South Park Mafia [Scum Win]

[evilchaos]

Fair enough, I am Jimbo, Town Tracker, given my role I assumed that Ned was the Watcher, but I may be mistaken, I can confirm that Comm went nowhere the last two nights.

If you aren't lynched today, track me and tell me where I go to confirm your role.

[kratos644]

Well the ability does make sense with the role so I'm willing to buy it for now. It seems logical to jump to the conclusion he made. We need to figure out who is lying. Right now the town should be up 5-2 on the mafia but if we mislynch today we'll be in lylo tomorrow. There could also be the possibility that Com is a threat to the town and he doesn't realize it but that might be a stretch. The only reason I say this is because it has only been the nights that he hasn't said anything to the boys that there hasn't been any poison soup. It could just be coincidence but seems unlikely.

We also have 1 person we know nothing about and 2 we know their role but not abilities. It could be believable that Butters is actually Professor Chaos and a threat to the town so I'd like to hear some more from tal about his role.

Then we have kyle who I can't really see being anti town unless he was Jersey Kyle but even then he helped people out.

And strikewolf we know nothing about.

Maybe it's mass claim time and we pick out the liars?

[Talapus]

Well the ability does make sense with the role so I'm willing to buy it for now. It seems logical to jump to the conclusion he made. We need to figure out who is lying. Right now the town should be up 5-2 on the mafia but if we mislynch today we'll be in lylo tomorrow. There could also be the possibility that Com is a threat to the town and he doesn't realize it but that might be a stretch. The only reason I say this is because it has only been the nights that he hasn't said anything to the boys that there hasn't been any poison soup. It could just be coincidence but seems unlikely.

We also have 1 person we know nothing about and 2 we know their role but not abilities. It could be believable that Butters is actually Professor Chaos and a threat to the town so I'd like to hear some more from tal about his role.

Then we have kyle who I can't really see being anti town unless he was Jersey Kyle but even then he helped people out.

And strikewolf we know nothing about.

Maybe it's mass claim time and we pick out the liars?

LOL, yes, lets point fingers at the kid who tries to flood the planet using a garden hose or dreams up a plot to fill all cherry cordials with 2 month old mayo. As professor chaos or not it should be obvious I am no threat to town...lol. As of lkast night though I did recieve a one shot ability. I have had no major role yet, just the original PR thing, but now I have a one shot. a one shot vig ability day or night. So if we decide who looks good, I can use it.

[strike wolf]

I'm Randy Marsh.

[strike wolf]

Sorry I hit submit by mistake.

Anyways. I do think you are underselling Professor Chaos' ability to be a serial killer tal but a day kill seems like a good selling point to prove your ability through the fact I don't think blake would include a day Sk. I'm not sure who you should kill if anyone tal. / can potentially prove his role and kratos is still a risk targeting a claimed doc so commander seems to be the safest choice I am just not sure I want to you to off him.

[kratos644]

Hmm well if you've got the 1 shot vig power then town should be fine today. We should be up 5-2 and we have a vig shot which I can make sure remains tomorrow by protecting you if we can't find a good target today. It could even be safe to no lynch today if things come down to that at the deadline and we can't decide on who to lynch. Now I'm obviously not suggesting that we no lynch right now because it's definitely better for us if we can get scum to slip up and lynch a scum today then we'll obviously be in a beautiful position especially still having a vig shot but what I don't want to see happen is we vig the wrong person and lynch the wrong person and then we lose which is the only reason I say a no lynch wouldn't be the worst situation today if it happens that we can't decide who the scum is as we would still be up 4-2 with a vig shot but more than likely the doc(me) will be dead unless we have a busdriver between Kyle or Randy and they haven't spoken up yet. I'm kind of at a loss today as to who should be lynched though. Chef is likely the one giving poison soup but I don't think Com has intentionally given it to anyone. So he probably has some sort of hidden part to his role. The big question that brings up for me is does this mean he still wins with the town or does he have some separate win condition?

