Trouble at Omega Sector Colony! Mafia --- Weekend 4

[mandalorian2298]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

Oh, sweet child, I think that you just over-played your hand.

thats pretty damning evidence mando....any comment

thats why im a mafia noob and your not everywhere....

Comment? I direct your attention to dcowboy's mafia game (Dallas Cowboys Mafia) where Red Bull was a cop and investigations showed him, not only town or mafia, but also the role and the explanation of the role. Further, I direct your attention to the roster of the forementined game. You will notice one everywhere116, on it! Trying to lynch a cop are we?
vote everywhere and I'll stick with this one 'till the bitter end.

[Puff]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

Oh, sweet child, I think that you just over-played your hand.

thats pretty damning evidence mando....any comment

thats why im a mafia noob and your not everywhere....

Comment? I direct your attention to dcowboy's mafia game (Dallas Cowboys Mafia) where Red Bull was a cop and investigations showed him, not only town or mafia, but also the role and the explanation of the role. Further, I direct your attention to the roster of the forementined game. You will notice one everywhere116, on it! Trying to lynch a cop are we?
vote everywhere and I'll stick with this one 'till the bitter end.

That is a very interesting theory.

It seems everywhere not only are you are doing what mando stated but you are also playing dumb when I am trying to explain to you that if mando is a thief it would be safer for him to say he was a cop.

I to am going to vote everywhere116

[s.xkitten]

he has several very good points

vote everywhere

[mandalorian2298]

If you want a proof of my allegations, "Dallas Cowboys Mafia" is on Page 5 of Social lounge II (I think) and Red Bull explains what kind of results he got by investigating on page 21 of the thread.

[mandalorian2298]

Of course, if red bull ever posts , he can confirm it himself.

[mandalorian2298]

BTW, autoload, maybe people would post more if they got a vote count every now an then.

[everywhere116]

Well, youre right about that, but the mod can change the rules of the roles. I think that is what cowboys did in that game. Anyway I guess I was wrong.

Unvote

[Colaalone]

MAX CAN'T BE LYNCHED!!!! We figured that out on day two.

Wrong. The mayor vetoed his lynch.

[unriggable]

I'm going to advise against voting for everywhere, he did not say anything scummy.

[autoload]

Vote Count



3 max is gr8 (Colaalone, red bull, Senfive)
3 everywhere116 (mandalorian2298, Puff, s.xkitten)
1 unriggable (Nyvek)
1 got tonkaed (max is gr8)



1 No Lynch (unriggable)



2 Not Voting (got tonkaed, everywhere116)



With 11 alive it takes 6 to Lynch!

[mandalorian2298]

I'm going to advise against voting for everywhere, he did not say anything scummy.

Spoken like a man who voted No lynch.

[Colaalone]

Why are we voting everywhere?
It seems pointless. He hasn't done anything THAT scummy. But nevertheless three people jumped his ass. I still think the death of Max will prove something. WHY DID HE LIE?! He said he targetted someone when Got Tonkaed proved he didn't! A townie wouldn't lie, mafia would. And mandy, I think lynching unriggable to test whether you're naive or not is a horrible idea, seems like a waste of a lynch.

[mandalorian2298]

Why are we voting everywhere?
It seems pointless. He hasn't done anything THAT scummy. But nevertheless three people jumped his ass. I still think the death of Max will prove something. WHY DID HE LIE?! He said he targetted someone when Got Tonkaed proved he didn't! A townie wouldn't lie, mafia would. And mandy, I think lynching unriggable to test whether you're naive or not is a horrible idea, seems like a waste of a lynch.

You don't even bother to read the posts, do you?

[Colaalone]

Why are we voting everywhere?
It seems pointless. He hasn't done anything THAT scummy. But nevertheless three people jumped his ass. I still think the death of Max will prove something. WHY DID HE LIE?! He said he targetted someone when Got Tonkaed proved he didn't! A townie wouldn't lie, mafia would. And mandy, I think lynching unriggable to test whether you're naive or not is a horrible idea, seems like a waste of a lynch.

You don't even bother to read the posts, do you?

No, I read the entirety of the pointless theif role argument and the little to no relevance of the suspicion pointed toward everywhere when he argued the TRUE statement of mafia cops getting roles and regular cops getting protown or promafia. Was just curious as to how this is worthy of a lynch?

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

So since you never investigated Max, what makes you so sure he isn't mafia?

Him and me were the most suspected players since CBlake got lynched, so I think it would be stupid of him to "prove" his powers by proclaiming me town (remember, every mafia player KNOWS who the townies are)

He never claimed you Protown, he said he received a "no" on you.

[Colaalone]

And also the whole thief thing wouldn't work. A thief steals an item from people, which leaves the role ambiguous (Ex:a knife could be doctor or serial killer; a gun could be cop or mafia.)

[mandalorian2298]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

Oh, sweet child, I think that you just over-played your hand.
I direct your attention to dcowboy's mafia game (Dallas Cowboys Mafia) where Red Bull was a cop and investigations showed him, not only town or mafia, but also the role and the explanation of the role. Further, I direct your attention to the roster of the forementined game. You will notice one everywhere116, on it! Trying to lynch a cop are we?
vote everywhere and I'll stick with this one 'till the bitter end.

The point was not in the "thief" argument (wich, by the way, everywhere intentinaly choosed not to understand). The point is that:
1. I claimed cop and said that I can see players roles (wich senfive confiremed)
2. Everywhere then tried to twist that argument, by saying that a townie cop can't see roles, although
3. Everywhere knows full well that it IS possible for a townie Cop to see roles, because he himself played a game with such a Cop

Everywhere probably figures that I will be a risky Night Kill choice because the Doc will protect me, so he is trying to get me lynched.

