mod for affairs like this and keep the whining out of the thread.

Don't be so harsh Aage. Its good to see someone who wants to be active and play. Knox, just drop commander9 a pm if you want to replace.

i invite illiad to investigate me bc she will find me a townie as well. I have nothing to hide

Cops can't investigate everyone. It takes too much time and if we waited on cops for every single lynch, then scum would win every game.

In my opinion you have been far too cryptic all game. You seem to love BWs (not counting herk. That wagon was justified) and aren't really helping town much. Your defense is weak and frankly, I am having a hard time thinking of why we shouldn't lynch you.

[Skoffin]

no one stopped to consider leaving a possible vig to take him out (based on the setup it would be very weird to *not* have some sort of town shooter on our side)

Actually, I do believe that I made the suggestion but no one wanted to go with it.

Sorry, I was meaning out of those adamant that he should be lynched and wagoned him.


I think what bothers me most about fuzzy was his 'It's not worth defending myself' deal. He went to more effort trying to convince us why it would be pointless for him to defend then actually defending/clarifying his actions. I think he gave that nonsense because he knew he wasn't going to be able to give justification for his actions. Again, I think he is a very noob scum. A common problem I have seen of such noobish scum is a 'I'm doomed no matter what I do, woe is me' attitude. He has been all over the shop and keeps making excuses. He's not serving towns interests.
I welcome anyone to strengthen any of the others cases to convince me otherwise, but until then we need to get rid of fuzzy.

[safariguy5]

Ah, the town vig. Maybe they could take out one of the inactives during the night phase then. Nice analysis there jeraado. Reminds me of Chu analyzing voting patterns.

Yes, fuzzy seems to not be making very much sense here, and I really don't think wasting an investigation on him is justified. I'd like to hear a claim, so I will

unvote vote fuzzylogic

And Iliad is a girl? I'm going to have to remember that and not mix up my he/she's

[Iliad]

Ah, the town vig. Maybe they could take out one of the inactives during the night phase then. Nice analysis there jeraado. Reminds me of Chu analyzing voting patterns.

Yes, fuzzy seems to not be making very much sense here, and I really don't think wasting an investigation on him is justified. I'd like to hear a claim, so I will

unvote vote fuzzylogic

And Iliad is a girl? I'm going to have to remember that and not mix up my he/she's

No I'm not.

[Fuzzylogic99]

yes Im am skimming....Im Add/Adhd so its hard to stay focus enough to read everything. Just who Iam.

Scoff I dont understand what more you want.I told you everything about the misquote.I was skimming and I misquoted you about killing the WW
and said aage said it. Theres no more to the story

Vio has a role and she submaring the two made me nervous so i voted for her.Its a good of vote as thoose who voted Jeraldo just to end the day.
At least my vote has some rationale even if it is a bit fuzzy.

Scoff- I cant be noob scum if I played WW/mafia games for a while now.I have not lied about anything and except for the poorly time joke I been fortright about everything . Have I played this game badly- probaly Am i scum absolutely not.Have I given up and want to die ??? no So everything you have said about me has been wrong. I am not defending myself bc I saod everything that needed to be said about the misqoute incident

[Streaker]

So far, Fuzzy, you are not doing a good job in convincing everyone NOT to lynch you. You jump your vote from one person to the next, as soon as someone asks you about your vote. You provide little or no evidence to your votes, you CLAIM you are skimming, reluctant to defend yourself and quite frankly, most of your posts don't make much sense. The last part i'll just assume is part of who you are...

Unfortunately for you, until recently, this game has been stalling and you are proving 'most' scummy. I agree that the few investigations we have are better spent elsewhere, and you are currently the best option to lynch.

Votecount please, Commander9. I'll wait until then to cast my vote.

[aage]

Oh PLEASE let me replace into this game soon. :S

I have something to say to a few of you people....

Please turn to the mod for affairs like this and keep the whining out of the thread.

Don't be so harsh Aage. Its good to see someone who wants to be active and play. Knox, just drop commander9 a pm if you want to replace.

viewtopic.php?f=213&t=131088&start=600
Also, it's not the role of the outsider to claim how much we're missing here.

I think what bothers me most about fuzzy was his 'It's not worth defending myself' deal. He went to more effort trying to convince us why it would be pointless for him to defend then actually defending/clarifying his actions. I think he gave that nonsense because he knew he wasn't going to be able to give justification for his actions. Again, I think he is a very noob scum. A common problem I have seen of such noobish scum is a 'I'm doomed no matter what I do, woe is me' attitude. He has been all over the shop and keeps making excuses. He's not serving towns interests.
I welcome anyone to strengthen any of the others cases to convince me otherwise, but until then we need to get rid of fuzzy.

I also would like to get rid of fuzzy but I can see his reasoning. He just simply made a mistake, but you want him to write a five-page analysis on it or something, while there frankly is nothing to discuss. FoS skoffin.

[Fuzzylogic99]

My vote on Vio has nothing to do with anyone questioning my vote ( ie I'm bandwagoning at least that's what I think the poster is saying) . Im going by expierence from other games My experience tells me that players that submarine and have obvious has strong possibility scum roles.

I dont understand why Im being targeted for Voting Vio when there have been players here voting Jeraldo just to speed up the game and in the day. I ll vote for myself if someone can tell me how this is more scummier than the player(s) who voted bc they wanted to end the day.This makes absoutly no sense to me.Atleast Im tryying to make an attempt to find scum and not make pointless random vote.

