The Thing TOWN WINS!

[DirtyDishSoap]

On another note, happy with the activity, but to put a cattle prod for everyone, i will implement a deadline the end of next week. (Not going to do this on a holiday.) Hope everyone is still enjoying this game despite how slap stick it has been.

[SoN!c]

Lets continue. Votanic explained himself he is shooting from the hip at everyThing that moves.. And strike said nothing wrong..

So: Nothing to see here, let's cary on. We have a Thing to find or we will all be Things pretty soon.

Did i already said it's Traf and how strange it is Traf never searched for the Thing? D2 lynch beeing the last chance and Traf wanting to win..

But no search whatsoever? Why is that do you think?

[SoN!c]

Great job Ragian, you've taken your dumb vendetta against me all the way to a lynch vote...
...and look who is the first person to jump on your bandwagon...Sonic!!!

Hopefully you're feeling a little embarassed right now.

Man, you and EW seem to defend each other like crazy.

Votanic: it was agreed we would follow the BT one if he tested negative

I have plenty qualms with Votanic's posts, but a large part of Rag vs Votanic feels personal and not game-related to me. Feel free to pair me with Votanic for today though, just remember that tomorrow everything changes again.

I still much prefer a Traf lynch. Or heck, a Sonic lynch. Guess who's laughing on the sidelines?

Tomorrow we are dead and you know it..at least your searching..

The lynch D2 is last call in the last chance saloon.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Oh Dear. U still continue have 0 proofs but just are shoehorned.

I have given my list of suspects. And I actually eblieve you slightly changed D1 to D2 game play.

I am willing to Lynch Sonic (As jsut mentioned I thing he went for a more aggressive D2 playstile), Charle (Jumping into every bandwagon) or even EW (I agree with strike the thing might try to recruit a smart player) All of them voted for Rag and I think the thing or the converted or both voted for someone to BT as they need it in order to not being bted themselves. I don't think Votanic is the thing but if deadline approach and rag have more insight on him then I might lynch him

[SoN!c]

Oh Dear. U still continue have 0 proofs but just are shoehorned.

I have given my list of suspects. And I actually eblieve you slightly changed D1 to D2 game play.

I am willing to Lynch Sonic (As jsut mentioned I thing he went for a more aggressive D2 playstile), Charle (Jumping into every bandwagon) or even EW (I agree with strike the thing might try to recruit a smart player) All of them voted for Rag and I think the thing or the converted or both voted for someone to BT as they need it in order to not being bted themselves. I don't think Votanic is the thing but if deadline approach and rag have more insight on him then I might lynch him

So you say the Thing is me (how convenient), Charle, EW or Votanic. Also saying "have 0 proofs".. saying "you have 0 proof" is only what the guilty say..

Im pretty sure its you and your recruit is one of those 3 then. Must be Votanic.

So lynch me, see im town, and you have your D3 names.

[Ragian]

I'm hung over. Will be back tomorrow.

[Charle]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

[Votanic]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

[SoN!c]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

You don't need reasoning Votanic. Asking for reasoning when you say your just going with Votanic reasoning in the end is kinda,.. "votanic" you know.

[Votanic]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

You don't need reasoning Votanic. Asking for reasoning when you say your just going with Votanic reasoning is kinda,.. "votanic" you know.

What the..?? I'd ask you to explain this latest satement, but that is just inviting you to lay down another layer of your BS that makes reasoning in this game that much more difficult.

Everybody else (besides Sonic): You need to run two separate analyses on this game in your mind.
First, run it with Sonic left in... and then, run it again, but leave out all of his aberrant non-data. I think you'll see they look quite different.

[SoN!c]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

You don't need reasoning Votanic. Asking for reasoning when you say your just going with Votanic reasoning is kinda,.. "votanic" you know.

What the..?? I'd ask you to explain this latest satement, but that is just inviting you to lay down another layer of your BS that makes reasoning in this game that much more difficult.

Everybody else (besides Sonic): You need to run two separate analyses on this game in your mind.
First, run it with Sonic left in... and then, run it again, but leave out all of his aberrant non-data. I think you'll see they look quite different.

