Should D-Mac have won the Heisman?

by **UCAbears** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 9:39 pm

Should Mcfadden have won it this year? I sure as hell think he should have. Mcfadden was .2 percent behind Tebow who shouldn't have gotten it because he was a sophmore. Look back at last year and Mcfadden should have won it if it wasnt for him being a sophmore. Gosh damn critics. Because he is from here(Arkansas).

by **dustn64** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:16 pm

Pfft...

by **dcowboys055** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:24 pm

by **soundout9** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:26 pm

no, chase daniels!

by **dustn64** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:28 pm

soundout9 wrote:no, chase daniels!

another Pfft...

by **Serbia** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:38 pm

Colt Brennan!

Well seriously, if he put up those numbers at say Texas, Michigan, or USC, he'd have won hands down.

by **dustn64** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:39 pm

Serbia wrote:Colt Brennan!

Well seriously, if he put up those numbers at say Texas, Michigan, or USC, he'd have won hands down.

I would put him as second choice in the Dustn64 Heisman race.

by **misterman10** on Mon Dec 10, 2007 11:31 pm

Suck it up cupcake. Tebow deserved to win, but if Dennis Dixon had stayed healthy he would have won it.

by **strike wolf** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 6:26 pm

I won't lie. Tebow was the best candidate. I was surprised they gave it to him.

by **got tonkaed** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 6:59 pm

run dmc was pretty big in those 3 games he didnt get 100 yards.

by **Harijan** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 7:36 pm

its a tough call. I agree that dixon would have locked it, if not for ASU's defense.

Tebow had the edge with numbers, and I have never been a supporter of seniority deserves to win.

What was funny was some the the Florida fan propoganda for Tebow.

"Superman wears Tim Tebow pajamas to bed."

"Tebow has counted to infinity twice"

"TT ordered a Big Mac at Burger King, and got it"

by **Gold Knight** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 7:52 pm

Serbia wrote:Colt Brennan!

Well seriously, if he put up those numbers at say Texas, Michigan, or USC, he'd have won hands down.

And he also would have faced some defenses worthy of his time, but he remained at Hawaii, where they play lackluster teams all years and expect the BCS system to kiss their ass for beating 12 teams that are talent-wise comaprable to high school teams.

Sorry, im just tired of this Hawaii bullshit, they schedule the weakest non conference schedule I have ever seen, thus they should schedule harder teams to play if they expect any respect.

by **ParadiceCity9** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:01 pm

nahh...

by **Neoteny** on Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:04 pm

Gold Knight wrote:
Serbia wrote:Colt Brennan!

Well seriously, if he put up those numbers at say Texas, Michigan, or USC, he'd have won hands down.

And he also would have faced some defenses worthy of his time, but he remained at Hawaii, where they play lackluster teams all years and expect the BCS system to kiss their ass for beating 12 teams that are talent-wise comaprable to high school teams.

Sorry, im just tired of this Hawaii bullshit, they schedule the weakest non conference schedule I have ever seen, thus they should schedule harder teams to play if they expect any respect.

This is true, which is why I'm looking forward to their bowl game. If Colt and the Warriers can hold their own against an SEC team, then I think that he was robbed of the Heisman. I dislike Tebow because I think he is overrated, but even I'll admit he's damn good. I've been a Mac fan since he started playing, and I'd really like to see him win one, but I think it should have been Tebow (unless Brennan manages to prove himself).

by **UCAbears** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 5:33 pm

Harijan wrote:its a tough call. I agree that dixon would have locked it, if not for ASU's defense.

Tebow had the edge with numbers, and I have never been a supporter of seniority deserves to win.

What was funny was some the the Flrida fan propoganda for Tebow.

"Superman wears Tim Tebow pajamas to bed."

"Tebow has countd to infinity twice"

"TT ordered a Big Mac at Burger King, and got it"

"When superman was little, he ran around pretending to be D-mac"

by **UCAbears** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 5:37 pm

Tebow ran for 20 touchdowns yeah, but they were all from 10 yards out or less. D-mac ran for 20 touchdowns every other one 30 yards or more. Tebow threw for 20 touchdowns, D-mac threw for 3 touchdowns and was a Running back. D mac also had 2 recieving touchdowns. He should have won it hands down.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:21 pm

25 touchdowns is better than 40 touchdowns?

As far as Hawaii v. Georgia, I've watched some of Hawaii's games and I would say that Georgia will probably win. Also, for those of you who might not have known, Georgia could be wearing the black jerseys again for the Sugar Bowl.

by **0ojakeo0** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:22 pm

i dont give a shit if tebow was a sophmore he deserved it.

by **unriggable** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 7:27 pm

The answer: It doesn't matter. It didn't happen. Better luck next year.

by **UCAbears** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 8:19 pm

unriggable wrote:The answer: It doesn't matter. It didn't happen. Better luck next year.

Your correct, because next year it will be rookie of the Year.

by **dustn64** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 8:41 pm

UCAbears wrote:
unriggable wrote:The answer: It doesn't matter. It didn't happen. Better luck next year.

Your correct, because next year it will be rookie of the Year.

by **UCAbears** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 9:01 pm

dustn64 wrote:
UCAbears wrote:
unriggable wrote:The answer: It doesn't matter. It didn't happen. Better luck next year.

Your correct, because next year it will be rookie of the Year.

by **Optimus Prime** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 10:03 pm

UCAbears wrote:Tebow ran for 20 touchdowns yeah, but they were all from 10 yards out or less. D-mac ran for 20 touchdowns every other one 30 yards or more. Tebow threw for 20 touchdowns, D-mac threw for 3 touchdowns and was a Running back. D mac also had 2 recieving touchdowns. He should have won it hands down.

Actually, that is false. Darren McFadden only rushed for 14 touchdowns this season.

by **UCAbears** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 10:09 pm

Optimus Prime wrote:
UCAbears wrote:Tebow ran for 20 touchdowns yeah, but they were all from 10 yards out or less. D-mac ran for 20 touchdowns every other one 30 yards or more. Tebow threw for 20 touchdowns, D-mac threw for 3 touchdowns and was a Running back. D mac also had 2 recieving touchdowns. He should have won it hands down.

Actually, that is false. Darren McFadden only rushed for 14 touchdowns this season.

Ok im sorry it was 20 in total i forgot. 14 rushing from MORE than 10 yards out, 4 passing and 2 recieving. almost 2,000 yards rushing.

by **dustn64** on Wed Dec 12, 2007 11:23 pm

UCAbears wrote:
Optimus Prime wrote:
UCAbears wrote:Tebow ran for 20 touchdowns yeah, but they were all from 10 yards out or less. D-mac ran for 20 touchdowns every other one 30 yards or more. Tebow threw for 20 touchdowns, D-mac threw for 3 touchdowns and was a Running back. D mac also had 2 recieving touchdowns. He should have won it hands down.

Actually, that is false. Darren McFadden only rushed for 14 touchdowns this season.

Ok im sorry it was 20 in total i forgot. 14 rushing from MORE than 10 yards out, 4 passing and 2 recieving. almost 2,000 yards rushing.

ok, Mcfadden Tebow

passing yards attempts- 123/ 11 3132/ 317

Rushing yards and attempts- 1725/ 304 838/194

Touchdowns- 20 51

Should D-Mac have won the Heisman?

Should He have won the Heisman?

Should D-Mac have won the Heisman?

Who is online