[Official] Holiday Mafia - Game Over!

[Kanin Usagi]

Why lynch the survivor instead of the claimed lyncher? If you want to know our "color" then lynch the lyncher, Spiesr.

Because you are most likely also a lyncher and just lying about it?

This^

The minute he was found out, Spiesr was very open with us. So, when its your word against his, his cred is greater than your's so far.

[MoB Deadly]

I respect IMB's excuse - unvote. And nice rebuttle, you are 100% right, I will guarantee say that exact phrase at some point through this game

[betiko]

I respect IMB's excuse - unvote. And nice rebuttle, you are 100% right, I will guarantee say that exact phrase at some point through this game

Why do you keep on calling IB "IMB"? there's not a single M in his username and you've been confusing me a little, lol

other than this, I guess its too late to start a forcing a claim now, people with something to hide will dodge it easy till the deadline.

As I said before, I'd like spiesr to vote soundman cause i'd rather not see him hammer.

[MoB Deadly]

I respect IMB's excuse - unvote. And nice rebuttle, you are 100% right, I will guarantee say that exact phrase at some point through this game

Why do you keep on calling IB "IMB"? there's not a single M in his username and you've been confusing me a little, lol

other than this, I guess its too late to start a forcing a claim now, people with something to hide will dodge it easy till the deadline.

As I said before, I'd like spiesr to vote soundman cause i'd rather not see him hammer.

OOPS. There's a guy in my clan - ironmanbravo and I always call him IMB. I have no idea why I gave that nickname to IB lol.

See this is exactly what I did not want. 2 days in a row we leave with no voting trends. Now mafia has a narrowed scope of who to shoot as we had multiple 3party claims.

We need to get ourselves organized and stop giving the mafia free night kills. And/or stop relying on night actions to get info.

[superkeener]

Just to keep from getting a 2 days without a kill, I will have to go with my previous tendency and VOTE spiesr

The other options that I previously mentioned haven't moved me enough to push for a vote on them. Even though I still have FoS on a couple of other players, this is how I fell I should currently vote.

[superkeener]

also, when exactly is the deadline for D2?

[pancakemix]

I'm setting the deadline at a week from today (Feb. 7).

[spiesr]

As I said before, I'd like spiesr to vote soundman cause i'd rather not see him hammer.

Okay. Vote Soundman

[MoB Deadly]

PCM, can we have a votecount please?

[pancakemix]

Vote Count

Spiesr - 4 (Nendreel, Little Witt, soundman, superkeener)
Mets - 1 (Betiko)
Edocsil - 2 (thechuck, animaniacks)
Soundman - 2 (IB, spiesr)

[MoB Deadly]

I dont like either "case" on mets or edoc. And I dont like lynching one of these 3rd parties, especially since the majority of us said we believe their claims. I am going to:

vote superkeener - He has been flip flopping back and forth all game long. Hes tripped my scumdar multiple times, but I had a gut feeling he was town. I am not so confident now...

I would like to see a claim from him. Evidence to follow hopefully......

[MoB Deadly]

Jan 16 - 11am - Non committal to D1 lynch or no lynch. Looks like trying to just "go with the flow"

Maybe a D1 lynch is good, but somehow I guess I just don't have enough to go on right now to just send a random person to the wolves. I never like to compare any mafia game to another as I typically give everyone the benefit of doubt in D1 unless there is something that grabs my attention.

Nothing has grabbed my attention just yet, but I am still open for a D1 lynch if evidence arises.

Jan 17 - 24 hours later - This is when spiesr and others said that no lynch wasn't necessarily bad.

I've thought about it a little more, and i am still in favor of a no lynch on D1.

Vote No Lynch

2 hours later: - We call him out on flip-flopping.... This is his response

I did explain my position. Go back and check. But just to ease your minds then...



UNVOTE

Leaving the office for lunch...... more evidence to follow....

[MoB Deadly]

Snuck this post in before we left


Here he says he does not think the misers are threatening, and the only player tripping his radar is edoc. Fosses everyone.

At least for me, the miser situation does not seem very threatening as of now, if indeed what they say is true. Also, I do not think that Snow is better than Heat or vice versa. I re-read D2 and besides the Miser brothers, the only thing coming up on my radar is edocsil.
FOS spiesr, soundman, edoicil

Then he just hops on the biggest bandwagon.

Just to keep from getting a 2 days without a kill, I will have to go with my previous tendency and VOTE spiesr

The other options that I previously mentioned haven't moved me enough to push for a vote on them. Even though I still have FoS on a couple of other players, this is how I fell I should currently vote.

Tell me superkeener, how did you come to the conclusion to cast a vote on spiesr, when we have a week until deadline is reached??

[MoB Deadly]

Ill be honest.... saying he was flip-flopping all game long was an exaggeration on my part. but like I said, pretty much none of his posts has "vibed well" with me this game. I had gut feeling though that he was town.

At this point I think we need to make some sort of move. I would like to see him claim, and then we choose the best candidate to lynch then.

[Nendreel]

I agree with MoB on Keener. He has caught my attention a few times and was going to be a high priority on my investigation list, but it may be best to pressure him now.
unvote, vote superkeener

[rishaed]

The case is well made. As such it has convinced me and I will vote superkeener.

[superkeener]

I dont think I have been flip flopping, just going with my gut as you with yours. I am the Baby New Year.

[superkeener]

Also, my 2nd vote for spiesr was before the deadline was announced.

[rishaed]

I dont think I have been flip flopping, just going with my gut as you with yours. I am the Baby New Year.

If you are going to claim make it a full claim . . . I mean Baby New Year doesn't sound all that bad, but checking a nameclaim is pretty much impossible . The reason is that we as town can't check to see if the Actions that you say you have are matching up with what with our investigatives can tell us.

[superkeener]

Ok. I will make a full claim. Since this is my first mafia game on CC, I did not want to break any house rules. Full claim coming soon

[MoB Deadly]

You didn't have to rush it and claim right away. It was my vote and opinion to see you claim. There are quite a few other players in the game. The important defense I wanted from you was my question to you in blue. but as others said, a half-claim is even worse now. Now you have no choice but to fully claim.

[betiko]

I went back to build a mets case but putting things together I'm not convinced anymore.
Also I m not convinced about superkeener anymore. Can the edoc acusers make a proper case on edoc?

unvote

fastposted

[superkeener]

I am the Baby New Yeat. I am a roleblocker alligned with the Town.

[betiko]

ebwop: I don't know why I wrote "anymore" for superkeener as I've never really been on this case after he started posting real stuff.

nevertheless, I'm surprised to see he posted something suggesting it will take a lot of thinking to make his full claim in the meanwhile

fastposted

why did you have to think about it keener?

[superkeener]

I didnt really have to think about it. Just had to take care some some stuff for work.