No votanic. Its you that has the double standard. You expect perfect reasoning on you but you can blast away any "votanic" arguement on others. Like creating chaos is your marching order. Also not one defence from you on the "recruited part"... like you understand because it is. The more you and Traf post the more obvious it gets. Say i have "0 proof" please

If you were town anybody saying "you have 0 proof" would sound suspicious and you would wanna know more, but you ignore it completely like you already know

[Votanic]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

You don't need reasoning Votanic. Asking for reasoning when you say your just going with Votanic reasoning is kinda,.. "votanic" you know.

What the..?? I'd ask you to explain this latest satement, but that is just inviting you to lay down another layer of your BS that makes reasoning in this game that much more difficult.

Everybody else (besides Sonic): You need to run two separate analyses on this game in your mind.
First, run it with Sonic left in... and then, run it again, but leave out all of his aberrant non-data. I think you'll see they look quite different.

No votanic. Its you that has the double standard. You expect perfect reasoning on you but you can blast away any "votanic" arguement on others. Like creating chaos is your marching order. Also not one defence from you on the "recruited part"... like you understand because it is. The more you and Traf post the more obvious it gets. Say i have "0 proof" please

If you were town anybody saying "you have 0 proof" would sound suspicious and you would wanna know more, but you ignore it completely like you already know

Okay, I've already asked the reasonable players to explain... and I've told the unreasonable player to stop fake-'explaining', so I guess it's...

[SoN!c]

Here is my take on this so far, although I am not sure enough to cast a lynch vote:

The Thing:
1. Traf
2. EW
3. Votanic

Town (could be converted as well but not The Thing):
4. Deg
5. Ragian
6. Strike
7. Sonic
8. Swang
9. Me

Charle, could expand on this by giving a summary of your reasons.
...and I'd be very curious to hear your reasoning for everybody, not just me.

You don't need reasoning Votanic. Asking for reasoning when you say your just going with Votanic reasoning is kinda,.. "votanic" you know.

What the..?? I'd ask you to explain this latest satement, but that is just inviting you to lay down another layer of your BS that makes reasoning in this game that much more difficult.

Everybody else (besides Sonic): You need to run two separate analyses on this game in your mind.
First, run it with Sonic left in... and then, run it again, but leave out all of his aberrant non-data. I think you'll see they look quite different.

No votanic. Its you that has the double standard. You expect perfect reasoning on you but you can blast away any "votanic" arguement on others. Like creating chaos is your marching order. Also not one defence from you on the "recruited part"... like you understand because it is. The more you and Traf post the more obvious it gets. Say i have "0 proof" please

If you were town anybody saying "you have 0 proof" would sound suspicious and you would wanna know more, but you ignore it completely like you already know

Okay, I've already asked the reasonable players to explain... and I've told the unreasonable player to stop fake-'explaining', so I guess it's...

So that is how you look in the mirror?

Because you are "unreasonable player n°1"..

Ps: I am way more handsome then you then, even 20 years older at least

Yeah, getting "Thinged" is not good for the looks i suppose

[SoN!c]

You played the ball on Strike so playing the ball is also receiving the ball Votanic. Play ball. Dont drop your mic. Don't walk away like you given up.

The truth will emerge. And what will people remember? You defending somebody else at cost of your own reputation..

[Votanic]

Not talking to Sonic.

Anybody else, please get in here and post something.

Charle, still waiting on a reply from you.

Actually, whenever anybody votes or is considering a vote, please do include your reasons for it.
Because to me, a lot of what is happening now, Day 2, still just reads as random guesses, personal or irrelevant attacks, and worst of all, very purposely misleading nonsense.
Does anybody else feel that?

[swang918]

Hmm I wonder if sonic vs votanic is the Thing and recruit doing a misdirection song and dance? Probably not right? I got to be overthinking it

[Votanic]

Hmm I wonder if sonic vs votanic is the Thing and recruit doing a misdirection song and dance? Probably not right? I got to be overthinking it

Uh, yeah, you are overthinking it... but that's okay...

