MAFIA- ATHF THE SOLE MAFIA (HOUSSAM) WINS THE GAME!!!

[Incandenza]

CB I can't believe you gave away being a cop! I hope that a doctor's protecting you. I don't like this, it's very possible that CB isn't the cop and he's defending his mafia buddies, but I guess no other mafia have stepped up. CB, I'm guessing a doc'll protect you. If we don't get trestain lynched since you guys are slow as molasses, check him out, will you?

okay, there's no way cb is a straight-up cop. And I don't think he's an insane cop either (where all the alignment info is reversed)... he's either a cop that gets random results, or he's mafia. and he may be a noob making noob mistakes, but if he's mafia, someone's potentially running him.

as far as senfive, it's hard to tell sometimes if he's freaking out because he's mafia or is he's freaking out for general purposes. Sometimes I think he's actually quite clever, in that he's basically spamming us with so many accusations and invective that we'd never be able to tell his alignment. Of course, that makes him the WORST kind of townie. Oddly enough, tho, at the moment I'm not even really all that focused on him.

what it boils down to is that cb tried to give us a nice handy lynchin' victim: senfive. I'd tend to shy away from anyone handed to us like that.

all this shit still doesn't really add up, tho.

[Incandenza]

but dussle makes a good point... tick tick tick.

VOTE trestain

geegel looked scummy, and tres has yet to show his face. I want to wait for him to show up and say something, but he might be lying low hoping we don't get a lynch in before the deadline.

[HoussamTheGreat]

I agree that geegle was acting scummy, and I agree that trestain has been very suspiciously absent. Question though.. Has any of you seen a mafia person being replaced for inactivity? Because I have seen many mafia games being played where the mafia's primary technique was just to lay low..

This is kind of why I initially was tending to semi-trust all subs, but given how many were substituted, I guess that might not be a sound theory. If you guys want to go with trestain, I can see that, and will go along - although I personally think Senfive is more suspicious.

I also have a renewed interest in CBlake... Incandenza makes a good point, his investigative choices seem intriguing to say the least.

[Incandenza]

I agree that geegle was acting scummy, and I agree that trestain has been very suspiciously absent. Question though.. Has any of you seen a mafia person being replaced for inactivity? Because I have seen many mafia games being played where the mafia's primary technique was just to lay low..

This is kind of why I initially was tending to semi-trust all subs, but given how many were substituted, I guess that might not be a sound theory. If you guys want to go with trestain, I can see that, and will go along - although I personally think Senfive is more suspicious.

I also have a renewed interest in CBlake... Incandenza makes a good point, his investigative choices seem intriguing to say the least.

good points. But at least one of the replacements almost HAS to be mafia. It's possible that one of the replaced players wasn't booted, but instead PMed MB and asked to be replaced (i.e. pyro, who was replaced by sen). The midday geegel/tres swap also strikes me as being somewhat unorthodox.

I just don't think we have enough time to build a lynch against cblake. Given that he's either random cop spamming us with useless info or mafia, killing him would seem win-win, even in our semi-dire straits. plus, if he were killed, we might get better investigative results.

My vote stays for the moment, but I'm certainly up for discussing other options.

[Master Bush]

Vote Count

• [2] senfive -- (houssam, rev)
• [3] trestain -- (dussle, mach, Incandenza)
• [4] Not Voted -- (trestain, senfive, cblake, fircoal)

5 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

THE DEADLINE TO LYNCH IS SUNDAY NIGHT AT MIDNIGHT

[Incandenza]

another bit of info:

sen has been online and posting (mostly in AK's mafia game), but he hasn't shown up here for some hours. He hasn't really said anything of merit since his big 'kill me' hissy fit.

In a weird way, that makes me feel like he's town. Not posting when you're clearly online and posting elsewhere is such blatantly suspicious activity that I can't believe sen would be doing it if he were really mafia.

[HoussamTheGreat]

I still think Senfive is scum.. HAving said that, this is my "trusted" list for now: Fircoal, Incandenza, RK, Mach, Cblake (!) - in addition to me, that's 6 - meaning that there are very good odds that BOTH Trestain and Senfive are scum. With that said

unvote senfive (very reluctantly)
vote trestain

[Incandenza]

I still think Senfive is scum.. HAving said that, this is my "trusted" list for now: Fircoal, Incandenza, RK, Mach, Cblake (!) - in addition to me, that's 6 - meaning that there are very good odds that BOTH Trestain and Senfive are scum. With that said

unvote senfive (very reluctantly)
vote trestain

you trust cblake? seriously?

I dunno. It takes a lot for me to trust someone in this. My list is exactly two people long: you and fircoal. (and I'm still keeping my eye on ya)

[HoussamTheGreat]

you trust cblake? seriously?

I know what you are saying, and hence the (!!). It's sort of like your note about fircoal being so blatantly suspicious that in a weird way makes him look like a townie in your eyes. I think that CB has played so incredibly bad that it makes it hard for me to imagine him as mafia.

[Master Bush]

Vote Count

• [1] senfive -- (rev)
• [4] trestain -- (dussle, mach, Incandenza, houssam)
• [4] Not Voted -- (trestain, senfive, cblake, fircoal)

5 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

THE DEADLINE TO LYNCH IS SUNDAY NIGHT AT MIDNIGHT

[dussle]

you trust cblake? seriously?

I know what you are saying, and hence the (!!). It's sort of like your note about fircoal being so blatantly suspicious that in a weird way makes him look like a townie in your eyes. I think that CB has played so incredibly bad that it makes it hard for me to imagine him as mafia.

