TOMBSTONE MAFIA *Day 7* MAFIA WIN!!!!!!

[wicked]

As for voting VOTE HITMAN because he is starting to make stuff up now to cover his ass.

where do you see this? can we have examples?

[MountainLion]

ok kiddo, you go find the clues, and we'll organize them!

You're right we have no clues to organize yet, but at some point it would help.

[mandalorian2298]

Iceman's argument against Hitman looks compeling. I am prepeard to vote Hitman to avoid a No Lynch, but a) he (Hitman) spamms so much that it is hard to tell if he is being scummy or is he simply puting too little effort into playing (by skimming instead of reading and spamming&bandwaggoning instead of helping to weed out the scum), b) I am still waiting for jnd to answer his FOSes and c) the Day is still early so I will not vote him yet to avoid a quick lynch. Let's see how will Hitman respond to Iceman's vote.

[Aimless]

Or C) There is no cult.

This is my guess. I can't think of how a cult would fit into the theme; none of the major characters fit the role of cult leader. I don't think we should concern ourselves with a cult until we know there is one.

As far as Hitman is concerned, I'm ambivalent. I see the case against him, but I don't think he's playing here any differently than he's played in the past. Then again, he just popped up scum in the NV3 game, and he submarined the same way.

I'd like to see jnd respond to the FOS's against him.

AK_iceman, I'd also like to see you answer the question I asked earlier; why the no lynch vote on day one?

[AK_iceman]

AK_iceman, I'd also like to see you answer the question I asked earlier; why the no lynch vote on day one?

I already answered that back on page 23.
Fast-track to Pg. 23

[Aimless]

Ah, I see it now.

Somehow I lost that within all the day one spam.

[Fircoal]

While hitman does since scummy by the ways that AK put, but some of it is false, because hitman is a noob.

[unriggable]

While hitman does since scummy by the ways that AK put, but some of it is false, because hitman is a noob.

He hosted a game - he isn't noob.

[Fircoal]

While hitman does since scummy by the ways that AK put, but some of it is false, because hitman is a noob.

He hosted a game - he isn't noob.

I've heard people call TEllivannia a noob even after he hosted a mafia game.

[AK_iceman]

While hitman does since scummy by the ways that AK put, but some of it is false, because hitman is a noob.

I'm pretty sure Hitman has been through more games than me. He should have some clue by now.

[Fircoal]

While hitman does since scummy by the ways that AK put, but some of it is false, because hitman is a noob.

I'm pretty sure Hitman has been through more games than me. He should have some clue by now.

deadbeated all of them but mine, and he asked me questions abot the role and stuff like that. A non-noob would know what a SK does. And a non-Noob wouldn't claim SK!

[Hitman079]

well, i've been in 3 games in my stay here that i have actually posted in.
first was the ATHF game hosted by master_bush (yes, i followed along but i got killed for inactivity)
second was the non-vanilla game by Fircoal...
third was this one
and if you count it, i hosted a game. but my game, if you look at it, only had 2 special roles..a doctor and a cop (the most basic roles there are).

[Hitman079]

i follow bandwagons because i'm not too good in logic, like if i was looking at someone's case similar to my own i wouldn't be able to come up with an argument like AK's.

[wicked]

hitman claimed SK? what? where?

[Aimless]

Just before we lynched him. Page 91 or 92, I think.

[Aimless]

Ack, the above is in reference to the NV3 game, not to this one. Sorry, got confused on which thread I was reading.

[MountainLion]

AK said about quotes by Hitman:

the above quotes all appear suspicious to me since they really don't help the game at all

Then Hitman said:

i follow bandwagons because i'm not too good in logic, like if i was looking at someone's case similar to my own i wouldn't be able to come up with an argument like AK's.

So you admit that you're not helping?

It seems that whether someone is good or not at thinking logical, they could at least come up with their own suspicions if they take the time to get a good look at what's being said. If they're not doing that, they're either lazy or don't care and neither looks good for you.

FOS Hitman

I would like to hold my vote until we hear from jnd. Where is he?

[Hitman079]

trying to make sense of what's going on now, and two FOS's is the same to one. jnd looks suspicious, but I think he does accuse a lot. although the FOS against me doesn't seem to make much sense.

[MountainLion]

I guess another way to put it is that if you're pro-town, you have to figure things out on your own because you don't know who anyone else is. Eventually you see different people as leaning towards one way or another, and you can kind of "team up" with others you think are pro-town later on, but you still be careful.

If you're mafia, you know who else is mafia. Because you have that knowledge you, in a way, work as a team with your mafia members.

Hitman, if you're not helping, you don't look like the (pro-town) individual that's doing his part. And if you're bandwagoning, you look like a part of a "team." (mafia)

That's what I'm thinking. Does anyone agree or disagree with this?

[Fircoal]

I guess another way to put it is that if you're pro-town, you have to figure things out on your own because you don't know who anyone else is. Eventually you see different people as leaning towards one way or another, and you can kind of "team up" with others you think are pro-town later on, but you still be careful.

If you're mafia, you know who else is mafia. Because you have that knowledge you, in a way, work as a team with your mafia members.

Hitman, if you're not helping, you don't look like the (pro-town) individual that's doing his part. And if you're bandwagoning, you look like a part of a "team." (mafia)

That's what I'm thinking. Does anyone agree or disagree with this?

I argee, yor catching onto this game nicely.

[wicked]

ok, you guys REALLY need to stop talking about other games like it's this one.

[Fircoal]

ok, you guys REALLY need to stop talking about other games like it's this one.

I only pointed out Hitman claiming SK in my game, because it proves he is a noob.

[AK_iceman]

i follow bandwagons because i'm not too good in logic, like if i was looking at someone's case similar to my own i wouldn't be able to come up with an argument like AK's.

I am curious now, if you aren't good at logic how did you end up playing RISK and Mafia, both of which require strategy and logic?
And I also was under the pre-conceived idea that this was an invite only game, with handpicked players? So how did you get invited?

Anyway, I'm less sure of my vote, but it will remain until I find someone more scummy.

[unriggable]

As for voting VOTE HITMAN because he is starting to make stuff up now to cover his ass.

where do you see this? can we have examples?

"He said he might no lynch I'm too lazy to go find it"

[moz976]

Sorry for the inactivity I'm pretty sick with all these weather changes I seem to have picked up a cold.

From my reading I think that Mandalorian seems to be pretty suspisious to me. He seems to be putting on a front of helping the town but it's with stuff that will only confuse us. eg. the whole maybe there is a cult or maybe there are two mafias. As wicked said a bad guy is a bad guy let's just get one.


So I'm going to FOS Manalorian