Mine was somewhat of a pity vote for the difficult situation he was in - I think the town JOAT should have had a name.
I was being truthful in my case that if he was scum, he probably wouldn't have killed Mets, and if he had, then he wouldn't have admitted it. I don't think his scum buddies would have tried something like that on someone playing their first game. Townies should have seen that and defended him more.