Non-VANILLA Game 3 *Game Over* 14 Winners

[Anarkistsdream]

Yeah, I just spent 5 mins digging through the thread to find them.

Who counterclaimed Greece?

No one. But Greece never claimed.

He never had time. That's what happens when you never post...

[Primate]

I personally reckon that speedlynching is most inherently stupid thing in mafia. Because people were so impatient, we lost our cop day 1.

I don't see how it's remotely his fault. It's everyone elses for not waiting that 12 hours or whatever. Lynching people without getting claims from them is fairly obviously wrong on a fairly basic level.

I don't think it's suspicious, really, it's just stupid.

[Anarkistsdream]

I personally reckon that speedlynching is most inherently stupid thing in mafia. Because people were so impatient, we lost our cop day 1.

I don't see how it's remotely his fault. It's everyone elses for not waiting that 12 hours or whatever. Lynching people without getting claims from them is fairly obviously wrong on a fairly basic level.

I don't think it's suspicious, really, it's just stupid.

You REALLY need to read the thread, as opposed to making rash accusations about shit you know nothing about it.

No offense, but that's a fact... Read the first three or so pages... He had plenty of time, and knew exactly what he was doing... Then, he disappeared... It was stupid of him, not of anyone else.

[Aimless]

I personally reckon that speedlynching is most inherently stupid thing in mafia. Because people were so impatient, we lost our cop day 1.

I don't see how it's remotely his fault. It's everyone elses for not waiting that 12 hours or whatever. Lynching people without getting claims from them is fairly obviously wrong on a fairly basic level.

I don't think it's suspicious, really, it's just stupid.

Sadly, about half the players here won't claim even if you give them time.

But yes, I absolutely agree that it's dumb to lynch without getting a claim.

[Anarkistsdream]

He had plenty of time... He posted on page 1 and page 12.... He knew... He chose his idiocy.

[The1exile]

Last edited by Hitman079 on 11 Apr 2007 18:33; edited 1 time in total

No editing posts!

[Anarkistsdream]

Last edited by Hitman079 on 11 Apr 2007 18:33; edited 1 time in total

No editing posts!

Nice catch, dude...

Hitman, that makes you look even MORE SCUMMY!

[Aimless]

He had plenty of time... He posted on page 1 and page 12.... He knew... He chose his idiocy.

I'm not disagreeing with you here, AD, just speaking in general. This crowd seems far to prone to lynching, and I hardly ever see anyone claim, even when they have a power role.

Basically, almost everyone here plays as if their role was "survivor," not "townie."

[Anarkistsdream]

He had plenty of time... He posted on page 1 and page 12.... He knew... He chose his idiocy.

I'm not disagreeing with you here, AD, just speaking in general. This crowd seems far to prone to lynching, and I hardly ever see anyone claim, even when they have a power role.

Basically, almost everyone here plays as if their role was "survivor," not "townie."

Well, that is why invitations are a good idea...

[Aegnor]

Is he acting like that on purpose, misleading us into thinking that he is a noob and thus look more innocent. Or is he really that dumb to edit a post in a mafia game?

[The1exile]

Aimless, it's true that we go for lynches but that's simply because there's no point in not having a lynch. We talked before about how interest wanes if no-one contributes.

[pancakemix]

Is he acting like that on purpose, misleading us into thinking that he is a noob and thus look more innocent. Or is he really that dumb to edit a post in a mafia game?

He's modded a game before. He should know better.

[Aegnor]

Alright, then it looks very fishy to me, I hope I didn't make a mistake by voting him.

[Aimless]

Aimless, it's true that we go for lynches but that's simply because there's no point in not having a lynch. We talked before about how interest wanes if no-one contributes.

I know. It's a matter of the board culture here. As for not having a lynch - it is okay to force a lynch if we're up against a deadline. If the deadline is not close, then it is always better for the town to wait for the player to claim.

Likewise, it is always better for the town for the player to claim; the reticence I see with some players, not claiming out of spite for being lynched, baffles me.

[The1exile]

Aimless, it's true that we go for lynches but that's simply because there's no point in not having a lynch. We talked before about how interest wanes if no-one contributes.

I know. It's a matter of the board culture here. As for not having a lynch - it is okay to force a lynch if we're up against a deadline. If the deadline is not close, then it is always better for the town to wait for the player to claim.

Well, we don't have a day deadline I think. Then it's just a matter often of wanting to get the deed done and dusted (because we don't want this mafia game to be taken over by our grandchildren )

Likewise, it is always better for the town for the player to claim; the reticence I see with some players, not claiming out of spite for being lynched, baffles me.

