Nashville Mafia Wars Mafia Night 3_Terror Subsides

[AceArtemis]

MEGA FoS Edocsil since I highly doubt that colton would put such a boring, useless role in a game like this.

My vote stays on lalaland though, because I find him suspicious and want a claim. After the claim, we'll lynch the less believable claim.

[aage]

For one I hope Edoc gets NK'd. It's well possible that his role is 3rd party and he's a survivor. Should be playable survivor with no vote is not someone you'd think of as a threat

[Fircoal]

Technically the ??? are on no LUNCH. Just saying.

Don't know what colton means with no lunch, but it's together with Cena's vote, which was on no lynch.

It's called Colton stealing mah phrases. x3

[Fircoal]

Your vote was on Fircoal FYI.

Oldrisky, is there a reason you're not choosing one of your suspects as a "main suspect" and start voting someone again?

Lastly, there still is no replacement for Duday. Colton, go get someone. I'm betting ga7 would join.

Lastly I'm rereading the first few pages and thinking... A role with seriously NOTHING in it (not even a vote) is not worth anything. Not even to town. I'm guessing there's more behind Edocsil than he likes to make us believe. It's reason enough for me to change my vote:
unvote vote edocsil
Simply because I want to know what power there is behind that role of yours. If there's no power, we lost nothing by lynching you. If there is, I think it's well worth trying to get it on the table. I'm thinking of a third party sk role that can't vote, or something like that. With these 2 mafia factions and the dead godfather I'm not unkeen on lynching a 3rd party on day 1.

Just because his role isn't worth anything doesn't mean that you should lynch him. It's entirely possible that he's town as I've seen that role put in games and have even put it in games once before. The fact that you don't bring up any other proof of why Edoc is scum makes me very suspicious of you. You've been jumping around your vote more than Colton when he's trying to get lynched. With 5 scum out of 11 people I don't think we can really take the chance of lynching Edoc. If he's a townie we just dug a big hole for ourselves because we need as much town alive as possible. To do that we have to lynch based off of scumminess and not role.

My personal vote is that Aage and Lalaland are both scum.

Vote: aage

[oldrisky44]

My personal vote is that Aage and Lalaland are both scum.

Vote: aage

Agree. Fircoal switch your vote to lala and she's out.

[Fircoal]

My personal vote is that Aage and Lalaland are both scum.

Vote: aage

Agree. Fircoal switch your vote to lala and she's out.

we need to let her claim first at the very least.

[aage]

Just because his role isn't worth anything doesn't mean that you should lynch him. It's entirely possible that he's town as I've seen that role put in games and have even put it in games once before. The fact that you don't bring up any other proof of why Edoc is scum makes me very suspicious of you. You've been jumping around your vote more than Colton when he's trying to get lynched. With 5 scum out of 11 people I don't think we can really take the chance of lynching Edoc. If he's a townie we just dug a big hole for ourselves because we need as much town alive as possible. To do that we have to lynch based off of scumminess and not role.

My personal vote is that Aage and Lalaland are both scum.

Vote: aage

1) Town without vote is not helping towards the Lynch vote count, so it doesn't make a difference towards when scum will win.
2) I don't need arguments to be suspicious of a special power assigned to a towny with no vote. I never saw the role before, that's why I was suspicious of it and that's why I wanted to find out.
3) why lynch me, except the part where I'm trying to get discussion going and you're obviously not?

[Fircoal]

Just because his role isn't worth anything doesn't mean that you should lynch him. It's entirely possible that he's town as I've seen that role put in games and have even put it in games once before. The fact that you don't bring up any other proof of why Edoc is scum makes me very suspicious of you. You've been jumping around your vote more than Colton when he's trying to get lynched. With 5 scum out of 11 people I don't think we can really take the chance of lynching Edoc. If he's a townie we just dug a big hole for ourselves because we need as much town alive as possible. To do that we have to lynch based off of scumminess and not role.

My personal vote is that Aage and Lalaland are both scum.

Vote: aage

1) Town without vote is not helping towards the Lynch vote count, so it doesn't make a difference towards when scum will win.
2) I don't need arguments to be suspicious of a special power assigned to a towny with no vote. I never saw the role before, that's why I was suspicious of it and that's why I wanted to find out.
3) why lynch me, except the part where I'm trying to get discussion going and you're obviously not?

1) It still does make a difference I would say. Serves as one less townie.
2) I'm suspicious of it too, but that doesn't mean I'm gonna vote him for it. Not yet, not now.
3) Because you look scummy obviously?

[colton24]

Vote Count
Fircoal(1)-freezie
no lunch(2)-cena-rules, ???
lalaland(4)L-2-spiesr, AceArtemis, oldrisky44, aage
Edocsil(2)-aage, Victor Sullivan
aage(1)-Fircoal

Not voting: duday53, edocsil, lalaland

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch

lalaland is at L-2

[lalaland]

As I'm L-2 with a hidden vote floating around, I suppose I must claim.
I'm Father Anthony, a town priest. I cannot cast a lynching vote.

[freezie]

MEGA FoS Edocsil since I highly doubt that colton would put such a boring, useless role in a game like this.

My vote stays on lalaland though, because I find him suspicious and want a claim. After the claim, we'll lynch the less believable claim.