[evilchaos]

Many people have commented that the soup appeared only when Com9 sent messages to the boys.

Let's examine the other side of that. People HAVE died even though no soup was given and Com9 didn't sent messages to the boys.

It is very possible that Com9 is giving soup without knowing, and the soup is only poisoning the people for a day, not killing them. Scum could have just been opportunistic in killing those effected by soup, since it makes Com9 seem scummy.

Since kills happened even when the soup wasn't given out, I think we can safely say that the soup doesn't cause death, only the one-day poisoning.

[blakebowling]

Attention:
Alright. Your deadline is Thursday, July 28th late night most likely.

NOTE:If a lynch is not reached by the deadline, there WILL NOT be a lynch.

[strike wolf]

Sorry for inactivity I just really don't know where to go from where we are.

[evilchaos]

I still have my vote on /. His "no lynch" idea yesterday when we had someone confirmed as scum by a cop was just plain bizarre. I still think we should lynch him.

[blakebowling]

Vote Count (Since I totally missed our vote)
/ (1) - evilchaos

With 6 alive, 4 votes are required to lynch.

[strike wolf]

So the way I see it we have 3 weird roles (I'm not including Tal as up to this point there is no proof that there is an SK so I believe he is town based on that much). Commander is somehow connected to the poison soup but his behavior if he was a pontential scum would have to be considered...odd. Kratos who has claimed a tiny character and acted fairly suspiciously but has also claimed doc which makes it still a risky move trying to lynch him. Then there is / whose behavior has been fairly hard to figure out. His actions have been somewhat on the scum side but at the same time he has shown to be a confirmable role.

Now my role isn't too terribly powerful to begin iwth so what I suggest is this: Kratos and Tal target me tonight and / tracks evilchaos as previously suggested. If things go as you would expect. I will still be alive in the morning and we've essentially cleared tal and kratos, maybe even / if he is able to prove that he knows who evil visited. This will leave us with a clearer field as to who to lynch tomorrow. IF it does not go to plan and I die. Kratos will be the clear lynch. If it doesn't go as planned and / guesses evil's action wrong, / is lynched. If it doesn't go as planned, I'm killed and / guesses wrong. We now know that both / and kratos are lying and we've definitively found the two remaining scum.

Does this sound good?

[Talapus]

So the way I see it we have 3 weird roles (I'm not including Tal as up to this point there is no proof that there is an SK so I believe he is town based on that much). Commander is somehow connected to the poison soup but his behavior if he was a pontential scum would have to be considered...odd. Kratos who has claimed a tiny character and acted fairly suspiciously but has also claimed doc which makes it still a risky move trying to lynch him. Then there is / whose behavior has been fairly hard to figure out. His actions have been somewhat on the scum side but at the same time he has shown to be a confirmable role.

Now my role isn't too terribly powerful to begin iwth so what I suggest is this: Kratos and Tal target me tonight and / tracks evilchaos as previously suggested. If things go as you would expect. I will still be alive in the morning and we've essentially cleared tal and kratos, maybe even / if he is able to prove that he knows who evil visited. This will leave us with a clearer field as to who to lynch tomorrow. IF it does not go to plan and I die. Kratos will be the clear lynch. If it doesn't go as planned and / guesses evil's action wrong, / is lynched. If it doesn't go as planned, I'm killed and / guesses wrong. We now know that both / and kratos are lying and we've definitively found the two remaining scum.

Does this sound good?

No, as I said, I'm a one shot, day or night. We do that and it wastes my ability.

[strike wolf]

Fair enough. Than the two most legitimate choices I see to lynch are commander and /.

[/]

Many people have commented that the soup appeared only when Com9 sent messages to the boys.

Let's examine the other side of that. People HAVE died even though no soup was given and Com9 didn't sent messages to the boys.