[Fuzzylogic99]

Im going by expierence from other games My experience tells me that players that submarine and have obvious has strong possibility scum roles

meat to say

Im going by expierence from other games My experience tells me that players that submarine and have obvious roles have strong possibility of scum roles

[Skoffin]

I also would like to get rid of fuzzy but I can see his reasoning. He just simply made a mistake, but you want him to write a five-page analysis on it or something, while there frankly is nothing to discuss. FoS skoffin.

That quote I keep asking about is not part of me trying to establish a case on him, I just want to know what it is about as I am confused on it. I'm baffled as to what he is saying I did. He brought it up as some scummy action you did, but then said I did it. Huh? From what it looked like he was meaning (which I could be wrong about, hence why wanted clarification) it wasn't even something I actually said. I just want him to repeat what he said it was, in a clearer tone, so I know what it's really about. But it's apparent that that is just not going to happen, so I'll drop it.

Part of making a case is not just to see how the person it's about reacts, but to see how others around respond to it. We had a sudden bandwagon before for a lame reason, although at the time I still felt that fuzzy was a bit dubious I still wanted to see if and who might jump ship. Back in my day this was a fairly standard practice.

yes Im am skimming....Im Add/Adhd so its hard to stay focus enough to read everything. Just who Iam.

Scoff I dont understand what more you want.I told you everything about the misquote.I was skimming and I misquoted you about killing the WW
and said aage said it. Theres no more to the story

Vio has a role and she submaring the two made me nervous so i voted for her.Its a good of vote as thoose who voted Jeraldo just to end the day.
At least my vote has some rationale even if it is a bit fuzzy.

Scoff- I cant be noob scum if I played WW/mafia games for a while now.I have not lied about anything and except for the poorly time joke I been fortright about everything . Have I played this game badly- probaly Am i scum absolutely not.Have I given up and want to die ??? no So everything you have said about me has been wrong. I am not defending myself bc I saod everything that needed to be said about the misqoute incident

You cannot use any conditions you might have to excuse your actions. You signed up knowing about your limitations, if your limitations include being unwilling to read through all the comments then you really shouldn't be signing up. While returning to skim through the game later is understandable, it's not really appropriate to be skimming it from the get go.

I commented on that above with aage.

Submarining isn't really a good enough reason to vote someone, while I'm not sure what 'She has a role' has to do with.. anything. I'm going to assume that was just another issue with communicating your thoughts.

Being noobish doesn't really have much bearing on how long you have been here, I think the term you are thinking of is 'newb'. You have been rather scattered, poor at communication and generally confused. That does seem rather noobish. Even veterans can have noobish play at times. Anyway, you can't really say everything I have stated on you is wrong. A lot of what I've made of you is true, I've merely interpreted those actions of yours as scummy.

I dont understand why Im being targeted for Voting Vio when there have been players here voting Jeraldo just to speed up the game and in the day. I ll vote for myself if someone can tell me how this is more scummier than the player(s) who voted bc they wanted to end the day.This makes absoutly no sense to me.Atleast Im tryying to make an attempt to find scum and not make pointless random vote.

Now on this you have a point.
Those Jeraldo jumpers seemed to have gone quiet. After jumping on one person for supposed submarining they have since decided to submarine too.
I am curious as to what these guys have to say, and it may very well be worth putting some pressure their way.

P.s Some of my posts have been cut off, so I'll have to come back to it later. My browser keeps crashing.

[safariguy5]

Yes, submarining sucks, but given that we have an active player acting scummy, I'm willing to pursue that over submarining which I pursue only when there's no better leads.

[Skoffin]

It's less 'Oh, these guys are submarining' and more 'Hey, these guys started a wagon on someone for being inactive, a seemingly innocuous thing, then when a new case came up.. nothing, these guys have suddenly turned to submaring themselves'.
Fuzzy still looks questionable, but these guys should still come back and say something.

[Dlanor A. Knox]

According to the PM I just received I will be replacing FuzzyLogic...?

/confirm

[edocsil]

Interesting, she replaced him and not Campin...

[safariguy5]

Odd, maybe he got so frustrated he quit.

[/]

Yeah..... hmmmm, I'll wait for comm to confirm that that the replace is correct, but if fuzzy asked to be replaced so spontaneously I think we found our scum. Heck, even an old player like me occasionally wants to run in the back of my mind when town has caught me as scum, as town there is always a claim to fall back on so the pressure isn't so bad.

[Commander9]

Lynching for Day 3:


Fuzzy (5) - aage,Mr. Squirrel, Naxus, Safari, Edoc
Thez (1) - TG
jeraado (1) - Saxlad,

With 18 alive, 10 to lynch.

Looking for replacements. Deadline this coming Friday at night.

Fuzzy asked me to replace him and he PM'd he has personal issues. Can't confirm the validity of these.

[Dlanor A. Knox]

Ah... so I'm being strung up for a lynch ATM am I?

Well... I would like to note that I will not be running away.Also, this policy lynch of lurkers is kind of strange. Is there a deadline or something? I don't see one listed in the latest mod update. Is there no other lead to go on? I would think with no deadline, and 40 pages of posts to go on, only scum would want to overlook that kind of information in favor of a lurker lynch.

Please allow me the time to read this thread before you string me up @_@

[Commander9]

Actually, there is indeed a deadline - probably should have posted again. The deadline is the night of Friday/early morning of Saturday.