Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[MountainLion]

Interesting... Mandy got scum for Koesen, but he was "unknown"...

FOS on MountainLion he's jumping all around constantly, and right now, I don't have anything else better to go on.

Unknown, but I'm sure Two-Face is mafia, and if he was killed by the Joker there must be two scum groups. Also the Joker must be part of a scum group that has the Janitor. It doesn't mean much now, but it's worth noting.

I've been jumping around because I like to get everyone involved...I've said that before. I don't like players getting a free pass through any day.

With the help of two of the night orderlies, I had to sedate derfderf34. He was trying to inflict harm upon himself and kept screaming random, nonsensical things.

I think this confirms derf as either a Fool or Jester, and should be ignored for a lynch. FOS all players who have targeted Derf for a lynch

Bullock's death is very confusing. What does it mean if he's a "Detective"? Is that the same as a cop?

I will be gone for the rest of the day. I will be back on later tonight or catch up tomorrow.

[MountainLion]

One more thing...

FOS The1exile because he hasn't posted in this thread since he voted for CMK on Day 2. Did he forget he was in this game? He's been posting everywhere else but in this thread. Here is his last post:

vote cmc "roman doctor" alert.

[Talapus]

Bullock's death is very confusing. What does it mean if he's a "Detective"? Is that the same as a cop?

It means just that. He was a detective and only able to investigate people...As I said before, this game doesn't have all the typical mafia roles in it...

I couldn't call him an investigator...he's always known as a detective. Besides, there was something else about his role which made me call it a "detective" role....But I'm not telling you why until the end of the game

[The1exile]

One more thing...

FOS The1exile because he hasn't posted in this thread since he voted for CMK on Day 2. Did he forget he was in this game? He's been posting everywhere else but in this thread. Here is his last post:

vote cmc "roman doctor" alert.

I'm not very into this game... sorta zoned out around the 20 pages mark and didn't follow as much as I should have. It's a good game but I frankly prefer smaller ones.

[Huckleberryhound]

vote exile


If he don wanna play...i say slay

[Fircoal]

Freezie, I don't think that you're evidence is that strong, but it may be true. I'm more on Jnd's side, I can see what he thought, but meh, it's a hard case to call.

[Skittles!]

This is interesting, but I really have no lead onto anyone.
But to the person that said Two-Face was mafia because he's unknown.
How would you know that? He could be really unknown, and not actually mafia.

[Koesen]

There are a lot of things I would like to say, but the only thing I'm allowed to say, is:


GO SCUM!

[Skittles!]

Ah, that confirms it. He was scum, but had an unkown scum role.

[Koesen]

Eh, oops...

Sorry, that was grief taking over for a moment. I'll shut up now.

[kwanton]

Heh. Wanna give us ur role too?

[MountainLion]

One more thing...

FOS The1exile because he hasn't posted in this thread since he voted for CMK on Day 2. Did he forget he was in this game? He's been posting everywhere else but in this thread. Here is his last post:

vote cmc "roman doctor" alert.

I'm not very into this game... sorta zoned out around the 20 pages mark and didn't follow as much as I should have. It's a good game but I frankly prefer smaller ones.

Your enthusiasm is contagious.

Talapus, I Vote Exile be Replaced unless he's willing to get off his ass and play this game.

[Skittles!]

I'm not prepared to read through 63 pages of mafia, but it would help to give me a lead. Hm, oh the agony.

[Neutrino]

I'm not prepared to read through 63 pages of mafia, but it would help to give me a lead. Hm, oh the agony.

I already tried that. Reading large pieces of text does not help in the least.

[Skittles!]

I'm not prepared to read through 63 pages of mafia, but it would help to give me a lead. Hm, oh the agony.

I already tried that. Reading large pieces of text does not help in the least.

I know. And uh, I remmeber something. You really don't post too much, Neutrino, why not? Submarining, are you? You never try to help with the town catch out the scum, and why is this? Is it because you're scum?

Vote: Neutrino. Give me a reason why I should not vote for you.

[MountainLion]

I'm not prepared to read through 63 pages of mafia, but it would help to give me a lead. Hm, oh the agony.

Skittles, you've only been out of the game for 20 of those pages.

[Skittles!]

I'm not prepared to read through 63 pages of mafia, but it would help to give me a lead. Hm, oh the agony.

Skittles, you've only been out of the game for 20 of those pages.

Only 20? I'll forget it just as I start posting!

[Neutrino]

Well what am I supposed to be posting about? Most of the action happens when i'm asleep. I can read what has been written, cast my vote and post some suspiscions, but there is no-one to get involved in a 10 page argument with.

[Skittles!]

As from I remember, you don't post that many suspicions. Most of the action happens when I'm asleep too, so that's not a very good excuse. I'm gonna keep my vote on you.

