Moderator: Cartographers
Androidz wrote:Hmm, you havent done any of the suggestion we all made to help you. And adding those circles on the pizza looks ugly. Makeing it the slices attack only the ones left & Righs slices and the one straight forward is the best option.
captaincanuck wrote:Androidz wrote:Hmm, you havent done any of the suggestion we all made to help you. And adding those circles on the pizza looks ugly. Makeing it the slices attack only the ones left & Righs slices and the one straight forward is the best option.
The circles (the pizza tables) were one of the suggestions made. Scroll up the thread.
We have taken away many slices, which was a good suggestion.
We tried the perspective thing (another suggestion) which doesn't work and I think we'll scrap it.
Our intention is that the slices will only attack to the left and the right, not across. We're trying to find away to make that clearer without covering the things with attack lines.
Keep in mind guys, this is a map designed by an 8-year-old (sensfan) with his dad's (captaincanuck) help and is for younger gamers on Conquer Club. It isn't intended to be photo realistic. It isn't intended to represent a historical battle.
It's intended to be cheesy and fun!
captaincanuck wrote:Our intention is that the slices will only attack to the left and the right, not across. We're trying to find away to make that clearer without covering the things with attack lines.
Androidz wrote:Makeing it the slices attack only the ones left & Righs slices and the one straight forward is the best option.
Juan_Bottom wrote:Have you two mapmakers tried printing this map out and testing it yet? It helps to play the maps with your Risk game pieces. Then you can doodle on the map too, and try new things.
Androidz wrote:Makeing it the slices attack only the ones left & Righs slices and the one straight forward is the best option.
Juan_Bottom wrote:I'm not entirely won over on that idea. But I see what you're saying about the slices only having a single border. They may have to play it and see.
Androidz wrote:3. It just seem "right"
sensfan wrote:Juan_Bottom wrote:Have you two mapmakers tried printing this map out and testing it yet? It helps to play the maps with your Risk game pieces. Then you can doodle on the map too, and try new things.
GOOD idea!
sensfan wrote:The reason why i love this map is because it looks real cute.
I usaully play on cute maps (No offence on the other non-cute interesting maps)
like doodle earth, arctic, crossword, duck and cover.
We could be dropping the perspective but that's just an idea.
But should we drop the perspective?
Please tell us if you like the perspective.
AndyDufresne wrote:sensfan wrote:The reason why i love this map is because it looks real cute.
I usaully play on cute maps (No offence on the other non-cute interesting maps)
like doodle earth, arctic, crossword, duck and cover.
We could be dropping the perspective but that's just an idea.
But should we drop the perspective?
Please tell us if you like the perspective.
I'm all for making cute maps (I like the look of Duck and Cover and Doodle Earth), but this idea just feels bad. There are hundreds of ideas out there...that would be more interesting than Pizza.
--Andy
Return to Melting Pot: Map Ideas
Users browsing this forum: No registered users