NCIS Mafia: Mafia Win!!

by **isaiah40** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 9:51 am

Well, I might as well claim. I am VERY Special Agent Dinozzo. Yes that right VERY Special Agent. I am Town Body Guard and can take one bullet before I get killed. So that would mean then that thechuck51 could be scum because he saw me with Gibbs last night.

vote thechuck51

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 9:59 am

isaiah40 wrote:Well, I might as well claim. I am VERY Special Agent Dinozzo. Yes that right VERY Special Agent. I am Town Body Guard and can take one bullet before I get killed. So that would mean then that thechuck51 could be scum because he saw me with Gibbs last night.

vote thechuck51

How do you reason that protecting Gibbs gets a guilty? Cops do not watch/track they simply note alighnment.

by **isaiah40** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 10:03 am

I don't know how thechuck got a guilty, unless he is a paranoid cop or he is scum.

by **isaiah40** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 10:10 am

Iron Butterfly wrote:
isaiah40 wrote:Well, I might as well claim. I am VERY Special Agent Dinozzo. Yes that right VERY Special Agent. I am Town Body Guard and can take one bullet before I get killed. So that would mean then that thechuck51 could be scum because he saw me with Gibbs last night.

vote thechuck51

How do you reason that protecting Gibbs gets a guilty? Cops do not watch/track they simply note alighnment.

! well of course he wouldn't SEE me. What was I thinking!? My claim is true, I went to protect crazymilkshake5 (Gibbs) last night. So that would mean that thchuck51 would be what, a paranoid cop? Forgive me I'm still trying to get the roles right.

unvote due to me not totally thinking straight. #-o

by **thechuck51** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 10:12 am

isaiah40 wrote:Well, I might as well claim. I am VERY Special Agent Dinozzo. Yes that right VERY Special Agent. I am Town Body Guard and can take one bullet before I get killed. So that would mean then that thechuck51 could be scum because he saw me with Gibbs last night.

vote thechuck51

How would I see you visit anybody if I was scum? If I were a tracker or a watcher yes but they are generally town roles. Its also convenient that we need the skills of the person killed last night to verify your claim.

vote isaiah

fastposted by IB and Isaiah

Paranoid is a possibility, however until I get guilty on somebody that flips town I will believe I am sane.

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 10:13 am

What makes you a Very Special Agent besides being a body guard?

by **isaiah40** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 10:19 am

Iron Butterfly wrote:What makes you a Very Special Agent besides being a body guard?

Ever watch the show? Dinozzo says that quite a bit. So I thought I'd throw that in. Everything you need to know is in my claim, I have not left anything out, or embellished any of it. If I get lynched, then you need to look more closely at thechuck51. I am fine with being lynched as I have told the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

by **chapcrap** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 12:08 pm

strike wolf wrote:So reading opening page...Dazza was the one killed. can you edit it to show Dazza's name in scene please?

Sorry, updated the scene.

by **strike wolf** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 1:25 pm

Lol at those following the probably paranoid cop without question. Isaiah'd claim is fairly solid. not beyond questioning but fairly solid. Also Chuck, Gibbs didn't die last night. if he had I would vote Isaiah. as far as cases I have a suspicion but may just take a while to get the actual case built.

by **new guy1** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 1:43 pm

As far as isiah goes, I believe his claim, but I am a little confused now. Is the "very" part of the name? Or did you just add that in for fun? For the reference I saw the post where he said he added it cause he says it alot, but I want to know if it was actually said... If that makes sense... I trust the claim just because he is a main character and so he is kind of bound to be in the game and so it would be a giant leap of faith for someone to fake claim him. I am doubting the chuck's sanity as Dinozzo should be town and so I dont find him to be credible. I do believe however that he is a cop, as he did calim Ziva and shes an important character too.

by **isaiah40** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 2:01 pm

new guy1 wrote:As far as isiah goes, I believe his claim, but I am a little confused now. Is the "very" part of the name? Or did you just add that in for fun? For the reference I saw the post where he said he added it cause he says it alot, but I want to know if it was actually said... If that makes sense... I trust the claim just because he is a main character and so he is kind of bound to be in the game and so it would be a giant leap of faith for someone to fake claim him. I am doubting the chuck's sanity as Dinozzo should be town and so I dont find him to be credible. I do believe however that he is a cop, as he did calim Ziva and shes an important character too.

I just added the "very" for fun.

by **edocsil** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 3:24 pm

strike wolf wrote:Lol at those following the probably paranoid cop without question. Isaiah'd claim is fairly solid. not beyond questioning but fairly solid. Also Chuck, Gibbs didn't die last night. if he had I would vote Isaiah. as far as cases I have a suspicion but may just take a while to get the actual case built.

Yeah, it's got to be paranoid/insane. I am not far into the series, is there any argument either way for this? FTC is standard Strike, so while it is funny to laugh at them, I do not deem the behavior to be overly suspicious.

by **thechuck51** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 7:51 pm

ok unvote because enough people feel my sanity is questionable and I don't want to mislynch anybody. Would I be able to investigate myself to determine if i'm insane/paranoid?