[Neutrino]

As from I remember, you don't post that many suspicions. Most of the action happens when I'm asleep too, so that's not a very good excuse. I'm gonna keep my vote on you.

I don't see you leading a mighty crusade against the forces of scum. In fact, the only reason you have out-posted me in this thread is because of the spam that your fool role entailed.

[Skittles!]

As from I remember, you don't post that many suspicions. Most of the action happens when I'm asleep too, so that's not a very good excuse. I'm gonna keep my vote on you.

I don't see you leading a mighty crusade against the forces of scum. In fact, the only reason you have out-posted me in this thread is because of the spam that your fool role entailed.

Eh, actually, I used my role to help the town, and I actually did help, unlike the other fool (Derf). I didn't post that much spam, at all. Maybe when I was dead, but I was dead.

[Neutrino]

As from I remember, you don't post that many suspicions. Most of the action happens when I'm asleep too, so that's not a very good excuse. I'm gonna keep my vote on you.

I don't see you leading a mighty crusade against the forces of scum. In fact, the only reason you have out-posted me in this thread is because of the spam that your fool role entailed.

Eh, actually, I used my role to help the town, and I actually did help, unlike the other fool (Derf). I didn't post that much spam, at all. Maybe when I was dead, but I was dead.

And Skittles, how can you expect me to have as many posts as you in this thread when I have only been playing for about half the time? Hell, the first day or so I was playing was spent purely re-reading and aclimatising to the situation.

[Skittles!]

As from I remember, you don't post that many suspicions. Most of the action happens when I'm asleep too, so that's not a very good excuse. I'm gonna keep my vote on you.

I don't see you leading a mighty crusade against the forces of scum. In fact, the only reason you have out-posted me in this thread is because of the spam that your fool role entailed.

Eh, actually, I used my role to help the town, and I actually did help, unlike the other fool (Derf). I didn't post that much spam, at all. Maybe when I was dead, but I was dead.

And Skittles, how can you expect me to have as many posts as you in this thread when I have only been playing for about half the time? Hell, the first day or so I was playing was spent purely re-reading and aclimatising to the situation.

I was out for 20 pages, remember? So that about evens up the time. You're trying to twist the arguement away from that you're scum, by saying that I have more posts than you. Saying I'm more active than you, it's not my fault I pay more attention to the game.

[MountainLion]

I'm still not sure if I should trust Mandy on this at this time, and even he's not sure what kind of cop he is. I personally would rather have him double check someone to make sure of his mental status before we start lynching on his whim.

And just wondering, does anyone else have this irrisitible urge to kill off Derf? I know people keep saying he's a fool and all, but Skittles was too and they posted coherent sentences and tried to somewhat help the town. So what's Derf's excuse?

QFT...The only post that made sense from derf was when i voted for him & he popped up to defend himself but otherwise it's been voting for people for having long nose hairs...

I think we are reading too much into the character names, anybody can search for batman characters & see who looks good & could be not well know so no counter claim comes out...cmckinney claimed & he got lynched because "his character description didn't match his pro-gotham claim". kalishnikov might not have done the smartest thing to get mandy to talk but it did the job & it has cleared up some of the confusion to a degree.

Kalish, if you are a vig then who did you kill in the 1st 2 nights?

The best lead in my eyes at this point could be Kernal_Kronic. He did NOT vote for kalishnikov who turned up scum and was an easy vote to make at the time. He voted for Derf who I believe is a Fool and has made an effort to help the town, even if it hasn't been much. We have no confirmation that Derf is a Fool, but I strongly feel he is at the very least a waste of a lynch. Kernal was online when there were only two votes needed to lynch kalish.

This is why I was suspicious of players voting for random at the beginning. You can look at vote counts and say this person or that person didn't vote for scum.

Skoffin was online when there were only two votes needed to lynch kalish, and he was hesitant to trust Mandy.

JND didn't vote for kalish either, but he wasn't online when the last four votes were made on kalish.

Kwanton more than anyone has seemed to be very careful with his vote...almost like you had to twist his arm to vote for kalish, and even after he voted for kalish, he still questioned Mandy.

I know some of you may be thinking how could anyone fully trust Mandy at the time? well, now that we know Mandy was Pro-Gotham and kalish was Anti-Gotham, we can view some of the players in this game as knowing who was on which side at the time.

Vote Kernal_Kronic

FOS Skoffin

[MountainLion]

I forgot to bold the part where he said "kalishnikov might not have done the smartest thing to get mandy to talk but it did the job & it has cleared up some of the confusion to a degree."

This sounds like he's defending kalish.

He also mentioned Derf "voting for people for having long nose hairs" which was not true. Huckleberry voted for long nose hairs. This means Kernal was skimming or simply made a mistake.