LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Sentinel XIV]

You seem awfully sure of yourself, there, Selin...

what do you know that we dont?

I'm pretty sure he knows it all, as far as this game goes.

[Neoteny]

You seem awfully sure of yourself, there, Selin...

what do you know that we dont?

I'm pretty sure he knows it all, as far as this game goes.

[cena-rules]

You seem awfully sure of yourself, there, Selin...

what do you know that we dont?

I'm pretty sure he knows it all, as far as this game goes.

what makes you so sure only the mod knows it all

[pmchugh]

I still think we should lynch mandalorian just to find out the true alignment of the boat people.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I disagree besides the obvious reason Mandy claims to be a "watcher". A watcher would be helpful later in the game and if you scumbags are that concerned on if boat is scum or not give me 2 more nights and then I'll sacrifice myself as my role will be completed at tha ttime and will only be a mason.

[Anarkistsdream]

May I just say I am very impressed by the way people are playing this game. Completely different than the way I thought it would go, which makes it more interesting for me!

Thanks for playing, all. Keep up the good work.

[cmckinney]

you are very welcome oh powerful mod

[pmchugh]

I disagree besides the obvious reason Mandy claims to be a "watcher". A watcher would be helpful later in the game and if you scumbags are that concerned on if boat is scum or not give me 2 more nights and then I'll sacrifice myself as my role will be completed at tha ttime and will only be a mason.

We already have one watcher, I dont see why you are so concerned to keep madalorien alive, if you are telling the truth then you will be revealed as town when mandlorien is lynched and we dont have any other great leads atm (unless you can provide one). Yes we would lose a town member but in doing so you would convince me and everyone else of your innocence as well as Gimpy's, giving the town an advantage, in the way of knowledge.

[gimpyThewonder]

Now, dear boat/heli group members, are you telling us that your group creates a townie group by recruiting players?
That would have been a very unbalanced game setup in favor of townies, don't you think so? Thank you very much for the info LSU. I believe that you unite yourself as a group as you said, but I don't believe that you are townies!
.

Selin pull your head out for a second mate. IF we were somehow detrimental to the rest of the town would we stick our necks out there? That would be stupid, and neither of us are stupid players. We are simply saying we can verify Mandy is who he says he is over the course of the night and if you are a REAL townie you would be ok w/ giving us another night to verify. but based on this comment:

You seem awfully sure of yourself, there, Selin...

With the role you gave me, I'm trying to get best out of it! The island was big enough to discover and I was worrying that I can't swim to the boat, but suddenly LSU helped me there.

I'm thinking you're likely 3rd party yourself w/ the goal of escaping the island.

Lastly, i can understand the suspicion towards us, i was very suprised myself when i got the role and was a townie. I wouldn't have set it up that way, but AD obviously has different theories about the TV show Lost than i do, which is why its a great show. If the fact that we are basically prostrating ourselves at the feet of the rest of the town and declaring our innocence isn't enough for then go ahead and kill one of us. and when the results come back EXACTLY the way we are saying then you will get a big ole I TOLD YOU SO and succesfully killed off a townie.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote PMC it is very scummy of you trying to off what I'm telling you a protownie role that will be helpful in the game. Why limit the town to only 1 watcher when we were given two to start and both are effective? I had already offered myself up as sacrifice after completing the mason group that is for the town as proof that we are for the town instead of against the town, but you don't think that is good enough.

FOS at Selin You are great usually as town, but as 3rd party or scum Selin you are acting very scummy.

[Fircoal]

I don't know it seems like Mandy was lying which is the deal. So I think he would be a better choice to test it out.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Fircoal if he is who he says he is during the night I can find that out. All I have to do is send off the name of the CHARACTER and at the end of the night I am given the player that is playing that part. If anyone OTHER then Mandy is playing that character, we can lynch Mandy tomorrow. If I am given Mandy as he claims that is his player, you would just be lynching a power townie.

[pmchugh]

Vote PMC it is very scummy of you trying to off what I'm telling you a protownie role that will be helpful in the game. Why limit the town to only 1 watcher when we were given two to start and both are effective? I had already offered myself up as sacrifice after completing the mason group that is for the town as proof that we are for the town instead of against the town, but you don't think that is good enough.

FOS at Selin You are great usually as town, but as 3rd party or scum Selin you are acting very scummy.

why the hell are you voting me? Isnt it clear i am not scum considering yesterday it was me that brought the case up against the godfather. And if there was to be another scum group surely it would be you lot. Your vote is purely OMGUS (for your group) because I am clearly not scum. Im still unconvinced of your pro-townness.

