Logic dictates that there is a God!

[Neoteny]

Good grief! Evolution isn't logical.


Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

I was going to see it, but it was out of theaters before I had a chance. Ben Stein is a quack when it comes to science, however.

[jay_a2j]

Good grief! Evolution isn't logical.


Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

I was going to see it, but it was out of theaters before I had a chance. Ben Stein is a quack when it comes to science, however.

It's still playing, but not in NY.

http://www.expelledthemovie.com/theaterap.php

[Neoteny]

Yeah, it's only playing in the Atlanta area near me... I'm not driving an hour and a half to see it, unfortunately. It'll be cheaper to rent the DVD. However, if I had gotten in to see it locally, I could have seen it without economically supporting the movie. Perhaps I'll just borrow it from someone.

[MeDeFe]

Does the internet count as "locally"?

[Juan_Bottom]

Good grief! Evolution isn't logical.


Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

I was going to see it, but it was out of theaters before I had a chance. Ben Stein is a quack when it comes to science, however.

Did anyone see his promotional appearance on THE TODAY SHOW? He is a quack when it comes to economics too. And no, Mr. Stein, Creationism should not be taught in public schools.

[Neoteny]

Good grief! Evolution isn't logical.


Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

I was going to see it, but it was out of theaters before I had a chance. Ben Stein is a quack when it comes to science, however.

Did anyone see his promotional appearance on THE TODAY SHOW? He is a quack when it comes to economics too. And no, Mr. Stein, Creationism should not be taught in public schools.

I suppose I have more respect for him on his economics, since that is what he actually studied, and I don't know anything about the subject. All I know is he is a quack in at least one department he is vocal in, so I do lose respect for his overall views.

Does the internet count as "locally"?

I was considering legally acquiring a video of the movie, but wasn't sure if it was worth the bandwidth.

[heavycola]

I've been trying to get hold of a copy of Expelled. It's not on piratebay yet and i doubt it will gbet shown here. But the marketing is interesting - apart from the word 'pastors' there is nothing on the websiet home page to suggest its fundy agenda. Why not? Because intelligent documentary watchers aren't generally wackjobs?

BTW if anyone knows where i can watch it online or in the UK, please let me know

[Juan_Bottom]

I have dail-up, so I can't check, but isn't it available at BITTORNADO? The legality of course being a little shakey......

[suggs]

Jay, this was your best thread I thought.
But I'm not sure I fully understand it.
Care to elaborate?

[Simon Viavant]

Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

They spliced several clips to get the shot of that evolutionist saying something offensive.

[jay_a2j]

Jay, this was your best thread I thought.
But I'm not sure I fully understand it.
Care to elaborate?

On what?

[CoffeeCream]

Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

Yeah I saw it. Provoked a lot of good thought. Many people applauded and I heard some people talking on the way out that it was about time the other side was heard. It didn't really get into the whole evolution vs. intelligent design, which one is right and which one is wrong. It was more like how people who don't subscribe to the evolutionary theory of origins are not given fair consideration of their points.

[The1exile]

On what?

I'm guessing, why you believe in god, why you choose to claim "logic dictates" it, what kind of logic it is, and how you've managed to argue for hundreds of pages here and not get convinced.

[heavycola]

Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

Yeah I saw it. Provoked a lot of good thought. Many people applauded and I heard some people talking on the way out that it was about time the other side was heard. It didn't really get into the whole evolution vs. intelligent design, which one is right and which one is wrong. It was more like how people who don't subscribe to the evolutionary theory of origins are not given fair consideration of their points.

What about flat earthers? Should they be given their classroom time as well? plenty of evdience for that in the OT.
What about people who believe in the Inuit creation story? What about Hindu creation?

Or, how about you take your kids and homeschool them if you want to teach them unsubstantiated fairy stories, or alternatively have some faith in the overwhelming scientific consensus, arrived at over the past 150 years by men and women who have devoted their lives to its study, and may of whom had their faith sorely tested while doign so?

Muppets. All of you. Muppets.

[jay_a2j]

Or, how about you take your kids and homeschool them if you want to teach them unsubstantiated fairy stories....

Like evolution? It is far more logical that God created people than by mere chance evolving from muck and if you can't see this, it's because you don't want to see it.


exile, It's been explained and quite thoroughly, in all these many pages. In a nut shell..... Life can not come from non-life, and using that as a given, in order for life to exist, something has always had to exist, that is living and has the ability to create.

[heavycola]

Or, how about you take your kids and homeschool them if you want to teach them unsubstantiated fairy stories....

