Non-VANILLA Game 3 *Game Over* 14 Winners

[everywhere116]

Back on topic.

[Selin]

you know wat, im on the verge of insanity so vote-sheepofdumb

JND... You have to realize, man... We all need to vote for the SAME person... Splitting up our votes doesn't do jack.

first warning of AD to jnd

fine UNVOTE ill use my vote for the greater good, and not for a crackpot scheme

You look scummy by voting and unvoting a lot... Be careful

second warning of AD to jnd

All in 7-8 minutes. Somehow strange to me. Did AD realised that jnd looked scummy and tried to stop him talking too much? And he didnt FOS him, but voted Primate who is inactive. Looks like he protects jnd and tries to draw attention to other players.

FOS Anarkistdream

.

That was my post on day 2.
We learned that jnd is mafia. Now this conversations make me more suspicious about AD.

Again FOS Anarkistdream

[Fircoal]

The sweaty kind.

[Selin]

My second FOS Hitman

In addition to his erratic posts on day 2, jnd's post about Hitman made me more suspicious about him. The only paradox in this suspicion is that unriggable who was killed last night defended Hitman exactly three times in different posts on day 2! Nevertheless I still I FOS him.

[Selin]

Back to analysis of the game:

There is something strange having only 1 kill each night with 24 players. After Fircoals modkilling Unit_2 we learned that he was the vig. That's more strange for me. Only one mafia in a 24 player game and we have a vig on top of it. That's simply strange!

I can think of two possibilities:
a) A big mafia or a medium one with recruiting powers, so that they become bigger.
b) A mafia and a serial killer. Although aimless' basic analysis showed very weak probabilities, we have to think of other combinations, eg. one night SK didn't do his choice, second night doc/role blocker protected townies or he chose same target as mafia or he chose bulletproof townie etc.

[Selin]

I remembered one more issue about AD in addition to my above post FOSing him.

He skimmed the death of mandolorian (night 1) on day two (page 44/45). However I'm not sure, if that is something positive or negative for him. On the one hand as being mafia he should have known it, on the other hand most of the time it is mafia who skims.

[Aimless]

As a gut feeling, I would say that there's about one chance in five that AD is scum. Enough of a chance for me to FOS him, but not enough to vote, unless other evidence comes along.

He did defend jnd, but it was more along the lines of trying to clue in a n00b; and frankly, AD is smart enough that if he were mafia, he wouldn't have tried to tie himself to jnd at all.

[Anarkistsdream]

While I'm annoyed at Hitman, I'm only halfway convinced he's scum. I'm more concerned about the way AD was defending jnd back around page 60. I was willing to pass it off as just helping a newbie, but now that jnd has turned up scum I think this casts it is a different light.

FOS Hitman
FOS AD

As I said then... Sorry, I won't be helpful anymore...

I just feel that I am one of the 'senior' players on this site, and it is my job to help everyone understand... I helped Mountainlion, too... I want people to understand and enjoy the game... My first game "Dead Man's Gulch" I was lynched almost immediately because I said stupid things and didn't understand... I got really frustrated and, luckily, had the beer to help calm me down... This game works me up, and I like that...

But, I also don't want true help to ever be seen as a 'helping the mafia' tactic...

SELIN, apparently you seem to be skimming too!!!

I already provided my defense...

Try reading and you will know!

[Selin]

I suspect also a cult. And I have a FOS for this role. That is red bull. I don't know if he is the leader or member. A post of red bull brought me to that idea stating that he is "pro town or at least no mafia".

[Selin]

While I'm annoyed at Hitman, I'm only halfway convinced he's scum. I'm more concerned about the way AD was defending jnd back around page 60. I was willing to pass it off as just helping a newbie, but now that jnd has turned up scum I think this casts it is a different light.

FOS Hitman
FOS AD

As I said then... Sorry, I won't be helpful anymore...

I just feel that I am one of the 'senior' players on this site, and it is my job to help everyone understand... I helped Mountainlion, too... I want people to understand and enjoy the game... My first game "Dead Man's Gulch" I was lynched almost immediately because I said stupid things and didn't understand... I got really frustrated and, luckily, had the beer to help calm me down... This game works me up, and I like that...

But, I also don't want true help to ever be seen as a 'helping the mafia' tactic...

SELIN, apparently you seem to be skimming too!!!

I already provided my defense...

Try reading and you will know!

I know that you defended yourself, but when I saw you voting Hitman directly at the beginning of day 3 (one of the first posts on day 3 although we have 3 days for discussing etc) somehow I got an impression that you were trying to quickly bring our attention back to the suspects of day 2 about Hitman.

