Skoffin's Madhouse mafia Day Seven

[Skittles!]

he answered to it, he's gotta be the one that killed Flores.

LOL worst logic EVA!

[animorpherv1]

I hate logic.

That's why logic mafia is (and isn't for seperate reasons) fun!

[nagerous]

Hmm. I think ani may be able to check dead people and see what role killed them. Ani, you need to see who killed exile, his death was fucked up and weird.

Yeah, I'll send that in during night. Doc protection plz!

You're like a forensic detective? So did you find out who killed someone the first night? and got told it was jack the ripper?? no actual player name.

[william18]

Hmm. I think ani may be able to check dead people and see what role killed them. Ani, you need to see who killed exile, his death was fucked up and weird.

We pretty much know it was a vigilante. We don't want to give the scum a basis on who is our vig.

We do? I never remember that happening...

All negetive outcomes if the scum killed exile.

1. Waste their kill on someone thats barley a threat
2. Killing exile would stop the Dito Exile argument, and suscpiscion might befall them.
3. Exile or Dito could easily be the day three lynch if their argument was still going on(which wouldve happened if they both survived.

I see no postives for the mafia, so they probably didn't do it(unless it's a noob mafia team).

[Innervision]

Vote Clive

Yay! Now dito won't be coming back! We'll have finally lynched out day 1 suspect!

[william18]

Hmm. I think ani may be able to check dead people and see what role killed them. Ani, you need to see who killed exile, his death was fucked up and weird.

Yeah, I'll send that in during night. Doc protection plz!

You're like a forensic detective? So did you find out who killed someone the first night? and got told it was jack the ripper?? no actual player name.

Well do to the fact he assumed the person who answered he argument first is Jack so I guess he didn't know.

[pancakemix]

Hmm. I think ani may be able to check dead people and see what role killed them. Ani, you need to see who killed exile, his death was fucked up and weird.

We pretty much know it was a vigilante. We don't want to give the scum a basis on who is our vig.

We do? I never remember that happening...

All negetive outcomes if the scum killed exile.

1. Waste their kill on someone thats barley a threat
2. Killing exile would stop the Dito Exile argument, and suscpiscion might befall them.
3. Exile or Dito could easily be the day three lynch if their argument was still going on(which wouldve happened if they both survived.

I see no postives for the mafia, so they probably didn't do it(unless it's a noob mafia team).

WIFOM. 'Nuf said.

[mandalorian2298]

Has Clive been lynched yet?

[william18]

Hmm. I think ani may be able to check dead people and see what role killed them. Ani, you need to see who killed exile, his death was fucked up and weird.

We pretty much know it was a vigilante. We don't want to give the scum a basis on who is our vig.

We do? I never remember that happening...

All negetive outcomes if the scum killed exile.

1. Waste their kill on someone thats barley a threat
2. Killing exile would stop the Dito Exile argument, and suscpiscion might befall them.
3. Exile or Dito could easily be the day three lynch if their argument was still going on(which wouldve happened if they both survived.

I see no postives for the mafia, so they probably didn't do it(unless it's a noob mafia team).

WIFOM. 'Nuf said.

I don't see a reason why the mafia would sacrifice all that for a WIFOM. Seems suprfluis to me.

[Sierra_Leon]

I agree with william. People who are most anxious to uncover a vig or SK are usually mafia. FOS ace for that suggestion.

[william18]

I agree with william. People who are most anxious to uncover a vig or SK are usually mafia. FOS ace for that suggestion.

If your read his post when he saw Clive make the mistake, it seemed a bit suscpiscious. Read:

What did my predesecor claim?

... Wouldn't you know what he claimed if it was your role? This is highly scummy, and I think clive needs to get lynched just for this comment.

A little jumpy don't you think?

Vote Clive
Since I unvoted.

[kwanton]

All negetive outcomes if the scum killed exile.

1. Waste their kill on someone thats barley a threat
2. Killing exile would stop the Dito Exile argument, and suscpiscion might befall them.
3. Exile or Dito could easily be the day three lynch if their argument was still going on(which wouldve happened if they both survived.

I see no postives for the mafia, so they probably didn't do it(unless it's a noob mafia team).

