autoload's 19 Player Mafia Game #1 --- Day 1 ---

[Roger Dodger]

no more chit chat from me. sorry for going so far from the topic.

forgive me for i know not what i do

[P Gizzle]

ok, so far, who hasnt posted.....

[wicked]

A LOT

1. reverend_kyle
2. Nyvek
3. supercram
4. Senfive
8. Wisse
9. vgmmaster
11. onbekende
13. Kokunai
14. HoussamTheGreat
16. XenHu
18. Fircoal

[P Gizzle]

Rev is the one that jumps out at me......THAT'S SUSPICIOUS!

[Fircoal]

Just got to post, I'm playing an RT, anyway, it seems that Mach would be the 1st to go because of all that he did last game, so I argee that the people the watched Auto's last game might be the mafia.

[Nyvek]

First thing's first

The 3 players I already trust in this game are Wisse, vgmmaster and Machiavelli, who are not mafia. Mach is easy to see now that he's dead.

Here's where I know this to be true.

3 more players need to Confirm by PM. I am going to go ahead and Officially put the game in Night One.

Those 3 players were the ones without X's next to their names, and they still dont have X's there. And they are Mach, vgmmaster and Wisse. Auto said he was gonna go ahead put the game in Night One. He would only do that if he received all confirming PMs from the Mafia, which mean those 3 are not.

So at this moment I trust whatever Wisse and vgmmaster say.

Howdy guys, I tend to agree with MB on this one. I don't think Autoload would let our excitedness rush the game if those 3 had night choices yet to take. And although Auto posted that they had confirmed pregame, he did same they confirmed by "daybreak." Which doesn't contradict MB's theory.

My only worry, can there be a mafia role that doesn't get a night choice? Maybe an unlocked traitor or something of that sort?

Ps. Nice Avatar Incandenza, you look like a Lyncher

[vgmmaster]

Reading the posts here, I'm going to assume that Mach is quite the experienced player. That, or he just got lucky.

If I had to make a guess, the mafia may want to go after someone who is experienced to give themselves a better chance at winning the game later. Going with that, I would assume that the mafia contains some experienced players. At least one or perhaps two.

[P Gizzle]

i actually didnt watch that one, but this is what concerns me.....

auto's games are usually played by the same people who play in Andy's games+guys like me who are too stupid to get into Andy's games.....

therefore, we have a lot of rivalries and grudges, etc. we need to watch who gets killed for a pattern, and if that person died, watch what he said before hand, that way we will probably know why he is dead.

Ex.

A said B was mafia
mafia killed A
B is probably mafia.....

[wicked]

good point Ny! There can be a sympathizer, a pro-mafia role that helps the mafia. The sympathizer knows who are the mafia are, but the mafia don't know about the sympathizer.

[Fircoal]

i actually didnt watch that one, but this is what concerns me.....

auto's games are usually played by the same people who play in Andy's games+guys like me who are too stupid to get into Andy's games.....

therefore, we have a lot of rivalries and grudges, etc. we need to watch who gets killed for a pattern, and if that person died, watch what he said before hand, that way we will probably know why he is dead.

Ex.

A said B was mafia
mafia killed A
B is probably mafia.....

Yep, or people like me, who didn't sign up until the last name, and didn't know mafia that well then.

ALso, good example.

[P Gizzle]

ok, more people are posting BUT STILL NO REV! that is messed up....

[HoussamTheGreat]

I hate first days!
It's confusing enough as it is, and now with the "unknown" role - it gets even weirder. No clues whatsoever at this point. I tend to agree with wicked though.. this is probably based on Mac's very last game, not on the game which he screwed up.

For the record, the last game, I was not mafia. I was the serial killer.

[Roger Dodger]

maybe he did get killed because he solved or helped solve the last game.

could there be more than 1 mafia group? is that possible?

it could be that maybe there are more mafia than townies. could this game work that way??

[P Gizzle]

it seems to me that Mach is a very unpopular mafia player.......

now, this could lead to many suspects, but we NEED to narrow it down

[Fircoal]

it seems to me that Mach is a very unpopular mafia player.......

now, this could lead to many suspects, but we NEED to narrow it down

ok, But first we should write out a list on suspects.

[HoussamTheGreat]

could there be more than 1 mafia group? is that possible?

Rivaling mafias? That would be AWESOME!
Actually, aside from awesome - that's possible.. with 18 people, there must be more than the usual 3 mafias. 2 groups of 3 would be a way of achieving this..

[Roger Dodger]

i agree that it would be really cool but, it scares me to think we can be out numbered.

[P Gizzle]

dussle tried this, it didnt work, but i could see why Auto would try that

[Roger Dodger]

could it be possible that there is no mafia just insane killers? could that happen?

[wicked]

I think our main list of suspects should be the non-townies from the last game. Sorry H, but that includes you since Mach took you out as well.

FOS Senfive and Houssam

[Roger Dodger]

i take that thought back. the game wouldn't be mafia if there weren't any. lol

[Nyvek]

it seems to me that Mach is a very unpopular mafia player.......

now, this could lead to many suspects, but we NEED to narrow it down

ok, But first we should write out a list on suspects.

Ok, if we go with MB's theory as a starting point, that leaves:

RK
Nyvek
SuperCram
Senfive
Trestain
Incandenza
MB
Wicked
Onbekende
for dummies
kokunai
Houssam
Rodger Dodger
XenHu
P Gizzle
Fircoal

[vgmmaster]

I don't know if a game with just serial killers is possible (I suppose it could be), but two mafia groups does sound likely.

Now we just have to figure out how many mafia members there are. I believe 3 is average. Going off of that, I'd say 6 total mafia members (3 per group)

[Roger Dodger]

gee, that narrowed it down alot. good work.

[HoussamTheGreat]

I think our main list of suspects should be the non-townies from the last game. Sorry H, but that includes you since Mach took you out as well.

FOS Senfive and Houssam

?? This is stupid. the townies in last game had eyes too! and they saw Mach's game too! And they would be equally inclined to get him out too.

based on that logic (and I am using that term VERY loosely), then we should FOS everyone!