Dude...have you been paying attention? Edoscil voted for someone, and never showed up on the corrected vote counts.

Hence, he IS a voteless townie. On that nobody can argument, since it's mod-proved. It's one of the few roles in the game that you can prove you have without any doubts.

He COULD be a voteless mafia..but the actual role is a voteless townie, and I wouldn't beleive colton changed that.

And with lala's claim..( -.- ) Unvote

Vote: AceArtemis

for trying to place suspicion on a mod-proved role.

[oldrisky44]

I don't understand that lala can't cast a lynching vote. Any vote is a lynching vote, isn't it? Or do you mean you can't be the final lynching vote?

[freezie]

A priest cannot hammer, pretty much.

[Fircoal]

As I'm L-2 with a hidden vote floating around, I suppose I must claim.
I'm Father Anthony, a town priest. I cannot cast a lynching vote.

WTF!?!?!?!??!? Either Colton deliberately made town super weak for the lolz, you're lying, or there are some seriously strong power roles out there. This makes no sensezel!

[spiesr]

Dude...have you been paying attention? Edoscil voted for someone, and never showed up on the corrected vote counts.
Hence, he IS a voteless townie. On that nobody can argument, since it's mod-proved. It's one of the few roles in the game that you can prove you have without any doubts.
He COULD be a voteless mafia..but the actual role is a voteless townie, and I wouldn't beleive colton changed that.

Well, all that is actually "proven" is that he apparently can't cast a regular vote. It proves nothing regarding his alignment, whether or not he is the secret voter, or any other powers he could have. Now at the moment it appears that voteless townie is most likely his role, but saying that it is "proven" it stretching our information beyond what it actually can prove...

[edocsil]

For one I hope Edoc gets NK'd. It's well possible that his role is 3rd party and he's a survivor. Should be playable survivor with no vote is not someone you'd think of as a threat

Cruel and unusual logic...

First off whats the point of a voteless nightactionless survivor, or even a voteless survivor? I have never heard of a role like that, just scum or town. I would hope that only a scum would waste a NK on me. FoS aage, though he may mean well I find his logic poor

[AceArtemis]

Dude...have you been paying attention? Edoscil voted for someone, and never showed up on the corrected vote counts.

Hence, he IS a voteless townie. On that nobody can argument, since it's mod-proved. It's one of the few roles in the game that you can prove you have without any doubts.

He COULD be a voteless mafia..but the actual role is a voteless townie, and I wouldn't beleive colton changed that.

And with lala's claim..( -.- ) Unvote

Vote: AceArtemis

for trying to place suspicion on a mod-proved role.

You really misinterpreted what I meant. Of course Edocsil is telling the truth...but is he telling the full truth, and nothing but the truth? Edocsil could have abilities that make up for his lack of voting, that he's not telling us because either he's town and doesn't want the mafia to know, or he's mafia.

Unvote in light of lalaland's claim. As Fircoal said, we must have a lot of powerful town roles, or a very weak town, or Lalaland and/or Edocsil aren't telling he full story.

[aage]

Whatever Ace said. You people assume too quickly to my liking that when Edoc says "im a voteless towny" he is NOTHING ELSE except a voteless towny.

@Edocsil above me
Yeah, a voteless survivor really sounds like a role Colton would've come up with. Especially since there are already so many sucky roles in there.

[oldrisky44]

I think colton should have named this "Paranoia Unrelenting Mafia Wars of Suspicious Mystery Powers".

I sure picked a tough one for my first time out of the gate.

Is it possible that there are no REAL mafia, and everybody in this game is some kind of weird powered townie?

[Victor Sullivan]

I think colton should have named this "Paranoia Unrelenting Mafia Wars of Suspicious Mystery Powers".

I sure picked a tough one for my first time out of the gate.

Is it possible that there are no REAL mafia, and everybody in this game is some kind of weird powered townie?

lol, of course not! One of them is lying through their teeth.

[edocsil]

I think colton should have named this "Paranoia Unrelenting Mafia Wars of Suspicious Mystery Powers".

I sure picked a tough one for my first time out of the gate.

Is it possible that there are no REAL mafia, and everybody in this game is some kind of weird powered townie?

lol, of course not! One of them is lying through their teeth.

Or the few who have claimed are town. Not impossible.

[cena-rules]

Right, we are still no further to finding out mafia and we have found one town role, though sucky, still means the mafia can go about killing each other, which could be their win condition! Also, this day has dragged on with not a lot of information

Furthermore STOP TRYING TO BE LIKE FIRCOAL COLTON!

My vote stands

[duday53]

Can we get a vote count?

Edoc - I'll believe it for now. However lalaland, you cannot hammer?

How about I put you at L-1 and you vote yourself. If you are telling the truth then you won't be lynched. :p

[edocsil]

Can we get a vote count?

Edoc - I'll believe it for now. However lalaland, you cannot hammer?

How about I put you at L-1 and you vote yourself. If you are telling the truth then you won't be lynched. :p

Actually, I support this.

[spiesr]

How about I put you at L-1 and you vote yourself. If you are telling the truth then you won't be lynched.

That sounds like an interesting, if somewhat unorthodox method of testing his claim. The issue with it being the unpredictable ??? vote that flies around the vote count at random. If we could find out way to make sure that it doesn't hammer than I would say this is worth thinking about...