Gilligan and PopTartPsycho18 [Cleared]

[IronWood]

<DELETE ME>
PLACE THE NAME OF THE ACCUSED IN THE SUBJECT LINE!!!

Replace or delete any xxxxxxx with the appropriate information.
Delete any accusations or entries which do not apply.

Be sure before you accuse someone!
</DELETE ME>

Accused:

poptartpsycho18
Gilligan

The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Other: Game 4068175 Tournament Game
These 2 players play together often. There are 3 players in bonus status and he SUICIDED me last round? Look at round 10 and 11. Poptartpsycho18 and I both had a chance to win the whole tourney with a victory here. Why would Gilligan make that play after a cashing a set if it wasn't just to help his buddy? He didn't have nearly enough troops to take me out??? ...and he could've got his bonus back?



Game number(s):

[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]



Comments:

[nagerous]

Gilligan's a tournament mod so hence plays a lot of tournament games. I doubt there is anything suspect here, I don't think either players accused play for rank much either, otherwise they wouldn't play tournaments so I'd imagine they will be cleared.

[Gilligan]

For one thing, it was not a suicide. I had more armies to use to take you out than you had altogether - Sorry if the dice failed me. Yeah, it sucks that if Arcane100 comes on at the right time to get your 5 cards - but it's a game. Dice aren't always on my side.

EDIT: If I had been conducting secret diplomacy with poptartpsycho18, then I would have waited for Arcane100 and Nicho to go then 'suicide' into you so poptart could kill you. It wouldn't make sense to do it before everyone else goes.

[Kotaro]

Looks like just another case of Gilligan failing Trust me, Gilligan doesn't cheat; otherwise, people would start mistaking him for good.

[Tisha]

why with poptartpsycho? Arcane100 doesn't have a chance to win? it looks like he was pretty close to killing you

[Godd]

wow, I am going to get accused next due to there is about 20 other players I play with in tons of tourneys and lots of the games are ended the same way with one player that is trying to win and fails so it looks like suicide and the next player wins it due to it (been on both sides of that)

[Bones2484]

I am in favor of this game being canceled and recreated because of Gilligan's cheating tactics*.




* Please note that this has nothing to do with the fact that I've been eliminated already and want another chance. Nor does it have anything to do with IronWood being clueless as to Gilligan taking a calculated chance and coming up just short.

[TheKidsTrumpet]

I am in favor of this game being canceled and recreated because of Gilligan's cheating tactics*.




* Please note that this has nothing to do with the fact that I've been eliminated already and want another chance. Nor does it have anything to do with IronWood being clueless as to Gilligan taking a calculated chance and coming up just short.

Hear Hear! haha.

[sailorseal]

I cannot believe someone would think Gillagan of all people as a multi, whats next lack? andy?

[king sam]

I cannot believe someone would think Gillagan of all people as a multi, whats next lack? andy?

Read the report, he accused him of a secret diplomacy cause he made a play that in IronWood's eyes helped poptartpsycho18 (a clansmate of Gilligan) get the win

Accused:
poptartpsycho18
Gilligan
The accused are suspected of:
Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Other: Game 4068175 Tournament Game
These 2 players play together often. There are 3 players in bonus status and he SUICIDED me last round? Look at round 10 and 11. Poptartpsycho18 and I both had a chance to win the whole tourney with a victory here. Why would Gilligan make that play after a cashing a set if it wasn't just to help his buddy? He didn't have nearly enough troops to take me out??? ...and he could've got his bonus back?
Comments:

[God Emperor Q]

looks like gilligan actually put green in a better position to win. I just think this is a case of crap dice. (and if it was a secret diplomacy, it wasn't a very good one )

[amazzony]

Read the report, he accused him of a secret diplomacy cause he made a play that in IronWood's eyes helped poptartpsycho18 (a clansmate of Gilligan) get the win

Get your facts straight - Gilligan and poptartpsycho18 are not in the same clan.

[king sam]

Get your facts straight - Gilligan and poptartpsycho18 are not in the same clan.

Your right, I misread the accusation wasnt Gilligan throwing the game to poptart cause they were clansmates, but cause they were friends. Either way my point still stands

[Kotaro]

Yes.. because trying to eliminate someone for their cards is throwing the game...

NEW RULE
You cannot try and eliminate anyone else, even if their cards look good

[Fireside Poet]

Suspects:
poptartpsycho18
Gilligan

Verdict: Cleared of secret diplomacy. Looks to me like Gilligan just went for the gusto and failed miserably, which we are all susceptible to do at times with streaky dice.

[sailorseal]

Suspects:
poptartpsycho18
Gilligan

Verdict: Cleared of secret diplomacy.

SHOCKER

[Kotaro]

FP, shouldn't this be moved to Closed Reports?

[king sam]

Clear this up real quick I never validated Iron Woods claim for this being an unsaid alliance, merely pointed out to sailor that his comment to the situation was wrong in the fact that Iron Wood had never made the accusation of both accounts in question being multi's.

I do however concur with Kotaro's new rule and think this should be added immediately

[sailorseal]

My question his why does his sig have f conquer club?

[Kotaro]

Well, since I've been informed the "no trolling" rule only applies sometimes, I'll respond to that.

It's not a f*ck conquerclub really, as the idea behind it is good. It's more like, "f*ck most of conquerclubs **** mods".

[sailorseal]

Well, since I've been informed the "no trolling" rule only applies sometimes, I'll respond to that.

It's not a f*ck conquerclub really, as the idea behind it is good. It's more like, "f*ck most of conquerclubs **** mods".

I see, and since trolling only applies sometimes, are there any in particular?