Battledome map [Abandoned]

[SunTsu]

I have recently created a map for WaW, BattleDome:


For the non WaW players here: The red boxes are capitals. They spawn an extra army on that country every time you take a turn. Also... WaW is pretty standard about 42 countries and 6 continents. That's why both Wacht and Woord are also capitals, but the two of them don't make a continent.


I wanted to port this to CC:



Ofcourse this is a work in progress, and the capitals will not be quite and exactly like I intended and how they work in WaW, but I think it'll still be workable...

Any ideas?

[vangogh62]

Sun,
I actually like this one better than the one at W@W. Seems cleaner, and you can use a larger map size. Playing a game on Battledome right now and it is certainly a tough one. I would like to see a map as this where there are no territories/countries that are protected from any other territory/country. The "diskworld" here would be a good idea to start - however I think it would need to be a true circle with all linking across the center like a bike wheel.

Van

[AndyDufresne]

It is an interesting idea and something worth consideration. Obviously though a complete overhaul on graphics to make it look much more sleek and splendid would be a starting place. Even if a map plays wells and is an instant success, it would still benefit in the long run from looking and feeling like a map, rather than random colored shapes on a background.


--Andy

[SunTsu]

This will probably give you an impression on how it's (probably) going to look with borders and all...

[Jota]

What's the difference between the solid lines in the green area and the lines with gaps in the blue area?

[SunTsu]

The blue continent is already done with gaps showing where the country borders are... The green continent has yet to be done...

[AndyDufresne]

I.E. the map is currently incomplete and a working rough draft. Try to get a 'finished' rough draft (what an oxymoron) up.

--Andy

[SunTsu]

Ok... the first draft of the map is finished...




This is more or less the map that's been played on at WaW for a few months now. There are differences, however, these are:

* The large continents in the middle look a bit different. Diagonal attacks are not possible anymore. The capitals have moved because of this.
* The capitals work slightly different here, since CC doesn't (yet) accomodate for armies being placed on the capitals themselves, you'll receive them as a continent bonus.

The countrynames are commonly used Dutch words (yes, I am Dutch). The capitals of the normal continents represent the Dutch word for the continent name.

[Marvaddin]

It remember me the Crossword map... I really dislike. Its not a beautiful thing to watch, and to me the appeal is a complete zero. If it looks like a castle or something, but it really seems another type of numbers pastime from a crossword magazine.

Maybe Im being too harsh, but I suggest you to create a poll to know if people will play it... You have my vote already. But its just my opinion, dont become angry

[Jota]

So... what exactly does it represent? I had been hoping it would become clearer with the later version, but I still can't tell. Is it some sort of stadium/arena? The name and layout would suggest that, but the territory names seem to be intended to be geographical.

[thegrimsleeper]

What's so exciting about taking over a bunch of colored squares?

[onbekende]

I like that every word is in Dutch, making a map of Flanders with Flemish names

Let the dutch-speaking people take over here

[max is gr8]

What are the pink squars for just as capitals

[SunTsu]

What are the pink squars for just as capitals

As I've stated before, this map was first designed for World at War, which can handle only 42 countries and 6 continents... I was wondering if the system could handle two countries not related to any continent, and apparantly it could...

In any case, people are playing the map at WaW, so I figured people would play this map here as well... Hell, people here even play the crossword map

As to what is exciting about conquering some colored squares... ever heard of something called imagination, you might want to use that some time, it'll make life in general a little more exciting...

Lastly I will also point out the educational value of this map to non-Dutch speaking people.... broaden your horizon...

[AndyDufresne]

Imagination is fine and dandy, and even though the Crossword map is played, it is one of the less played ones. It's already got its own niche of players, I don't know if there are enough to have these two maps. I doesn't appeal to me, and usually things do.

Perhaps if you spruce up the visuals. Try not just doing simple colors, and boxes. Look into perhaps things with more visual quality. Images, maybe of a stadium, or some sort of battle arena? This map could have potential, but I don't know how much.


--Andy

[kingwaffles]

I happen to be one those who occupy the crossword niche and this feeles quite different and I don't think I would play it. It's really just a bunch of boxes....

[Jota]

I don't imagine the Crossword map would have even the fans it does if it didn't resemble a crossword puzzle. I think that to be of interest to players, a map has to represent something, even if that something is an abstract concept totally unrelated to geographical territory.

That said, I think there's merit to AndyDufresne's suggestion of modifying this to resemble an arena of some kind. It'd give it a theme and some flavor.

[ThuMp]

Yeah Sun, maybe you should make it resemble something! Hey, I know. Make it resemble your own idea of a Battle Dome

I've played a bunch of games on this map at http://www.wawgame.com/ and it plays very well. I can't wait to try it here!

[thegrimsleeper]

What if you renamed it Thunderdome and it had all sorts of post-apocalyptic Mad-Max style graphics? I'd play that.

[Dark Shadow]

It looks interesting, I would play it.

[pevanelagas]

I didn't read everything here.. Although, have you considered making 1 or 2 of those small squares in the corners only have 1 way to enter and exit?


This would do a few things to the gameplay, wich I definately approve of.


A. Those 2 area's would either be strongly gone after, or strongly avoided. (brings australia back into the mix) This would, hopefully, confuse many larger players and the newer players who aren't used to the normal risk wouldn't be confused at the similarities and would have better judgement..*hopefully*, not to mention.. It also makes it much harder to capture and secure the 1 square connected to them(if there are 2 with only 1 entrance, especially if they linkt o the same large square.)

B. Looks cool ... AND, it sounds cool... AND It'd let 1 person protect another after he lost a few troops, and etc..etc.etc...

etc.etc.etc.

thoughts?



-I'd definately play it either way, nice map!-

[SunTsu]

pevanelagas, could you give an example of this with countrynames? I sounds rather interesting....

[pevanelagas]

I just edited your pictures with paint, and it looks really bad but it gets my point across.

I hope you don't mind?

I made 1 resembling my description, and I made 3 other just random ones. Basically, all I'm trying to express is that yours is...; very.. boring?

Its just a bunch of squares, the ones I made from yours allow for alot of planning or alot of random attacking. Wichever suits you

Although, i think it'd favor the planners^


Oh, and I guess you'd probably need to change the value of owning all of 1 color.

Of course, this is still your idea..; and if you want me to remove the picture consider it done. It doesn'thave to be here

Also, feel free to branch off from my idea.. Doesn't bother me any, I'd actually be sorta flattered

[SunTsu]

I think the general idea is clear... I'll do some editing when I've found the time for it, and update the map a little...

Anyone else thoughts on this?

[Marvaddin]

I believe pevanelagas version is even worse than yours... I wouldnt do the map if I were you... unless, of course, you can increase the appeal with some great graphics.