DirtyDishSoap wrote:Having 8 threads titled more or less the same is getting silly. Give it is own sub forum and they can spam their ideologies to their hearts content
It is true that the proliferation of highly-similar threads is annoying. However, it has been suggested to me that more aggressive moderation -- merging similar threads, and if necessary taking action against people who make too many -- is more effective way of dealing with the problem.
I'm not in love with this idea, because
- it will make a lot more work for me, and
- it's going to lead to a shitload of new accusations of bias
but the idea is out there.
KoolBak wrote:Do the members with the most tenure and who are obviously the most dedicated to the site get more sway in the voting?
I value your opinion more than most people's, but in this case I have to disagree with you.
The majority of visitors to this forum love to argue about politics. Cutting it out could cut out their last surviving reason to stay here.
jusplay4fun wrote:In my opinion, if you move Politics out of this Forum, it will likely die, a slow death (and perhaps a bit faster than CC will die out) with a whimper, and not a bang (Big or otherwise).
Politics is what many get passionate about, and there are few other such topics that inspire such passions.
I tend to agree.
Votanic wrote:2. I still seriously want TeeGee to explain the history and motivation for that lame Street Corner Forum, as I suspect it is a failed previous attempt at something very akin to this.
There's a very long history that I probably can't do justice. But basically, the site has always had arguments between people who say we have too much moderation and people who say we have not enough moderation.
Street Corner was meant to be a testing ground. Any paying member of Conquer Club can volunteer to be head moderator of Street Corner for 30 days, and demonstrate to the world exactly how their brilliant idea of maximum or minimum moderation will work. After 30 day, the Street Sweeper was to wipe the slate clean and someone else would have their turn.
Unfortunately, Street Corner died, not through any fault of its own, but because CC was already too depopulated to support the experiment. Only two people ever volunteered to run Street Corner. They both had equal lack of success, and a third has never stood up.
DirtyDishSoap wrote:I'm not asking for you to be restricted. I'm asking to move your 200 hundred threads of [place politican here] into its own political sub forim. That's it
And that cup of water thread was satire. It was meant to poke fun at you dorks because in EVERY thread, you guys start bringing it down into more political non sense.
Yeah, I think your frustration in real, and shared by many.
But I think killing politics will kill this forum. I think some variation on the "merging threads" idea might be the way forward.
Votanic wrote:However, having a limit on the number of new threads per player might be a good idea. Maybe 1 thread a week? (...1 a month?) That should be enough to handle any new wars, elections, or stupid videos that come down the pike.
I think you may be on to something.