I'm kinda seeing your point there. this reminds me of a lot of situation. CB's just a mafia n00b. I trust him until something comes up.

[dussle]

Guys, I'm gone all of sunday. Sorry. gl!!!

[Incandenza]

you trust cblake? seriously?

I know what you are saying, and hence the (!!). It's sort of like your note about fircoal being so blatantly suspicious that in a weird way makes him look like a townie in your eyes. I think that CB has played so incredibly bad that it makes it hard for me to imagine him as mafia.

actually, I was saying that about sen, not fircoal. Just for the record.

[Incandenza]

the CB thing actually gives me a thought for future mafia games. It wouldn't be a bad idea, towards the end of the day, for townies to maybe talk out who should be investigated. That way, if the cop ends up being a noob, they won't just be taking a shot in the dark. They'll have a list of potential suspects to check out.

[HoussamTheGreat]

the CB thing actually gives me a thought for future mafia games. It wouldn't be a bad idea, towards the end of the day, for townies to maybe talk out who should be investigated. That way, if the cop ends up being a noob, they won't just be taking a shot in the dark. They'll have a list of potential suspects to check out.

I always kinda do that once it's all on the table. It's not applicable here though since obviously CB is not reliable..

[HoussamTheGreat]

actually, I was saying that about sen, not fircoal. Just for the record.

Correct. Typo. Sorry Fircola..

[Senfive]

you trust cblake? seriously?

I know what you are saying, and hence the (!!). It's sort of like your note about fircoal being so blatantly suspicious that in a weird way makes him look like a townie in your eyes. I think that CB has played so incredibly bad that it makes it hard for me to imagine him as mafia.

actually, I was saying that about sen, not fircoal. Just for the record.

never said I trusted him. I was giving him the benifit of the doubt. saying maybe his investigation were opposites until he comfirmed this wasn't the case when he said I was townie during his investigation and then wanted to vote against me. Incandeza I love your read through and you bring up a lot of good points. Like I said it might be only a hunch but you already know who I think are mafia.

[Incandenza]

Here's something, just kinda throwing it out there, but something I never saw discussed:

what's the pattern behind the mafia killings?:
colaalone the first night, which seems breathtakingly random
second night doesn't count, as we can't tell who got RD and who got cowboys
cmckinney the third night, leading me to think that there's a mafia cop who sniffed him out
a no kill, which means the mafia either couldn't make a decision or attacked someone who was protected (if it's the latteer, I wouldn't be surprised if the protected townie in question was either mach or CB)
chessplaya, even tho many people were deeply suspicious of him

It seems like, in contrast to other games, the mafia is intentionally going after newish players. I don't know what other games those three have been in, so I don't know their playing history, but it seems strange that the mafia wouldn't have tried to pick off at least one veteran player.

Another thing to consider: I'd guess that there's only three mafia, if for no other reason than if MB did indeed decide to saddle us with a totally unreliable cop, he wouldn't make the mafia particularly large. But that's just vile speculation at this point.

Just something to stir the pot a bit.

[Incandenza]

you trust cblake? seriously?

I know what you are saying, and hence the (!!). It's sort of like your note about fircoal being so blatantly suspicious that in a weird way makes him look like a townie in your eyes. I think that CB has played so incredibly bad that it makes it hard for me to imagine him as mafia.

actually, I was saying that about sen, not fircoal. Just for the record.

never said I trusted him. I was giving him the benifit of the doubt. saying maybe his investigation were opposites until he comfirmed this wasn't the case when he said I was townie during his investigation and then wanted to vote against me. Incandeza I love your read through and you bring up a lot of good points. Like I said it might be only a hunch but you already know who I think are mafia.

Do you still think it's mach and fircoal? mach is a possibility, but I'd have to buy the fact that hous and fir are masons. If they were mafia, they'd have no way of knowing that there were no masons amongst the townies, thus they'd risk claiming mason and having the real pair of masons start hollering.

I gotta say, it's a much different experience getting parachuted into one of these games midstream. Plus I've been keeping notes, which helps a lot.

[reverend_kyle]

if it means the for sure guilty gets lynched next time vote trestain

senfive can wait. Its fun to watch him freak out so lets lynch him later anyways.

[Master Bush]

Vote Count

• [5] trestain -- (dussle, mach, Incandenza, houssam, rev)
• [4] Not Voted -- (trestain, senfive, cblake, fircoal)

5 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch


With 5 Votes, you have lynched trestain, Emory (townie)



IT'S NOW NIGHT 6, EVERYONE WITH NIGHT ROLES HAS UNTIL TUESDAY NIGHT AT MIDNIGHT TO GET ME YOUR PICKS

NOW NO MORE TALKING

[Master Bush]

~DAY 6~

Found dead is CBlake, Master Shake (Insane Cop - townie)



WITH 7 PLAYERS REMAINING IT TAKES 4 VOTES FOR A LYNCH. YOUR DEADLINE TO LYNCH IS WEDNESDAY NIGHT AT MIDNIGHT.

Now lets get the day going!

[autoload]

Short night for these fellas...

[dussle]

Glad he was insane. Sorry boys, geegel must just suck. Now then, who's our doctor and why did he not protect CB? Not that it was a smart choice for him in the first place to reveal himself. People? Any ideas on who the mafia is?

[dussle]

P.S. If you're our doctor DO NOT REVEAL YOURSELF.