[Anarkistsdream]

While I'm annoyed at Hitman, I'm only halfway convinced he's scum. I'm more concerned about the way AD was defending jnd back around page 60. I was willing to pass it off as just helping a newbie, but now that jnd has turned up scum I think this casts it is a different light.

FOS Hitman
FOS AD

As I said then... Sorry, I won't be helpful anymore...

I just feel that I am one of the 'senior' players on this site, and it is my job to help everyone understand... I helped Mountainlion, too... I want people to understand and enjoy the game... My first game "Dead Man's Gulch" I was lynched almost immediately because I said stupid things and didn't understand... I got really frustrated and, luckily, had the beer to help calm me down... This game works me up, and I like that...

But, I also don't want true help to ever be seen as a 'helping the mafia' tactic...

SELIN, apparently you seem to be skimming too!!!

I already provided my defense...

Try reading and you will know!

I know that you defended yourself, but when I saw you voting Hitman directly at the beginning of day 3 (one of the first posts on day 3 although we have 3 days for discussing etc) somehow I got an impression that you were trying to quickly bring our attention back to the suspects of day 2 about Hitman.

WHAT?!?!?! I AM!!!

Hitman is mafia!

[Selin]

While I'm annoyed at Hitman, I'm only halfway convinced he's scum. I'm more concerned about the way AD was defending jnd back around page 60. I was willing to pass it off as just helping a newbie, but now that jnd has turned up scum I think this casts it is a different light.

FOS Hitman
FOS AD

As I said then... Sorry, I won't be helpful anymore...

I just feel that I am one of the 'senior' players on this site, and it is my job to help everyone understand... I helped Mountainlion, too... I want people to understand and enjoy the game... My first game "Dead Man's Gulch" I was lynched almost immediately because I said stupid things and didn't understand... I got really frustrated and, luckily, had the beer to help calm me down... This game works me up, and I like that...

But, I also don't want true help to ever be seen as a 'helping the mafia' tactic...

SELIN, apparently you seem to be skimming too!!!

I already provided my defense...

Try reading and you will know!

I know that you defended yourself, but when I saw you voting Hitman directly at the beginning of day 3 (one of the first posts on day 3 although we have 3 days for discussing etc) somehow I got an impression that you were trying to quickly bring our attention back to the suspects of day 2 about Hitman.

WHAT?!?!?! I AM!!!

Hitman is mafia!

Honestly said, I believe that too. Hitman lied about his experience etc. I don't see a motive behind that if he is townie. But if he is mafia that makes sense, trying to show himself as a noob!

So, in that respect I'm with you.

[Anarkistsdream]

Okay... I am just saying... He is.

[pancakemix]

How do you know?

[Anarkistsdream]

How do you know?

Gut feeling.

[pancakemix]

I still want to hear from him. If I don't hear from him by tomorrow, he's got my vote.

[Anarkistsdream]

I still want to hear from him. If I don't hear from him by tomorrow, he's got my vote.

Fair enough, dude.

[pancakemix]

I still want to hear from him. If I don't hear from him by tomorrow, he's got my vote.

Fair enough, dude.

It's not that I don't trust you, it's that I don't trust gut feelings. My gut feeling right now is that I might throw up. That's probably right, though.

[red bull]

I suspect also a cult. And I have a FOS for this role. That is red bull. I don't know if he is the leader or member. A post of red bull brought me to that idea stating that he is "pro town or at least no mafia".

can i see the post please and yes i am not mafia or a cult AND DONT MAKE ME JOIN YOURS !!!!!!!!

[Primate]

heh.

AD's 'gut' has my support.

I'm not going to vote, cause of how silly quick you do things round here, but I'm prefer AD to hitman on this matter.

[sheepofdumb]

I will support the gut.

Red bull is roleclaiming in his own special way. Fos red bull

[Shadowstar]

heh.

AD's 'gut' has my support.

I'm not going to vote, cause of how silly quick you do things round here, but I'm prefer AD to hitman on this matter.

Same thing here, but not enough to vote. Last time we relied on guts, we got our cop lynched. I hope this won't turn out the same.

$5 that he's the doc

[Hitman079]

i've read
and here's my post
now everyone can remember to pounce on me again
i will be laughing from my grave when you lynch a townie

[Hitman079]

if you looked back, i unvoted, but Fircoal counted it anyways.

[Hitman079]

jnd seems suspicious...he says he's a noob..but he doesn't look it to me..besides we do have a deadline, right? or someone back there said "no deadline"..anyways
vote jnd
my spidey sense tells me people will switch their votes to me again

note: these posts were on page 77

umm.unvote jnd?

edit: replaced "78" with "77"