Loose Canon wrote: Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:43 pm
If noone wants to engage me on 58% logic, not obviously any place for me to go substantively gamewise in this game for now till dev has posted.
i'll engage on the 58%. there are two problems i have with it. one minor and one major
minor concern - it assumes that we believe you're house. i think most people are leaning that way.. but 100%? not quite. and every percentage of doubt we have on you reduces that 58%.
major concern - you seem to think 58% = 100%. yes, the numbers show it's more likely than not that the archivist has been turned. but 42% isn't negligible. you're harping on about this as if once you hit 51%, it's fait accomplis that it has to go that way and nothing else can happen.
but this all may be a moot (moo? mute?) point if we can't get the inactives to show up and chime in as well
a couple of other points - annieh's timing checks out. LC made a lengthy post that included an ask for the archivist to speak up now because we're in trouble. two minutes later, annieh puts up her flavourful post speaking up as the archivist. there is no way she wrote that post that fast. so that means, independently of LC's request, she was already writing her post. find it off-putting that LC then claims that timing is "holding on to" the information so far in to D2.
and was there really confusion about charle's role in this game D2 onwards? sonic clearly stated that he is still alive, he was house, but he has lost his vote as a result of the mislynch. i instantly read that as him being a living player but not being able to vote. i guess it would have been nice if sonic had said explicitly "10 players remaining so it takes 6 votes to lynch" but i think that should have been understood.
