Moderator: Community Team
safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
aage wrote:safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
So there's three cops in this game according to you? And you don't even bother to mention that, since you claim to be town, DJ Fireside must be lying? vote stays.
safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
samgrossy wrote:safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.
safariguy5 wrote:samgrossy wrote:safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.
I'm claiming because the insane cop got an innocent result on me which is basically like a sane cop getting a guilty result on me.
What's interesting here is that aage says that his vote stays because DJ is lying. But not 1-2 pages ago, it was brought up that busdriver could be either mafia or town aligned. So aage just automatically assumes the busdriver is town despite no other person actually confirming alignment. Could be aage got recruited to cult and he's afraid he's going to have to make up some night actions because he lost his actual powers.
aage wrote:safariguy5 wrote:samgrossy wrote:safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
Why are you claiming when you only have on person voting you. This seems suspicious to me. I'm not sure if its scummy or not, but it just doesn't seem like a very good idea.
I'm claiming because the insane cop got an innocent result on me which is basically like a sane cop getting a guilty result on me.
What's interesting here is that aage says that his vote stays because DJ is lying. But not 1-2 pages ago, it was brought up that busdriver could be either mafia or town aligned. So aage just automatically assumes the busdriver is town despite no other person actually confirming alignment. Could be aage got recruited to cult and he's afraid he's going to have to make up some night actions because he lost his actual powers.
My problem is not that DJ could be mafia. My problem is that your defense is so poorly constructed that you don't even care to mention that DJ has to be scum for you to be telling the truth. Nice try twisting my words. Also nice try at diverting attention towards me as a possible cult recruit (which is, let's be honest, the least of our concerns right now) while there has been a cop claim against you which I have nothing to do with. I hope that whoever is left of town still has their senses about them.
redhedge47 wrote:lets hear it you clearly dont have any guilty results you would have already told us claiming with one vote is fairly scummy if you ask me
Vote Safari
redhedge47 wrote:lets hear it you clearly dont have any guilty results you would have already told us claiming with one vote is fairly scummy if you ask me
Vote Safari
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
edocsil wrote:So here is how it stands. Right now I think Hippo V2 or aage is the CL, but I want to review my lists of night actions before I make a final call. I think this for 1 reason primarily. Others are largely following their lead. See the current wagon, and the wagon of yesterday.
thehippo8 wrote:Well, I am caught up. I firstly have to apologise to LSU - in my previous incarnation I dithered about not keeping attention and calling the game dull. I was wrong to dither and I am certainly wrong about it being dull - ain't anything but!
Anyway, that aside, let me first say that I do not believe that Saf can be a rolecop. I seriously doubt there would be two of those! Maybe Saf has some sort of espionage skill that let's him tap into the rolecop's results but that just makes me laugh. To prove I am right, Aage, let me do this in stages. Please answer the questions (which I will drip feed) exactly.
Question: Aage - did you go near Sam on night 3?
aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:Well, I am caught up. I firstly have to apologise to LSU - in my previous incarnation I dithered about not keeping attention and calling the game dull. I was wrong to dither and I am certainly wrong about it being dull - ain't anything but!
Anyway, that aside, let me first say that I do not believe that Saf can be a rolecop. I seriously doubt there would be two of those! Maybe Saf has some sort of espionage skill that let's him tap into the rolecop's results but that just makes me laugh. To prove I am right, Aage, let me do this in stages. Please answer the questions (which I will drip feed) exactly.
Question: Aage - did you go near Sam on night 3?
Yeah. But there hasn't been another rolecop, fyi, just a regular cop.
safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
thehippo8 wrote:aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:Well, I am caught up. I firstly have to apologise to LSU - in my previous incarnation I dithered about not keeping attention and calling the game dull. I was wrong to dither and I am certainly wrong about it being dull - ain't anything but!
Anyway, that aside, let me first say that I do not believe that Saf can be a rolecop. I seriously doubt there would be two of those! Maybe Saf has some sort of espionage skill that let's him tap into the rolecop's results but that just makes me laugh. To prove I am right, Aage, let me do this in stages. Please answer the questions (which I will drip feed) exactly.
Question: Aage - did you go near Sam on night 3?
Yeah. But there hasn't been another rolecop, fyi, just a regular cop.
You missed this ...safariguy5 wrote:I'm not scum, I'm Mr. P the rolecop.
I know what roles aage and strike/hippo are (the other people are all dead), but I'm concerned revealing them would set them up as prime targets for cult recruitment because then cult would have a lower chance of hitting mafia.
I'm perfectly willing to reveal them if that is the wishes of everyone, but I'm a bit concerned about cult recruitment.