It is very possible that Com9 is giving soup without knowing, and the soup is only poisoning the people for a day, not killing them. Scum could have just been opportunistic in killing those effected by soup, since it makes Com9 seem scummy.

Since kills happened even when the soup wasn't given out, I think we can safely say that the soup doesn't cause death, only the one-day poisoning.

It could be both, the scum might choose who sends a kill on any given night, on nights using the soup the person is incapacitated and the kill delayed, on nights using someone else it is probably a normal kill.

I will track evilchaos as planned, I agree that comm is likely the best choice for a lynch, the scene indicated that a bowl and spoon were abandoned in an alley near to the body, this means it is more likely the action was related to scum, since only scum would have presumably been involved with the death scene, and since I know that comm hasn't used his ability for two nights it is a likely flavor indication that he has been laying low and therefor doesn't need his bowl anymore.
Vote commander

[Commander9]

And you are really going to let / off? What's with everyone recently being lynch happy on me? Geez...

[evilchaos]

I don't know Com9, I don't know.

Bandwagon on / now please? He has a confirmable claimed role, but we're forgetting that every day we waste waiting for the confirm that is 100% not happening is a day that scum is getting a free kill. It's not worth it when we already know he's scum.

He's clearly scummy, much more so than anyone else in the game.

[/]

Why do you feel my actions were so bad?
I explained the reasons for every part of my plan, and comm, the reason I am wary of your actions is because I intended to find out the nature of your role, like I said in my plan, I wanted to see if you were not targeting anyone specific with your action like you claimed... but you avoided it despite the numbers, could you explain why please?

And by the way evil, why are you so concerned about an extra day for confirmation? We have talapus on our side to provide an extra kill tomorrow if need be.

[evilchaos]

Had forgotten about Tal's kill, to be honest. I just don't want town to be in a situation where we lose because we waited when we had scum right in front of us.

If we don't have enough people behind a lynch of /, I'm willing to go with a no lynch I guess, but if / can't tell me who I visited tomorrow, then he should 100% be our lynchee tomorrow.

[strike wolf]

I still like the plan I laid out but I won't fool myself into thinking it's so flawless that everyone needs to follow it.

[Talapus]

I still like the plan I laid out but I won't fool myself into thinking it's so flawless that everyone needs to follow it.

Well, lets be honest. Butters is probably gonna be targeted tonight. I think it would either be best for Kratos to protect me tonight or, we decide right now who we want day killed and I send it in and then we try to either lynch or no lynch. That way, my one town action is put to good use before I get offed.

[kratos644]

I still like the plan I laid out but I won't fool myself into thinking it's so flawless that everyone needs to follow it.

Well, lets be honest. Butters is probably gonna be targeted tonight. I think it would either be best for Kratos to protect me tonight or, we decide right now who we want day killed and I send it in and then we try to either lynch or no lynch. That way, my one town action is put to good use before I get offed.

My plan was to protect you tonight so we'll have our kill for tomorrow but I'll likely end up dead so after that you guys have to get the scum

[blakebowling]

Vote Count
/ (1) - evilchaos
Commander9 (1) - /

With 6 alive, 4 votes are required to lynch.
Deadline is Thursday, July 28th. Late Night EST most likely. This is two days away. As of now, there will NOT be a lynch.

[blakebowling]

I wasn't sure what was going to happen, but I surely wasn't expecting nothing.

As there are not enough votes to force a lynch, the day ends without one.

Begin Night 5

You have 48 hours to send me your night actions.

[blakebowling]

This morning in South Park was a foggy one at best.

The corpse of Butters Stotch was found lying in the center of town. But he was not alone. Standing at his feet was a large dark figure, when he was approached, the demented face of Chef was shown.

Talapus - Butters Stotch (Danger-Activated One Shot Vigilante) has been killed.

In other news; Scum Win.

Roles, actions and such coming in the next post. Feel free to discuss while I compile things.