saraith wrote:conquerAce wrote:
As many people have pointed out, the reason for asking for home settings is to play to strengths. all of the people that vote Yes could be stronger in Terminator games so the vote is not a fair way to make the changes to the settings mid stream
just my two cents
I'll add my own pennies to that.
Thanks to everybody for voicing your opinion about this issue. I wanted to have a vote in addition to written posts to have a feeling about what the lazy players think.
Right now I have enough feedback to decide. I conclude that:
- Players are divided more or less half-half about this issue (56%-44% in the vote now)
- Making no spoils games terminator don't have to make games quicker.
- As some players pointed, flat rate games can take as much time as no spoil games. And escalating can also get stalled if players survive to the point when set are worth 50+ and start building up.
- Making no spoils games terminator is an unfair change mid-way for the ones who did choose that combination. Is removing their best choice to score (as that game is supposed to be the best suited for their strengts)
If a big majority wanted the settings to be changed I was ready to make the change, but as I see no clear majority, and the arguments have convinced me that the change would be unfair (why not make scalating games flat rate because they take too few turns?)
I am not changing the settings.
I know that this can lead to some angry player leaving the tournament, (I hope no one does) but if that's the price that I have to pay for keeping the game fair for everyone then I am willing to pay it.
Actions I will take to speed up tournament:- Right now I am creating a second (or third) game for all groups. Players may join this second game so two games are played simultaneously if they wish, but they are not forced to do it if they don't want to.
- As soon as all 128 players are mathematically qualified, the next round will start without waiting for the remaining games in the first round to finish.
Again, thanks so much to everybody who voiced their opinions and helped me deciding.