TOMBSTONE MAFIA *Day 7* MAFIA WIN!!!!!!

[got tonkaed]

well the only problem is this seems to be a very similar start to the way you played film noir, a game that you almost won for us as scum. Your being fairly helpful without being too helpful and suggesting things that sort of line you up down the line as being a good guy, though they dont really add up to too much of substance.

So i ask again, why exactly arent you scum?

[wicked]

well usually submariners are mafia, in other games I've played. of course, that wasn't the case with hitman, but apparently he's been kicked out of games before for not playing that much. So who that is normally chatty has gone quiet? Who is submarining?

[Aimless]

well the only problem is this seems to be a very similar start to the way you played film noir, a game that you almost won for us as scum. Your being fairly helpful without being too helpful and suggesting things that sort of line you up down the line as being a good guy, though they dont really add up to too much of substance.

So i ask again, why exactly arent you scum?

Bah. That one I can't answer... yet. I don't have anything of substance to work with. Give me a day or so to prove you wrong.

[got tonkaed]

you dont get a day sir, its fairly clear in my eyes at least that you are scum, and if i give you a day, its quite possible that i die isnt it?


Vote Aimless

[Aimless]

well usually submariners are mafia, in other games I've played. of course, that wasn't the case with hitman, but apparently he's been kicked out of games before for not playing that much. So who that is normally chatty has gone quiet? Who is submarining?

unriggable is the only name that pops to the top of my head at the moment. In the games I've played with him, he's usually more active than this.

I haven't played with moz or XenHu yet, so I can't answer for them. Balsiefen was quiet in the werewolf game, but he was also scum that game.

[MountainLion]

XenHu, why aren't you scum?

Although Xen posted a pretty good amount, a lot of it has been short. When he voted sheep he did it without any stated reason. He only said "Vote Sheep." On the topic of Hitman should roleclaim on Day 2 he said "If I don't hear from him soon, he gets my vote." Then he disappeared.

[wicked]

just because he's being helpful tonka? any good mafia player will change up their style of play. what else do you have?

[got tonkaed]

honestly having been scum with him in that game and being out early, aimless weaved a masterpiece as scum. And ive played with him in games where hes pro town and honestly its a bit more like his style to be scum when hes acting as he is right now. Im as sure as i can be that he is in fact scum.

[MountainLion]

is Aimless a good mafia player?

[wicked]

moz is actually posting a lot for moz..lol... he's usually a submariner. the fact that he's posting more is noteworthy.

xenhu usually posts more than he is now I think.

Where is fircola?? he usually has 3-page long posts. his absence is notable.

I really don't know any of the other players that well. sorry!

[got tonkaed]

xen for the record has been fairly quiet lately im not sure whats up in a variety of games,

i think aimless is one of the best mafia players on site, especially as scum.

[wicked]

and why should we trust you blindly tonka? I've never played with Aim, so don't know. Anyone else know?

[got tonkaed]

you should trust me blindly because if im wrong im clearly out of the game. And because in other games this is what i do when i know.

[MountainLion]

Sounds like if you play enough games on CC people get to know you well enough to pick up on things. got tonkaed really seems sure of his vote. maybe if we keep the pressure on...

Vote Aimless

I still don't like to go through a day without hearing from everyone. I'm glad we have a 3-day Day. Hopefully everyone makes it in here over the next 24 hours.

[I GOT SERVED]

So after reading the last few posts, I've compiled a bit of a list, in order from most scummy to least scummy:

-XenHu (He normally is a bit more active)
-unriggable (see above)
-Aimless

More to come......maybe

[got tonkaed]

frankly i understand how i sound a bit manical at the moment (trust me) but anyone who lines themselves up with aimless, will be seen as scummy in my eyes, and considering i feel by the end of the day i will have him lynched, its important to note who sticks up with him now.

as a start i would consider igs questionable.

[jnd94]

seems like mountainlion did this whole xenhu guilty thing kinda quicky. maybe he just wants a kill? but what im thinking is that since this is an invitational, he would probably give the best players the best roles. maybe its one of the more experienced players who would do the role better than a newer player, like me. just thoughts....

[got tonkaed]

jnd, the roles given out in games even in invitational ones, tend to be random. One should not assume simply because someone is new that they cannot play or that because someone plays a lot that they automatically have all of the power roles.

[Fircoal]

jnd, the roles given out in games even in invitational ones, tend to be random. One should not assume simply because someone is new that they cannot play or that because someone plays a lot that they automatically have all of the power roles.

Ad, said that they wouldn't be random, I believe I remember him saying that.

And he was against me giving Sheep the jester role, when it was random.

[jnd94]

there was a thread i made where he said that if you dont know how to play, you will get vanilla townie role.

[Fircoal]

Gt, how sure are you that Aimless is mafia. The only proof I've heard yo say his that he's acting like he did before when he was mafia. That is metagamming. So is there anything else that makes him scummy, and in which ways is he acting like he was acting when he was mafia?

[got tonkaed]

fircoal think about it....of course i know im metagamming but im doing for a specific purpose. If i feel this strongly to put aimless on the chopping block without giving out the exact reasons why i feel so, dont you think i would realize that if im wrong about such things im out of hte game (now im wifom ing myself)

im doing it all because im that confident that hes scum.

[MountainLion]

got tonkaed, how many games have you played with him?

[Fircoal]

fircoal think about it....of course i know im metagamming but im doing for a specific purpose. If i feel this strongly to put aimless on the chopping block without giving out the exact reasons why i feel so, dont you think i would realize that if im wrong about such things im out of hte game (now im wifom ing myself)

im doing it all because im that confident that hes scum.

Or your using metagamming, and your "confidence" in him being scum, so that yo can cover up your argressiveness. While something in my brain says I should believe you, I'm not sure, because this seems, like a go cover up for your pushing.

[jnd94]

well im always thinking that he could just be taking any talks that were about him and putting it on aimless, so that he isnt under the spotlight, and there will be a lynch. We have to get our lynches correct TODAY or the town will most definatley lose.