[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

[TimWoodbury]

FOS @sausage

My thinking here is that if someone wants to place pressure, they should just go ahead and vote when there are this many players left alive. Because there is so much time left in the day, its not like it will immediately become a wagon, so it isn't risking a life, it is just applying some pressure to an end, instead of a weak "I'm looking at you if no one else comes out and screams scum"

If enough people vote for Hotshot, I a openly stating now, I am willing to put the hammer on him, and if anyone asks why, please refer to the post where I voted for Benga earlier on this page; I already gave a list of which he was only one of three which I was willing to vote for.

skw is making a jump here, from being willing to vote someone to being willing to be the hammer (without even clarifying if he would wait for a claim). I am torn on this, I'm not sure if it screams confident or scum. Right now I'm leaning confident, as it may be too bold of a move for scum to make. This put hotshot potentially at L-2, if we count skw's vote and the doublevoter is in on it, so anyone else voting hotshot should be aware of that. I think we should let him speak before more votes are placed.[/quote]



okay i can see and accept what your saying about there being so much time let and not being life threatning yet
and 2 i agree skw is very odd about being so eager to hammer im thinking possably noob town sticking head to far out there hopeing to be right then again can be skum saying hes willing to lynch and wanna get ton cred.

[TimWoodbury]

Hold on: unvote

this also almsot makes you look sum, so i think no matter what streaker flips whatsuasage should go next

[TimWoodbury]

Holy quick lynch guys.... Hopefully my unvote wasn't too late

If for nothing other than decency, we should let streaker speak before he is lynched: we have tons of time left in the day.

I agree that Streaker should get a chance to say something, and I agree that we shouldn't immediately lynch when that just entails losing scum-hunting time. But if we are going to kill Streaker either way, I don't think it's very wise to let him live one more night, which will permit him to use whatever role he might have.

do we wanna give streaker a chance to talk his way out of this?

[subtleknifewield]

Hold on: unvote

this also almsot makes you look sum, so i think no matter what streaker flips whatsuasage should go next

It's not a scum move to pause and let a person answer the accusations leveled against them.

[TimWoodbury]

i am thinking streaker would be the double voter, him being skum explains why he changed hi vote like 5 times in a matter of hours d1 and we know the double voter was on the d1 lynch im good with a streaker lynch as well
after reading your exlanation of why you unvoted its okay i accept it for now but will wanna keep an eye on you. im gonna have to read back some over weekend to figure out where hotshot votes came from/why

[Endgame422]

Good shit mets.
As to scumhunting i dont think we will get very much done as but we may as well give a shot for a couple days.

[Endgame422]

If streaker claims DO NOT counterclaim him.
He is as good as dead no matter what he says,so no need to give scum any extra info today.
Streaker sticking up for mitch there right before mets outs him makes the case on mitch seem more realistic.
If i had to guess right now id say streaker/mitch are one of our scum teams.
Other team of HS and ???.
Im fairly sure tim is town(hes def vig and def did not kill anyone last night),and i believe mets is most likely town as well.
That leaves pix,AoG,sausage,subtle and benga.
Of those my pick for HSs scumbuddy is hard to make,subtle and Benga both stated HS was a top pick for them early on,so i think pix,AoG,sausage are my top 3.
Probably AoG(HS defended him yesterday) first,pix second,sausage 3rd.

[Streaker]

Well f*ck me, I'm dead. You guys have no option but to lynch me.

Here's my last thoughts and reads, you might need them:

-HS likely scum
-Mitch town
-Whatsausage town, based on his last few posts
-Pixar probably scum (quick to end the day)
-subtleknifewield possible scum, trying to direct the vig
-endgame town

I am indeed the Town Double Voter. That's why I was comfortable switching my vote to ensure the lynch, they were closer to lynch then you guys could see.
Don't lynch mets tomorrow, and don't vig him. A few things could have happened to give the skewed result.

Good luck!

[subtleknifewield]

Direct the vig? Lol. Even you admit you likely find HS scum.

[Marashu]

DAILY VOTE COUNT

madmitch: AoG
Benga: subtleknifewield
HotShot: Endgame, Streaker
Streaker: Mets, mitch, Pixar, benga

not voting: Tim, sausage, Hotshot

Deadline is Saturday, Oct 10, at 1000CCT. With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

[*Pixar*]

Nice try Streaker but you are not town lol. I would like to know why I am on people's scum radar and hopefully I can tell you why you are wrong

[Streaker]

Nice try Streaker but you are not town lol. I would like to know why I am on people's scum radar and hopefully I can tell you why you are wrong

Mmmhmmm. You consider it very towny then to quicklynch someone without discussion?

Anyway, I made my list. Don't forget to read it.

[TimWoodbury]

i actully somewhat agree with streaker on skw being skum, steaker pointed out 3 potential skums there is 11 active players 4 skum 7 town.

we know metsfan and me are town that brings it to 5 possable town we know streaker is skum so its to 3 skum 5 town

i think at this point the chances of finding skum is looking good for us town folks.

[benga]

Well f*ck me, I'm dead. You guys have no option but to lynch me.