FOS Colaalone for playing dumb. It seems to me that you are counting on another No Lynch and are stalling for time to save everywhere.

[Colaalone]

The point was not in the "thief" argument (wich, by the way, everywhere intentinaly choosed not to understand).

How can you know someone doesn't intentionally understand something? Besides, HE IS RIGHT! Why would you claim cop instead of a theif? A theif isn't more valuable, at all. Their "investigations" leave ambiguity as to what the person's role is.

The point is that:
1. I claimed cop and said that I can see players roles (wich senfive confiremed)
2. Everywhere then tried to twist that argument, by saying that a townie cop can't see roles, although
3. Everywhere knows full well that it IS possible for a townie Cop to see roles, because he himself played a game with such a Cop

Everywhere probably figures that I will be a risky Night Kill choice because the Doc will protect me, so he is trying to get me lynched.

FOS Colaalone for playing dumb. It seems to me that you are counting on another No Lynch and are stalling for time to save everywhere.

Though a cop receiving roles is possible, its generally not the rule.
I just don't think his legitmate argument is worthy of a lynch.

Stalling for no lynch? I keep trying to point out the fact the Got Tonkaed caught max in a lie concerning his "role claim." But you seem convinced that his lie is something to worry about?

[Colaalone]

nothing to worry about*

[got tonkaed]

sorry ive been away most of the day, thursday gets a bit sketchy sometimes....

I guess we have two seemingly workable lines here...max and unriggable both would seemingly provide some information that would help us out in the long term....however if i do remember i think max may have at one point claimed to run some kind of investigation on unriggable, so perhaps he is the sounder lynch because if that proves to turn up incorrect we find out something about max too i suppose.

However i cant really get over the fact that we are possibly letting max off here...hes claimed to have an investigatory role and i found he did not use it in a situation where he claims he did. Seemingly max is a pretty sure fire scum and i would think that might have an implicatoin on mando if he is. Now we of course could lynch unriggable and find out more info, but if it turns up town arent we risking two townies in order to find out a little bit of information, when seemingly we alreadly have one mafia outed?

Either way deadline will be sneaking up soon and we dont want another no lynch i think.

[Puff]

sorry ive been away most of the day, thursday gets a bit sketchy sometimes....

I guess we have two seemingly workable lines here...max and unriggable both would seemingly provide some information that would help us out in the long term....however if i do remember i think max may have at one point claimed to run some kind of investigation on unriggable, so perhaps he is the sounder lynch because if that proves to turn up incorrect we find out something about max too i suppose.

However i cant really get over the fact that we are possibly letting max off here...hes claimed to have an investigatory role and i found he did not use it in a situation where he claims he did. Seemingly max is a pretty sure fire scum and i would think that might have an implicatoin on mando if he is. Now we of course could lynch unriggable and find out more info, but if it turns up town arent we risking two townies in order to find out a little bit of information, when seemingly we alreadly have one mafia outed?

Either way deadline will be sneaking up soon and we dont want another no lynch i think.

You think?

Of course we don't want another no lynch situation. And if nyvek stopped max's lynch the first time whats to say he won't do it again hmm?

My vote stands. Not only that I suggest you vote soon. Its a little scummy when someone is saying we should avoid a no lynch yet he does not vote himself. This is a tactic to ensure the blame of accidently lynching a townie is not placed on oneself.

FOS got tonkaed

[Senfive]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

This leads me to believe that everywhere is Scum. Wanting the town to kill the cop. Every Mod has different ways of showing the cop his investigations. Auto usually does do that anyway if you had been in any of his games you would have known that. Don't get me wrong I was thinking the same thing everywhere but I still want max dead to see if his role claim is genuine. A Cop alive is more valuable than Max's roleclaim.

[everywhere116]

Which is true, and I am already convinced of that.

Vote Max I believe he is lying, and to avoid a no lynch.

[Puff]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

This leads me to believe that everywhere is Scum. Wanting the town to kill the cop. Every Mod has different ways of showing the cop his investigations. Auto usually does do that anyway if you had been in any of his games you would have known that. Don't get me wrong I was thinking the same thing everywhere but I still want max dead to see if his role claim is genuine. A Cop alive is more valuable than Max's roleclaim.

Max's role does seem odd to me. But we can deal with that when the rescue crew comes next week. Right now we need to lynch someone we think is scum. That someone would be everywhere116.

For the good of us townies my vote stands

[Senfive]

he has several very good points

vote everywhere

This is total Bullshit from you S.xkitten. You haven't patticipated in this discussion at all yet you vote when the time comes. My next vote is on you cause you have just been going with the flow and bandwagoning. Mandalorian investigate her tonight. I am getting tired of the spammer of CC not contributing at all to the mafia game she asked to be replaced into.

[everywhere116]

I suck.
Oh well, time to role claim. I am the Cop.
I investigated AK and got a Unlynchable townie result, Unrigable and got a townie (well, Colonist) and senfive and got a Priest (wich he should have figured out from the TONS of hints I left in posts directed to him ).

I cant believe no one noticed this! Pro-town cops just get innocent or guilty results. Mafia cops get actual roles, like what he did. The only pro-town role that gets roles is the thief, which he isnt.

This leads me to believe that everywhere is Scum. Wanting the town to kill the cop. Every Mod has different ways of showing the cop his investigations. Auto usually does do that anyway if you had been in any of his games you would have known that. Don't get me wrong I was thinking the same thing everywhere but I still want max dead to see if his role claim is genuine. A Cop alive is more valuable than Max's roleclaim.

Max's role does seem odd to me. But we can deal with that when the rescue crew comes next week. Right now we need to lynch someone we think is scum. That someone would be everywhere116.

For the good of us townies my vote stands

It appears
I cannot convince you otherwise. I am not scum, just your simple colonist.