Bizarro World Mafia (Day 8) Game over, Mafia win!

[trestain]

AD are you 100% sure because xen claims to has undeniable proof. if you cannot be as sure as xen i think we should go with xen on this one and look at puff later

[I GOT SERVED]

I uhh....wow

I have no idea who to vote for. I'll just wait and see how this one unfolds...

[Anarkistsdream]

I am 100% sure.... And I am not a cop.

[I GOT SERVED]

I am 100% sure.... And I am not a cop.

For some reason, this tipped me off that you might be a jester.....

[XenHu]

I am 100% sure.... And I am not a cop.

*sigh*

Alright. Puff first. Then Senfive.. Agreed?

Un-vote:Senfive

Vote:Puff

-X

[I GOT SERVED]

Agreed.

Vote: Puff

[Anarkistsdream]

Unvote

Vote: Puff

Just to make sure.

[trestain]

xen you have confused me, are you saying that you are not 100% sure in senfives guilt now??? you couldn't have been that sure if you are willing to switch your vote like that.

unvote senfive

[XenHu]

xen you have confused me, are you saying that you are not 100% sure in senfives guilt now??? you couldn't have been that sure if you are willing to switch your vote like that.

unvote senfive

I am. However, I also trust AD's judgment and at this time, more so then mine.

-X

[Aimless]

Well... this is interesting.

Again, with the same caveat as before: if Puff is not scum, would the vig please take care of AD overnight?

Unvote
Vote: Puff

[for dummies]

wow xenhu. For being so gungho on lynching senfive switching to puff doesn't make sense. If you knew because of your role that senfive was mafia there would be no reason to switch your vote. For all we know AD is also mafia and is trying to get the attention away from Senfive. If you are sure Senfive is mafia, say so and we will lynch him. If not, why did you lie to us before?

[XenHu]

f*ck..

I didn't lie..

*sigh*

Un-vote: Puff


Vote:Senfive

-X

[Anarkistsdream]

I'm telling you both it would be a SURE THING to lynch Puff.

[Anarkistsdream]

Do I need to roleclaim????

[trestain]

i thought i would point this out aswell

I uhh....wow

I have no idea who to vote for. I'll just wait and see how this one unfolds...

followed 4 minutes later by this

Agreed.

Vote: Puff

[Anarkistsdream]

FOS: I got Served

[I GOT SERVED]

After re-reading Xen's post, I was convinced.

And if I have to, then I'll roleclaim.

[mandalorian2298]

Well... this is interesting.

Again, with the same caveat as before: if Puff is not scum, would the vig please take care of AD overnight?

Unvote
Vote: Puff

Well, said. I must say that this is a strange move for a townie Narc, as we had a meaningfull bandwagon allready (that was going to yield a mafia at best, and rid us of jester, at worst) and your accusation of Puff could have splited the vote (since this game hasn't been real active before couple hours ago when senfive claimed Doc). Well, since town responded, to this and the result will get us one less worry either way, unvote
vote puff
Might I ask what evidence turned up so suddenly, Narc?

[Aimless]

wow xenhu. For being so gungho on lynching senfive switching to puff doesn't make sense. If you knew because of your role that senfive was mafia there would be no reason to switch your vote. For all we know AD is also mafia and is trying to get the attention away from Senfive. If you are sure Senfive is mafia, say so and we will lynch him. If not, why did you lie to us before?

We, apparently, have two semi-claims with two guaranteed scum. Frankly, I don't think it matter which one we lynch today, as long as we lynch them. If AD is lying and Puff is town, then we vig AD tonight and lynch Senfive tomorrow.

As I see some merit in your post - ie, that it's possible AD is doing this as a ruse to distract us from Senfive, I think that is actually a point in favor of lynching Puff, since if Puff is town, we will have found two guaranteed scum.

Actually... I think we've found three. FOS for dummies. Your post strikes me as an attempt to sow confusion amongst us, possibly trying to save both of your scum mates.

[Anarkistsdream]

Wait until he hangs, Aimless....

You will see I am right... I have no fear, and no need to defend.

[Aimless]

In fact, here's what I think the optimum game plan would be :

We lynch Puff today. If he's town, we vig AD tonight and lynch Senfive tomorrow.

If Puff is scum, we vig Senfive tonight. Then if Senfive is town, we lynch XenHu tomorrow.

If both Puff and Senfive turn up scum, then I think my case against for dummies is pretty strong, but it merits more consideration.

[trestain]

i think we should be looking at these claims of AD and zen surely they both can't be telling the truth, if so i think we have both a day and night cop.

both xen and AD however, even though they have both claimed they know 100% that they are right, xen has changed his vote and AD has started to FOS someone else, so im wondering how credible either of there claims are.
Which makes me wonder why

[Anarkistsdream]

An FOS is saying what I think... I didn't unvote... My claim is 100%, and you are reaching.

[mandalorian2298]

1. for dummies: if Puff and senfive, lynches bring us mafia (one way or the vig way )

2. Xen: If you are a pro-town then please ignore dummie and let's finish the lynch on Puff, since we can lynch only one person today. Whichever way that lynch goes, we can go back to lynching senfive tommorow. No matter the amount of night-kills, either you, Aimless (for whom I'm pretty sure that he isn't mafia) or I will remain alive to go on with an iron case against senfive ('specially if mafia kills you, so don't sweat about that ).
If, however, you and Narc are mafia and are trying to stall this day to a no lynch, you're welcome to try

[for dummies]

i wasn't trying to sow confusion i was asking a legitimate question: If Xenhu was so sure that Senfive was mafia then why did he change his vote away from Senfive?

At least AD's actions back up his claims because of that;
Vote: Puff