[mandalorian2298]

Vote PMC it is very scummy of you trying to off what I'm telling you a protownie role that will be helpful in the game. Why limit the town to only 1 watcher when we were given two to start and both are effective? I had already offered myself up as sacrifice after completing the mason group that is for the town as proof that we are for the town instead of against the town, but you don't think that is good enough.

FOS at Selin You are great usually as town, but as 3rd party or scum Selin you are acting very scummy.

Vote PMC?! Dude, thank you for defending me and all, but voting the pro-town heor of day one without a shred of proof gives me no other option but to vote for you.

Unvote vote LSU

[LSU Tiger Josh]

It is possible that he is an Userper. I have yet to see proof that he is anything than a scumbag trying to eliminate what is a watcher that can help the town. That to me is VERY SCUMMY.

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(3) Nagerous – GT, rebelman, SECRET VOTE
(1) Sentinel XIV - Iliad
(9) Mandalorian2298 - Selin, /, ditocoaf, pmchugh, Nagerous, LoVO, cmckinney, Sentinel XIV, Fircoal
(1) pmchugh - LSU Tiger Josh
(1) LSU Tiger Josh - Mandalorian2298

With 19 alive it takes ten to lynch!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'll say this much that even if he is NOT an Userper there really is no reason to kill off Mandy a claimed watcher when I can easily verify if he is who he claims during the night phase. You already have the name of someone else in my group and all of you voting on Mandy are really just showing yourselves to be brainwashed knuckleheads I've already addressed the question on if the crashed helicoptor group were protownies or not and have even volunteered my own lynch on Day 4 if that is the evidence you "want". Right now though, I think I'll go find my old t-shirt that says never doubt the power of stupid people in large numbers if you either insist on lynching mandy or myself today instead of doing the smart thing and waiting until my mason group verifies who mandy is and then after that group is complete lynching one that will at that point lose their power other then being a mason and voting during the day.

[got tonkaed]

Im just not sure having read over some of the last few pages if mandy is legit or if i want LSU attempting to "verify him" which could be a problem down the line. Im just not sure i believe that even if mandy is a watcher that he is helpful to the town.

Therefore ill hammer...

Unvote Vote Mandalorian

[nagerous]

[Anarkistsdream]

DAMMIT!

You WOULD have to hammer while I'm at work, wouldn't you, Tonkaed?

Lynch scene will be in about 7 hours.

It is twilight, so you may continue talking... However, make sure nothing of substance is revealed...


Mandy, if you still have your role PM, send it to me and I can get the lynch scene up earlier.... Thanks.

[pmchugh]

i hope we were right...

[Sentinel XIV]

It is interesting to see how LSU is tying himself to mandalorian so intently. I mean, he is trying with great verve to keep him alive. I hope, for LSU's sake, he is not scum. If he is, LSU looks very suspicious.

Also, LSU, a quick question:

Do you not think it is a benefit to sacrifice a possible 3rd party member to find out a great deal of information?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I think it is right to do at CERTAIN times. Early on when you've already given the info from another member of said party, I think it is dumb to do at least on a power role. If my role info is correct then the said person was in fact a watcher. FOS at GT for the hammer.

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(2) Nagerous – rebelman, SECRET VOTE
(1) Sentinel XIV - Iliad
(10) Mandalorian2298 - Selin, /, ditocoaf, pmchugh, Nagerous, LoVO, cmckinney, Sentinel XIV, Fircoal, GT
(1) pmchugh - LSU Tiger Josh
(1) LSU Tiger Josh - Mandalorian2298

With 19 alive it takes ten to lynch!

And so it was that the crowd of survivors gathered around Mandalorian2298, disbelieving that a man who admits he's from the boat off-shore could actually be here for the benefit of the survivors.

"Wait," Jack says. "We can't just kill this guy. He may be here to help us."

But before anyone will listen to him, they grab poor Mandy and strip him naked, hanging him from the nearest coconut tree.

Mandalorian2298 - Miles Straume - Watcher

has been lynched!

It is now night. You have 72 hours to send in your night actions.

NO TALKING!

[Ditocoaf]

ugh... so much of this depends on Anark's interpretation of the show.

In the last episode, Faraday finally admits that they never planned to help the survivors, which many people figured from the beginning of the season. But Anark seems to consider them pro-town... so will knowledge of the show be worthless, since it's all subject to opinion?

ugh.