Um no. There really wasn't any legitimate suspicion on anyone else. So unless dito/clive is mafia there was no suspicion on a mafia member. There was no reason for mafia to think that any suspicion would befall them (#2) unless there was an investigation of some kind. And if there was an investigation that would be enough to debunk the dito/ex suspicions. Now for #1....who would you say is more of a threat? No one else was revealed yet. And you can't just look at roles in this situation, there are certain players who are always a threat. Exile is one of the people in this game who could have survived a bandwagon on him. And with a claim, if he convinced us he was telling the truth (and he probably could) he would not be lynched. If it was mafia then it was smart of them to take out a non-power claimed role when they can. As for number 3, is dito/clive still not an easy day3 lynch? Kill one off at night and let town lynch the other. BAM! 2 non-mafia deaths.

[sam_levi_11]

unvote (?) vote: sam_levi_11

wow so i laugh you dont know wone of the worlds most famous killers so you vote me.....

[nagerous]

It is better to focus on scum tells/ mafia hunts etc than who is doing the killings, especially when scum appears to be dying at night.

[/]

It is better to focus on scum tells/ mafia hunts etc than who is doing the killings, especially when scum appears to be dying at night.

It's very unlikely that two people with the same role died on consecutive nights.

Anyways, I think that lynching clive may not be necessary for him to die, why? Remember what one of our historians said (I forget which one) if they don't post two vote counts a day, they are mod killed. (I think, or maybe it was replaced?) So he might die anyways, and we save a lynch since Clive doesn't want to do anything either way.

[william18]

All negetive outcomes if the scum killed exile.

1. Waste their kill on someone thats barley a threat
2. Killing exile would stop the Dito Exile argument, and suscpiscion might befall them.
3. Exile or Dito could easily be the day three lynch if their argument was still going on(which wouldve happened if they both survived.

I see no postives for the mafia, so they probably didn't do it(unless it's a noob mafia team).

Um no. There really wasn't any legitimate suspicion on anyone else. So unless dito/clive is mafia there was no suspicion on a mafia member. There was no reason for mafia to think that any suspicion would befall them (#2) unless there was an investigation of some kind. And if there was an investigation that would be enough to debunk the dito/ex suspicions. Now for #1....who would you say is more of a threat? No one else was revealed yet. And you can't just look at roles in this situation, there are certain players who are always a threat. Exile is one of the people in this game who could have survived a bandwagon on him. And with a claim, if he convinced us he was telling the truth (and he probably could) he would not be lynched. If it was mafia then it was smart of them to take out a non-power claimed role when they can. As for number 3, is dito/clive still not an easy day3 lynch? Kill one off at night and let town lynch the other. BAM! 2 non-mafia deaths.

The point is that it's most likely a vig did that kill. Clive/Dito would have survived today if he didn''t mess up. Are you trying to point out other alternatives to justify the uncovering of a vig?

[fireedud]

I'm back. I read, but I'm very confused, I will reread.

[Neutrino]

Ok, after something like 5 days worth of re-reading, I have finally conquered this thread. I think I deserve a medal.

Anyways, don't we think we're being a little hasty with this Clive bandwagon? I, for one, find it a little excessive for a single line (admittedly a blindingly stupid and completely inadvisable single line) to warrant a lynch. To me, Clives questioning smacked of noobishness (and lazyness), but little actual scummyness. Ness. Of course, I haven't been around lately and didn't know Clive's skill level to any geat degree of accuracy before then anyway. Anyone with more up-to-date knowledge like to comment on Clive's likelyhood to make some massive, noobish mistake? I'm not convinced that he's guilty, but equally, I'm not convinced that he's innocent. We need more than a hugely rushed bandwagon if we want to make a difference with the first lynch of the game.

O' course, I'm not completely allied with the "Save the Clives" faction. William's been votehopping like there's no tomorrow, onto the person he is defending. Same with TWO (though he didn't directly ally himself with said faction). William changed his vote within 5 hours , for no adequately explainable reason. TWO wasn't far behind him in either case. I'm beginning to suspect some kind of bond there. FOS to 'em both.

Anyone else wonder what happened to a few of the early posters? Futurerichguy and Salubri spring to mind, though there may be others that I overlooked. Both are apparently answering PMs, since they haven't been replaced, but are doing a damn fine job of submarining. Hell, what happened to Salubri's famed Power Role o' Doom? Shouldn't it have attracted a certain number of pointy instruments to his general vicinity?
Hmmm, I just had an idea. Salubri mentioned some kind of "Kirbylike" power, didn't he? It could have some kind of tie-in with all the Terminator clones we've found lying around. Salubri kills 'em, takes their powers and turns them into himself.
Of course, this is a Skoffin game, and there likely is someone else with the ability to extrude copies of themself, if only to screw with us. I think it's worth investigating, provided we can coax Salubri out of hibernation, of course.