Here's my last thoughts and reads, you might need them:

-HS likely scum
-Mitch town
-Whatsausage town, based on his last few posts
-Pixar probably scum (quick to end the day)
-subtleknifewield possible scum, trying to direct the vig
-endgame town

I am indeed the Town Double Voter. That's why I was comfortable switching my vote to ensure the lynch, they were closer to lynch then you guys could see.
Don't lynch mets tomorrow, and don't vig him. A few things could have happened to give the skewed result.

Good luck!

can you please elaborate?

[subtleknifewield]

i actully somewhat agree with streaker on skw being skum, steaker pointed out 3 potential skums there is 11 active players 4 skum 7 town.

we know metsfan and me are town that brings it to 5 possable town we know streaker is skum so its to 3 skum 5 town

i think at this point the chances of finding skum is looking good for us town folks.

He said possible. If he flips town I would go after his stronger reads. It makes the most sense, don't you agree that is only logical?

[subtleknifewield]

Well f*ck me, I'm dead. You guys have no option but to lynch me.

Here's my last thoughts and reads, you might need them:

-HS likely scum
-Mitch town
-Whatsausage town, based on his last few posts
-Pixar probably scum (quick to end the day)
-subtleknifewield possible scum, trying to direct the vig
-endgame town

I am indeed the Town Double Voter. That's why I was comfortable switching my vote to ensure the lynch, they were closer to lynch then you guys could see.
Don't lynch mets tomorrow, and don't vig him. A few things could have happened to give the skewed result.

Good luck!

can you please elaborate?

Assuming he is town, he might not want to give too much information away, or he believes Mets is simply being mislead.

I still think it's worth lynching Streaker, which would give a clearer picture of the possibilities here.

[TimWoodbury]

Well f*ck me, I'm dead. You guys have no option but to lynch me.

Here's my last thoughts and reads, you might need them:

-HS likely scum
-Mitch town
-Whatsausage town, based on his last few posts
-Pixar probably scum (quick to end the day)
-subtleknifewield possible scum, trying to direct the vig
-endgame town

I am indeed the Town Double Voter. That's why I was comfortable switching my vote to ensure the lynch, they were closer to lynch then you guys could see.
Don't lynch mets tomorrow, and don't vig him. A few things could have happened to give the skewed result.

Good luck!

can you please elaborate?

Assuming he is town, he might not want to give too much information away, or he believes Mets is simply being mislead.

I still think it's worth lynching Streaker, which would give a clearer picture of the possibilities here.

hes in no way trying to defend himself so i do bealve that he is in fact skum and he nows its his time. if he was town he would of attempted to defend more then jsu say im double voter these are my reads before im dead.

though id like to know what he ment saying a few things could of happened to give skewed results

[subtleknifewield]

We've already discussed at least a couple possibilities to skew the results, you know. It's not hard to make an educated guess on what he means.

However, I kind of agree with you here, I would like to hear his own reasoning here.

[TimWoodbury]

yes we have discussed a few differant options but i am thnking hes saying his skum partner redirected a kill or that his team was wanting to kill someone else if we can figure out what his partner did without his revealing who the partner is it will help us to figure out exactly what happened last night between differant night actions

[Army of GOD]

Probably AoG(HS defended him yesterday)

I mean, Mets defended me too, but yeah, go with that...

hm so with Mets pretty much confirmed as the cop, I don't think there's a chance he isn't scum. I don't see how mafia would really use the cop to their advantage.

While I am very confident in Mets' result, I do want to point out that we could've been mislead one way or another by a bus driver. But, this is something we'll find out afterward.

unvote vote Streaker


and for the record, I haven't posted in a while because I was in South Carolina visiting family not trying to die from all the rain.

[Army of GOD]

Also, Streaker said everything he can so there really isn't any reason to not hammer him...

[Army of GOD]

Also found this post while reviewing:

Mod question for you. Lets say last two standing are bomb and SK. Who wins if the SK targets the Bomb during a night action?

I just reviewed all the win conditions, and I will say that in the specific case of SK vs bomb, the bomb's faction would win.

I hope the bomb lasts long enough to make this happen.

so...are you saying you're the bomb...?

-_- ...seriously?

1) How do you derive my 'claim' from that post? And you consider it likely I'd claim bomb a day after it exploded?
2) That's all you have to say about my post?

for the record, I was hammered when I made this post, so it's probably best to disregard it

[Army of GOD]

also, this night should be interesting with the jailer (if one exists), the doc and the Empowerer, which sounds like a very scum-favorable role.

[Endgame422]

The tailor is the only way mets could be wrong.
Busdriver is 1 way so the only way it could give an incorrect reading is if streaker is the busdriver and he targeted scum, thus redirecting the investigation to a scum player.
But hes claimed DV so only possibility is both tailor and Mets targeted Streaker,which i find super unlikely.
If you were scum and tailor your best move would be to tailor your scumpartner,essentially making your teammate a GF for the night.
Trying to hit a random townie that the cop also chooses to investigate is a serious long shot for scum and i doubt thats the case.
If streaker flips town ill be quite surprised.

[TimWoodbury]

im gonna go ahead and make the hammer as said above streaker sid eveything he can/will and were not learning anything by keeping this going vote streaker this is seen right i think its bold as wlel