If there is no case on isaiah where do we go from here? investigator and watcher/tracker are dead. anybody got anything?

by **new guy1** on Sat Jul 07, 2012 9:04 pm

In response to Edoc, in the series from what I know if she has a strong feeling about someone she is pretty interested in showing they are the bad guy, but you would have to check with someone that watches it actively. Also, chuck, I dont know thats a question for the mod really.

by **safariguy5** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:18 am

I'm concerned about how many possible investigative roles we have left. If chuck is paranoid, we may have little to no information to work on from here on out. Also, I wonder if we have any other third party roles. It appears that there were only 1, but I cannot be sure of that.

by **new guy1** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 12:18 pm

For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

by **thechuck51** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 1:52 pm

new guy1 wrote:For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

the other cop may have been the "investigator" that died night 1.

If we have nothing else do we lynch happy feet (inactive)?

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 2:08 pm

new guy1 wrote:For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

I will be offline till tomorrow.

Granted it is a TV show about cops but how many "cop"s would there be? We lost our investigator night one. An investigator role is pretty powerful according to wiki. Being able to determine someones role is pretty straight forward. At present we may have a ratio of 3 mafia to 8 or 4 mafia to 8. We may also have a SK although I am more inclined to believe we have a Vig as there was only one night kill last night. IF we do have a third party killer Town would be in dire straits if we mis lynch.

If Chuk is a paranoid/insane cop we have no way of knowing at the moment. In my mind it would not make sense to have just a paraniod cop/insane cop. Either Chuk is for real or we have another cop as well.

by **edocsil** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 2:11 pm

thechuck51 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

the other cop may have been the "investigator" that died night 1.

If we have nothing else do we lynch happy feet (inactive)?

He has been exceptionally useless, but it feels like a shot in the dark, and perhaps a pointless one at that. I would rather there was a replace, but he is friends with Chap, and I doubt that would happen.

by **thechuck51** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 3:38 pm

edocsil wrote:
thechuck51 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

the other cop may have been the "investigator" that died night 1.

If we have nothing else do we lynch happy feet (inactive)?

He has been exceptionally useless, but it feels like a shot in the dark, and perhaps a pointless one at that. I would rather there was a replace, but he is friends with Chap, and I doubt that would happen.

Ok, how about we find out who CM5 blocked. There was no mafia kill last night, maybe because they were blocked (though there is nothing in the flavor showing a blocked kill attempt)

by **new guy1** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 4:01 pm

Plus then we run into a WIFOMy situation, cause he may have blocked someone, but the mafia might have held back their kill in order to frame someone. Just a suggestion, but I see no reason as to why we shouldnt get that information. Its a better place to start then nowhere.

by **edocsil** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 4:06 pm

thechuck51 wrote:
edocsil wrote:
thechuck51 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:For the cop role question, Im guessing theres at least one more cop to make up for the sanity of the chuck. As for the third party, I dont remember many of the main characters besides the team besides maybe the board of directors (the one that used to be married to Gibbs) might be in the game. I dont think theres enough main characters in the show to take up the rest of town, and so I would assume there were more third parties, but I am not positive. Any other takes on it? I understand its a weekend so not everyone will be AS active as they usually are, but Im trying to start conversation :/.

the other cop may have been the "investigator" that died night 1.

If we have nothing else do we lynch happy feet (inactive)?

He has been exceptionally useless, but it feels like a shot in the dark, and perhaps a pointless one at that. I would rather there was a replace, but he is friends with Chap, and I doubt that would happen.

Ok, how about we find out who CM5 blocked. There was no mafia kill last night, maybe because they were blocked (though there is nothing in the flavor showing a blocked kill attempt)

Could be a doc or a BP too. Lots of WIFOM, and we would have to run a lynch on hopes of a lucky RB.

by **strike wolf** on Mon Jul 09, 2012 8:55 am

Busy weekend caught back up now. LSS, I agree with edoc. There's too many factors for the role blockers comments to be accurate. It could be that mafia has some kind of kill system where they kill one night and poison the next, they could have had a one shot killer and an arsonist. Maybe the role block was busdriven or maybe mafia's role blocker (if htey have one) had his target busdriven with the killer. Maybe there's a bullet proof. Maybe a jailkeeper was involved. there's too many factors for the role block to be any kind of reliable for picking out mafia.

by **jonty125** on Mon Jul 09, 2012 12:29 pm

unvote seems like FTC won't work. I previously contributed what I thought mafia could have been built on, so I won't repeat myself.

by **happyfeet** on Mon Jul 09, 2012 8:16 pm

im not in active just not totally for sure whats going on. if you guys feel it would be best to replace me thats fine. everyone knows this is my first game and no one has really stepped up to teach me whats going on. so, i just say nothing.