[william18]

Ok, after something like 5 days worth of re-reading, I have finally conquered this thread. I think I deserve a medal.

Anyways, don't we think we're being a little hasty with this Clive bandwagon? I, for one, find it a little excessive for a single line (admittedly a blindingly stupid and completely inadvisable single line) to warrant a lynch. To me, Clives questioning smacked of noobishness (and lazyness), but little actual scummyness. Ness. Of course, I haven't been around lately and didn't know Clive's skill level to any geat degree of accuracy before then anyway. Anyone with more up-to-date knowledge like to comment on Clive's likelyhood to make some massive, noobish mistake? I'm not convinced that he's guilty, but equally, I'm not convinced that he's innocent. We need more than a hugely rushed bandwagon if we want to make a difference with the first lynch of the game.

O' course, I'm not completely allied with the "Save the Clives" faction. William's been votehopping like there's no tomorrow, onto the person he is defending. Same with TWO (though he didn't directly ally himself with said faction). William changed his vote within 5 hours , for no adequately explainable reason. TWO wasn't far behind him in either case. I'm beginning to suspect some kind of bond there. FOS to 'em both.

Anyone else wonder what happened to a few of the early posters? Futurerichguy and Salubri spring to mind, though there may be others that I overlooked. Both are apparently answering PMs, since they haven't been replaced, but are doing a damn fine job of submarining. Hell, what happened to Salubri's famed Power Role o' Doom? Shouldn't it have attracted a certain number of pointy instruments to his general vicinity?
Hmmm, I just had an idea. Salubri mentioned some kind of "Kirbylike" power, didn't he? It could have some kind of tie-in with all the Terminator clones we've found lying around. Salubri kills 'em, takes their powers and turns them into himself.
Of course, this is a Skoffin game, and there likely is someone else with the ability to extrude copies of themself, if only to screw with us. I think it's worth investigating, provided we can coax Salubri out of hibernation, of course.

Well Clive isn't really a noob, but he doesn't alot anymore. He might make mistake like that, i think.

[Skittles!]

William, you're changing your mind all the time. Vote William. You're the biggest vote hopper I've seen for a very long time [even when I still played mafia before I left]. You defend Clive, but then you vote him, and when you still have your vote on him, you're undecided. If you are undecided, then just FOS him. Unless you think it's finally worth to vote your scum partner, and as Neutrino mention, TWO hops right in on that too.

[william18]

William, you're changing your mind all the time. Vote William. You're the biggest vote hopper I've seen for a very long time [even when I still played mafia before I left]. You defend Clive, but then you vote him, and when you still have your vote on him, you're undecided. If you are undecided, then just FOS him. Unless you think it's finally worth to vote your scum partner, and as Neutrino mention, TWO hops right in on that too.

A survivor isn't a bad lynch.

[Skittles!]

That's your defence? You defended him for how many pages, and then you decided to change your mind and join the bandwagon on a line because he didn't know what the person he replaced claimed as! Wow, great scum tell.

I would rather keep a survivor who is basically a nobody in a game than someone that vote hops and such.

[william18]

That's your defence? You defended him for how many pages, and then you decided to change your mind and join the bandwagon on a line because he didn't know what the person he replaced claimed as! Wow, great scum tell.

I would rather keep a survivor who is basically a nobody in a game than someone that vote hops and such.

This far in the game how many scum have we caught? Zero. Im pretty sure a survivor knows what side they want to be on at this point of the game.

[animorpherv1]

That's your defence? You defended him for how many pages, and then you decided to change your mind and join the bandwagon on a line because he didn't know what the person he replaced claimed as! Wow, great scum tell.

I would rather keep a survivor who is basically a nobody in a game than someone that vote hops and such.

We both forgot to blue our votes. sam- I'm not that much into movies with killers in them.

[fireedud]

I believe Clive does seem scummy. It's not impossible that he did read dito's claim, and said that to act like a n00b and avoid being lynched.

But I think william is even scummier. Vote William

If william turns out to be scum, Clive is next.