... hence my questions.
So you visited Sam night 3.
Next question for Aage: Did you protect Sam?
samgrossy wrote:redhedge47 wrote:lets hear it you clearly dont have any guilty results you would have already told us claiming with one vote is fairly scummy if you ask me
Vote Safari
This adds to the summary that aage put out. You would think that if someone comes out and calls you a scummariner, you would make a better effort to make a longer post than just one line.
FoS REDHEDGE
thehippo8 wrote:It is possible but highly unlikely that Saf is also a rolecop. But before continuing with that, one more question.
Third Question: Did you use an additional power while you protected Sam?
As you consider this question, ask yourself ... how can thehippo know this without knowing my role? I don't want to state your role right now as that does not serve this purpose. But the point of these question is to have you reconsider Saf's declaration that he is a role cop.
As I said, I find that very hard to believe.
Following from there the inevitable question is ... who and what really is he? And is that a mystery that is so easily resolved without him being lynched?
Again, I await your answer to the main question above before pondering this further.
aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:It is possible but highly unlikely that Saf is also a rolecop. But before continuing with that, one more question.
Third Question: Did you use an additional power while you protected Sam?
As you consider this question, ask yourself ... how can thehippo know this without knowing my role? I don't want to state your role right now as that does not serve this purpose. But the point of these question is to have you reconsider Saf's declaration that he is a role cop.
As I said, I find that very hard to believe.
Following from there the inevitable question is ... who and what really is he? And is that a mystery that is so easily resolved without him being lynched?
Again, I await your answer to the main question above before pondering this further.
I'm not sure if I want to answer that question right now. Lots of people still have to vote, we need to get people to add their night actions to their claims, there's a rolecop on the loose who claims to know my role and the cylt leader is probably still alive. Maybe you should look back at night 1 for an answer.
aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:It is possible but highly unlikely that Saf is also a rolecop. But before continuing with that, one more question.
Third Question: Did you use an additional power while you protected Sam?
As you consider this question, ask yourself ... how can thehippo know this without knowing my role? I don't want to state your role right now as that does not serve this purpose. But the point of these question is to have you reconsider Saf's declaration that he is a role cop.
As I said, I find that very hard to believe.
Following from there the inevitable question is ... who and what really is he? And is that a mystery that is so easily resolved without him being lynched?
Again, I await your answer to the main question above before pondering this further.
I'm not sure if I want to answer that question right now. Lots of people still have to vote, we need to get people to add their night actions to their claims, there's a rolecop on the loose who claims to know my role and the cylt leader is probably still alive. Maybe you should look back at night 1 for an answer.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
edocsil wrote:aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:It is possible but highly unlikely that Saf is also a rolecop. But before continuing with that, one more question.
Third Question: Did you use an additional power while you protected Sam?
As you consider this question, ask yourself ... how can thehippo know this without knowing my role? I don't want to state your role right now as that does not serve this purpose. But the point of these question is to have you reconsider Saf's declaration that he is a role cop.
As I said, I find that very hard to believe.
Following from there the inevitable question is ... who and what really is he? And is that a mystery that is so easily resolved without him being lynched?
Again, I await your answer to the main question above before pondering this further.
I'm not sure if I want to answer that question right now. Lots of people still have to vote, we need to get people to add their night actions to their claims, there's a rolecop on the loose who claims to know my role and the cylt leader is probably still alive. Maybe you should look back at night 1 for an answer.
Why dodge the issue? We need a mass claim to find the CL anyhow.
aage wrote:edocsil wrote:aage wrote:thehippo8 wrote:It is possible but highly unlikely that Saf is also a rolecop. But before continuing with that, one more question.
Third Question: Did you use an additional power while you protected Sam?
As you consider this question, ask yourself ... how can thehippo know this without knowing my role? I don't want to state your role right now as that does not serve this purpose. But the point of these question is to have you reconsider Saf's declaration that he is a role cop.
As I said, I find that very hard to believe.
Following from there the inevitable question is ... who and what really is he? And is that a mystery that is so easily resolved without him being lynched?
Again, I await your answer to the main question above before pondering this further.
I'm not sure if I want to answer that question right now. Lots of people still have to vote, we need to get people to add their night actions to their claims, there's a rolecop on the loose who claims to know my role and the cylt leader is probably still alive. Maybe you should look back at night 1 for an answer.
Why dodge the issue? We need a mass claim to find the CL anyhow.
I gave four reasons. I agree we need a mass claim but I'd prefer if the rest of the players were actually there to claim. I could give you a list of whom I visited on which night if that satisfies you.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users