Like evolution? It is far more logical that God created people than by mere chance evolving from muck and if you can't see this, it's because you don't want to see it.

230 pages and you still haven't got a clue what you are talking about...

EDIT: So it boils down to a failure of imagination in your case, jay. You can't get your head around the idea of evolution, that's all.

[Juan_Bottom]

Jay ure dumb. You may want to check out the evolution v creationism thread.

[Dancing Mustard]

Like evolution? It is far more logical that God created people than by mere chance evolving from muck and if you can't see this, it's because you don't want to see it.

Actually it's far more logical that people evolved from more simplistic life forms by a long process chance-governed refinement, than that some mystical invisible mega-fairy conjoured them up out of nothing. If you can't see this, it's because you don't want to see it.

[joecoolfrog]

Hey anyone see that new movie by Ben Stein, Expelled?

Yeah I saw it. Provoked a lot of good thought. Many people applauded and I heard some people talking on the way out that it was about time the other side was heard. It didn't really get into the whole evolution vs. intelligent design, which one is right and which one is wrong. It was more like how people who don't subscribe to the evolutionary theory of origins are not given fair consideration of their points.

Think for one moment about the statement ' it was about time the other side was heard '
The other side is in fact heard every day in the environment where it belongs, be it church,temple,mosque or synagogue. It was also generally taught as the definitive explanation of creation for over 1000 years with rather unfortunate consequences for those who cared to question it, those who dismiss evolution are at worst dismissed as cranks in comparison. There is no great conspiracy against creationism,it has simply been superceeded by a theory the most people accept as far more likely and logical, except within a narrow religious framework creationism has no role to play in modern education and it should certainly not be considered in any way scientific.

[liamo6969]

lads firstly i dont believe in a "GOD" but i also believe its a personal choice!

In your search for meaning people often follow the wrong road. It starts with philosophy! its fundamental questions are
-who am i
-where do i come from
-why are we here
-and most importantly, why

every person will have a different quest for meaning and it will pose infinte numbers of mental paradoxes!!
I believe that the god most people believe in is their only way to explain, bypass or understand these questions.

It is the clear inability to provide a definitive answer to these questions that leads people to believe in a god! the reason they believe is because they feel deep down(they want to and hence need to) that there is a meaning to their life.

which in a simple persons mind equals "their" god!

[Dancing Mustard]

I'm sorry, but your post is not irrational, bigoted or trolly enough to be welcome in this thread. Please excuse yourself immediately and do not return until you have something unconstructive to add.

[liamo6969]

well if your lookin for that sorta shit den i also believe (just didnt want to say earlier) taht anybody who claims there is a god is mentally weak, dependant on hopes that arnt there because they cant find enough reason in there on lifes to find meaning. obviously they are seeing themselves as failures in their own eyes without admitting it! live for your self if your able, only the weak and puny say they are livng for there "god" doing his wil and all that shit.
hence anybody that believes in a god is self pronouncing there mental inferiority!! .

[Juan_Bottom]

well if your lookin for that sorta shit den i also believe (just didnt want to say earlier) taht anybody who claims there is a god is mentally weak, dependant on hopes that arnt there because they cant find enough reason in there on lifes to find meaning. obviously they are seeing themselves as failures in their own eyes without admitting it! live for your self if your able, only the weak and puny say they are livng for there "god" doing his wil and all that shit.
hence anybody that believes in a god is self pronouncing there mental inferiority!! .

Serious? Awesome. Just awesome.... F*CK YEAH!

[The1exile]

Like evolution? It is far more logical that God created people than by mere chance evolving from muck and if you can't see this, it's because you don't want to see it.

See, in moments of me doubting that you might actually lose all paths of logic, you astound me. Brilliantly done, jay.

Come on, if you're so fixated on your idea of a god being the source of all life, you could compromise; the evidence points to evolution, whether you like it or not, so maybe you could claim that whichever god it was created the precursors to life (that then evolved) even if that does hold its own myriad flaws for you to amplify.

something has always had to exist, that is living and has the ability to create.

yeah, but I can do that too.

[heavycola]

anybody who claims there is a god is mentally weak, dependant on hopes that arnt there because they cant find enough reason in there on lifes to find meaning. obviously they are seeing themselves as failures in their own eyes without admitting it! live for your self if your able, only the weak and puny say they are livng for there "god" doing his wil and all that shit.
hence anybody that believes in a god is self pronouncing there mental inferiority!! .

Woohoo! That'll do it!