Better than underthinking it by starting a bandwagon because... I talked about the flavor of the game.

So Trang (or anyone else), just looking at the last few posts Sonic dropped since I asked Charle for clarification... Is that making sense to you?

First, he seems to try to flip my argument and say I'm not making sense... even though I don't have any overall theory that I'm pushing.
My only real argument or observation is that Sonic isn't making sense.
...and then in his last post, he says I'm trying to defend someone else... but that's not true either. I'm not defending anyone.

As far as I know any of you could be a Thing (except Ragian...), either 'original' or converted.
No one is a confirmed guilty or innocent in my book... but Sonic gets my vote for trying to capsize the whole boat with tidal waves of nonsense.
The only 'justifiable' explanation for such play is that he is scum... but if he's town, then the situation is even more bleak.

This game seems to be just guessing so far. Even is/when somebody does nail the Thing they'll probably just do it cluelessly for some random reason.
Sherlock Holmes has left the building. Buy a lottery ticket instead.

Okay, I'm not posting again for at least another day if not two. Hopefully by then everybody who is being quiet will come back with fresh ideas and minds, both open and analytical.

[SoN!c]

Hmm I wonder if sonic vs votanic is the Thing and recruit doing a misdirection song and dance? Probably not right? I got to be overthinking it

Nope, was just rubbing Votanic but he does not want to reply anymore..

[Charle]

I will give explanations, but very busy at work right now, will look later this afternoon

[strike wolf]

Hmm I wonder if sonic vs votanic is the Thing and recruit doing a misdirection song and dance? Probably not right? I got to be overthinking it

Vot disagreed a lot with Son!c from day 1. So recruit, recruiter, town that at least has been consistent.

[SoN!c]

Hmm I wonder if sonic vs votanic is the Thing and recruit doing a misdirection song and dance? Probably not right? I got to be overthinking it

Vot disagreed a lot with Son!c from day 1. So recruit, recruiter, town that at least has been consistent.

Yes perhaps he got recruited for exactly that reason?

I was on Traf on D1.. Votanic was on me so recruiting Votanic would be a nice move.. if he is, you know who must have recruited him then..

[SoN!c]

This is my second mafia game. I learned in the first game that the downside of searching means you get suspected BIG TIME. Got no problem there as im confident i can explain all my actions when needed.
ALSO, not searching is achieving nothing in my book..


But: the n1 question is: does searching outways confusing town? Searching (rubbing / scratching) IS attracting a lot of heat..and confuses town a lot apparently.. like Swang and Strike's latest post..

What is the alternative? Not searching , rubbing it and coasting along? Not posting for days/weeks?

[strike wolf]

This is my second mafia game. I learned in the first game that the downside of searching means you get suspected BIG TIME. Got no problem there as im confident i can explain all my actions when needed.
ALSO, not searching is achieving nothing in my book..


But: the n1 question is: does searching outways confusing town? Searching (rubbing / scratching) IS attracting a lot of heat..and confuses town a lot apparently.. like Swang and Strike's latest post..

What is the alternative? Not searching , rubbing it and coasting along? Not posting for days/weeks?

Probably because you come off as arrogant and not an insignificant number of your posts are either non-sensical or whiny like this one.

[SoN!c]

This is my second mafia game. I learned in the first game that the downside of searching means you get suspected BIG TIME. Got no problem there as im confident i can explain all my actions when needed.
ALSO, not searching is achieving nothing in my book..


But: the n1 question is: does searching outways confusing town? Searching (rubbing / scratching) IS attracting a lot of heat..and confuses town a lot apparently.. like Swang and Strike's latest post..

What is the alternative? Not searching , rubbing it and coasting along? Not posting for days/weeks?

Probably because you come off as arrogant and not an insignificant number of your posts are either non-sensical or whiny like this one.

okay. all "whiney", and No difference at all if its rubbing or analytical.. all the same in the end, got it

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Part of me want to be lynched just to see what Sonic says when he realize I'm town

Anyway Lynch Sonic I am willing to change my vote to the people I mentioned before.