Rodion wrote:pancakemix wrote:Open Question: Without actually naming the contradiction, can anyone in here say they knew what contradiction ghostly was talking about in regard to Looten?
I "understood" after Ghostly explained it D2. When Looten made the challenge (lynch him and if he is town lynch Ghostly next) Ghostly spun this into a "how can you be town if you don't care who's lynched which is mafia behaviour" and thus considered this a contradiction, which he later acknowledged not to be a "textbook" contradiction. I personally only understood the explanations after Looten got "baited" into raging and got modkilled, but it is possible that Ghostly explained it before D1 ended somewhere around the biblical quotes and the major mutual raging I quite frankly did not bother to read.ghostly447 wrote:And lets not single anyone out! I will make a random order list for a yoshi roll call (not role like your actual role, just sign in and give you input!)
This reminds me of a funny story. It involved Yoshi and Zimmah if I recall correctly.ghostly447 wrote:1. He understands day one lynches, and how random they are and how much info they give. That shows town in my eyes.
That shows he possesses (or pretended to possess) general mafia knowledge. Period.ghostly447 wrote:2. Thinks I should be lynched if he flips town. That shows Mafia in my eyes because why if he was town would he want another towny to risk that? He did flip town, therefore the blame is on me for you know..Leading a fucking case the second I got here. But it still would favor mafia if he flipped town then I did too.. Mafia.
Couldn't he truly believe you were mafia? This way, after being lynched D1 at least he would have helped town (from his perspective) in that he set up mafia (you, again from his perspective) for the D2 lynch.
Besides, if he flipped mafia as you suspected he would, all this would be moot, no?ghostly447 wrote:3. He knows I dont 100% know but still wants me to put my life on the line. Mafia.
Why mafia? If he flipped mafia this would all be moot and you would not be lynched. If he flipped town, then he's proven town. This is to say I don't see the mafia motivation in saying "lynch me and if I flip town lynch player X".
You have your points, but what if I am not mafia? What if he didnt make a counter case (he didnt) so he could not honestly say that I was mafia except for OMGUS because I was leading his lynch...So, I guess OMGUS has its benefits, but is it really something town can be able to lynch a suspected mafia over? Its all kind of silly if that is how people play.
I can accept that some of my points are not fully, if at all, strong. But I am doing what I can to keep this game active. If that is scummy, lynch me now. Here is the random generator:
Shieldgenerator7 - Skip he is out of town.
Kratos644 - Skip unless he has any more input (enough input given)
crazymilkshake5 replaced by Rodion
Fircoal replaced by ghostly447 - I dont think I have to give much more since I obviously wont listen to any new input.

TA1LGUNN3R
Edocsil
Iron Butterfly
Freezie
Pancakemix - Skip unless he has any more input (enough input given)
zimmah
Victor Sullivan
Eldario
strike wolf - Give quite a bit of input. May have a bit more to say (always does) but I wont be heartbroken if he doesnt. (enough input given)
Some7hingclever
jonty125
Lets get it done:
The marks are my personal opinion. I dont care if they do or dont add more input. If the others dont give any more input, then I may be pretty disappointed after everything that has been said.
The game is for fun, but its only fun if you give input IMO. So lets get to it!