TOMBSTONE MAFIA *Day 7* MAFIA WIN!!!!!!

[MountainLion]

I was just going to ask how many roles there are and what they are, but maybe they are suppose to be secret?

[AK_iceman]

I was just going to ask how many roles there are and what they are, but maybe they are suppose to be secret?

There are 21 roles.

[AK_iceman]

I was just going to ask how many roles there are and what they are, but maybe they are suppose to be secret?

There are 21 roles.

Edit: In this game.

[The1exile]

Multiple mafia's is also possible with the number of players we have. 3 on each side wouldn't be too far out of the question. Or perhaps a mafia/cult combo? Hmmm... again, this is all just conjecture and we have nothing to go on yet.

6 mafia for 21 players? Eh... could happen. We won't really know until we see the night kill results.

[AK_iceman]

Multiple mafia's is also possible with the number of players we have. 3 on each side wouldn't be too far out of the question. Or perhaps a mafia/cult combo? Hmmm... again, this is all just conjecture and we have nothing to go on yet.

6 mafia for 21 players? Eh... could happen. We won't really know until we see the night kill results.

Well... from what I've seen happen in multiple mafia situations, is that the mafia try and kill each other because the other mafia group is a bigger threat than the town. In one of my games, I had 25 players and 2 mafia groups with 4 mafia each, and the town still won because they kept killing each other.
So, if mafia start dying at night, I would assume it was multiple mafia groups rather than a very lucky vigilante.

[jnd94]

well i wasnt mafia.

If you're going to lie after death, that's just retarded.

Syzygy points at Jnd saying. This guy is Mafia. the town argees and lynches him.
You have lynched Jnd (Mafia)
After all the shock Aimless steals Jnd's new car.

It is now night yo uhave 2 days to send in choices.

well i wasnt pro-town, but i wasnt mafia. I was the SK.

[MountainLion]

I've never played mafia on a forum before. I've played with about 15-20 people with 3 mafia, 1 cop and 1 doctor. Is there a "doctor" in this game?

I have a theory on sheep: if he's new to mafia on CC then he's probably just excited, hence the posts at the beginning. Then when he was voted on he got defensive because IMO the last thing he wants is to be taken out first in his first ever game. I'm a "newb" here too and I think it would suck. No one wants to be taken out of the game, but those who've never played before could be upset about it more than those who've played before cause it's just another game.

What do you all think?

[AK_iceman]

I've never played mafia on a forum before. I've played with about 15-20 people with 3 mafia, 1 cop and 1 doctor. Is there a "doctor" in this game?

That is the only noob mistake I'm going to let you get away with.

I am going to assume that yes, there is a doctor. Probably more than 1, maybe 1 is locked until the first doctor dies. But you never want to ask who the doctor is, because sometimes he just might be dumb enough to answer, and since the doctor is one of the best pro-town roles, if he reveals himself he will be dead.

[The1exile]

well i wasnt mafia.

If you're going to lie after death, that's just retarded.

Syzygy points at Jnd saying. This guy is Mafia. the town argees and lynches him.
You have lynched Jnd (Mafia)
After all the shock Aimless steals Jnd's new car.

It is now night yo uhave 2 days to send in choices.

well i wasnt pro-town, but i wasnt mafia. I was the SK.

PM Fircoal.

[wicked]

forgot about SK. Cult's always a possibilty too, but I've yet only seen that over on mafia scum. of course not knowing where Ank used to play, no way to tell what he might include.

[AK_iceman]

forgot about SK. Cult's always a possibilty too, but I've yet only seen that over on mafia scum. of course not knowing where Ank used to play, no way to tell what he might include.

We've had a couple games with a cult over here at CC. So don't rule that out so fast.

[wicked]

No way IC. The COP is one of the best pro-town roles, much better than the doc.

[wicked]

We've had a couple games with a cult over here at CC. So don't rule that out so fast.

really? btw, wasn't ruling it out, just saying it's not as common.

[AK_iceman]

No way IC. The COP is one of the best pro-town roles, much better than the doc.

"One of the best" implies more than 1. Yes, I would include cop and vigilante in that group as well as doctor.

[pancakemix]

I alway consider a theme before I think about possible roles. The theme is Tombstone, right? So that basically eliminates cult as a possibility. As I recall from Tombstone, there were no cults.

[The1exile]

We've had a couple games with a cult over here at CC. So don't rule that out so fast.

really? btw, wasn't ruling it out, just saying it's not as common.

We had cult in the Pulp Fiction that won, primarily because the cult recruited the vig.

[wicked]

this'll be my last post on this, as we're not getting anywhere. Cop & Mayor are the best, roleblocker & doc & vig next (b/c they're never sure who to act on usually)

[MountainLion]

[But you never want to ask who the doctor is, because sometimes he just might be dumb enough to answer, and since the doctor is one of the best pro-town roles, if he reveals himself he will be dead.

sorry I just assumed the doctor wouldn't be that stupid, but I guess you never know. I was just asking is there WAS a doctor that's all.

I don't know what a "cult" would be...help?

[pancakemix]

We've had a couple games with a cult over here at CC. So don't rule that out so fast.

really? btw, wasn't ruling it out, just saying it's not as common.

We had cult in the Pulp Fiction that won, primarily because the cult recruited the vig.

Cult won in Halo mafia because everyone deadbeated.

[AK_iceman]

I alway consider a theme before I think about possible roles. The theme is Tombstone, right? So that basically eliminates cult as a possibility. As I recall from Tombstone, there were no cults.

It doesn't have to be an actual cult, it could just be a group of people.

[pancakemix]

MountianLion, click here

It's a list of common mafia roles. It should prove useful to you.

[MountainLion]

thanks pancake

[pancakemix]

Any time. You now owe me 1 premium membership. jk

[unriggable]

No way IC. The COP is one of the best pro-town roles, much better than the doc.

"One of the best" implies more than 1. Yes, I would include cop and vigilante in that group as well as doctor.

Only problem is how the vig knows nothing, and kills pretty much anybody they find suspicious.

[mandalorian2298]

We had cult in the Pulp Fiction that won, primarily because the cult recruited the vig.

I apologize for writting about another game, but I MUST say that recruiting a smart vig (everywhere)is the only reason we won (since I made a fool out of my self on every possible occasion, lynched a cult cop and finally suicided under Doctor's protection. ).

On a more constructive note, I think it is possible that there is a Cult in this game. Most recent Tombstone-related thing I red was a comic book in wich there was some kind of anti-vice religius/political movement in Tombstone (who's leader was one of the bad guys).
One the topic of possible 2nd mafia, it could be possible. If you read the opening scene, you will see that Narc shows townies as being cought in a crossfire between the Earp's and the Clanton's.