Well, I can understand their motivation, but meh. It's true that it's the worst thing to do objectively, but subjectively, I can see it's appeal. (I don't play enough games as a townie to form a proper opinion, though )

[Primate]

I personally reckon that speedlynching is most inherently stupid thing in mafia. Because people were so impatient, we lost our cop day 1.

I don't see how it's remotely his fault. It's everyone elses for not waiting that 12 hours or whatever. Lynching people without getting claims from them is fairly obviously wrong on a fairly basic level.

I don't think it's suspicious, really, it's just stupid.

You REALLY need to read the thread, as opposed to making rash accusations about shit you know nothing about it.

No offense, but that's a fact... Read the first three or so pages... He had plenty of time, and knew exactly what he was doing... Then, he disappeared... It was stupid of him, not of anyone else.

He was on 3 votes at 18:00 on the 18th. two hours later, he was lynched. There was no deadline, and no reason to lynch him that quickly. Throughout the rest of the day, no-one had even mentioned the merest hint of the possibility of a chance that claiming might be a spiffy thing for to do. I think that pretty squarely falls under the banner of a claim-resisting speedlynch, don't you?

@everyone discussing editing: you either think that he is scum editing out suspicious stuff, or you think he made a mistake. If you think that he edited out something suspcious, then please, dears, say what it is you think he removed. Simply editing is not, in itself, suspicious, surely? (admittedly, it is still against the rules, and should be punished but editing doesn't make someone any more likely to be mafia.

[Primate]

also, vote jnd94 for being fairly probable scum.

[Shadowstar]

School is STILL holding me back, I just finished reading what I missed.

Anyway, at one point, jnd was acting rather scummy, and now hitman. Right now, what I see is not enough for a vote, so I'll

FOS: jnd and hitman

[Fircoal]

Vote Count:
SChool(1) - Shadowstar
Primate(1) - AD
Jnd(3) - Syzygy, Hitman079, Primate
Hitman(3) Got Tonkaed, Exile, Aegnor.

On another note. To get onto Fircoal's Good list, or to get off the bad, sleep on the ground list. Helping Fircoal with stuff, would be good.

Like right now, pm Fircoal to review his map of a game he may start here.

I MEAN DO IT!!!!

[jnd94]

not because he voted for me, but im gonna Vote- Primate I just think that if you post early, then stop osting till you runder the radar, that qualifies as scum-like

[Anarkistsdream]

Unvote

At least he is here contributing... Hitman says one thing and disappears again...

Not to mention, he knows better than this, because, as people have pointed out, he has moderated his own game, before...

Vote: Hitman

[Anarkistsdream]

I personally reckon that speedlynching is most inherently stupid thing in mafia. Because people were so impatient, we lost our cop day 1.

I don't see how it's remotely his fault. It's everyone elses for not waiting that 12 hours or whatever. Lynching people without getting claims from them is fairly obviously wrong on a fairly basic level.

I don't think it's suspicious, really, it's just stupid.

You REALLY need to read the thread, as opposed to making rash accusations about shit you know nothing about it.

No offense, but that's a fact... Read the first three or so pages... He had plenty of time, and knew exactly what he was doing... Then, he disappeared... It was stupid of him, not of anyone else.

He was on 3 votes at 18:00 on the 18th. two hours later, he was lynched. There was no deadline, and no reason to lynch him that quickly. Throughout the rest of the day, no-one had even mentioned the merest hint of the possibility of a chance that claiming might be a spiffy thing for to do. I think that pretty squarely falls under the banner of a claim-resisting speedlynch, don't you?

@everyone discussing editing: you either think that he is scum editing out suspicious stuff, or you think he made a mistake. If you think that he edited out something suspcious, then please, dears, say what it is you think he removed. Simply editing is not, in itself, suspicious, surely? (admittedly, it is still against the rules, and should be punished but editing doesn't make someone any more likely to be mafia.

I think it was a Day One lynch, done on a newbie...

He KNEW what was happening... If he didn't, he should have read the thread...

As for claiming... I think he never would have, regardless...

You may know a lot about the game, but not about playing it HERE... These people play very fast or not at all... Both are a detriment to the game.

But, on Day One, what else are you gonna do?

[Anarkistsdream]

In any case, that is a moot point... He's dead, let's move along with the game now.

[Hitman079]

it's rather easy..if you ever checked i've never played a mafia game prior to modding my own..plus i thought the rule for editing posts just applied to voting..but oh well i'm guessing since so many people are changing their vote to me now i'm dead

[pancakemix]

You only have about 4. There's still time.