Baron Von PWN wrote:Phatscotty wrote:Woodruff wrote:Phatscotty wrote:Woodruff wrote:
Yes, it would be much better to have a school system like we can find currently in Afghanistan. Great idea.
Oh, so there are Zero options between US education as it is now and Afghanistan...REALLY?
Now
that is an intelligent statement....
You want to cut education 100%. That would equate to zero education. That is what we currently have in Afghanistan.
You were saying?
refine....cut 100% federal/50%state level. They cannot spend the money properly, stop letting them spend it. you may of course, jump straight to the conclusion that means I am arguing for pure anarchy........Dont be a poo poo head. Of course, we can handle education the way we always have handled it. The most recent failure in US education was just a social experiment that failed. Let's admit this failure first, only then can we start talking about what will succeed.
The private sector would just step in and fill in the gap overnight would it? It would amount to a lost generation of uneducated Americans and even when the private sector eventually filled the gap you would have a sector of the population without access to education, the poor would be shut out of any real chance of advancement . This must be the dumbest and most callous idea I've seen you propose so far.
I'm pretty sure it would take longer than 1 day, but yes, the students would show up at school tomorrow, same place, same time..... Let's use our heads here. I pre-emptively addressed the concerns of people exactly like you with my "pure anarchism" statement.
also, I am sure the private sector is not the only option. more head using....
it's only the dumbest most callous idea you've ever seen because you only have your own ideas to plug in, and then take your own line of thinking, as to think that is the only way possible, and also plug in your own warped conclusions. That's the only reason it's dumb and callous. Your imaginary example was nowhere near the top of the list of possibilities. the idea you provided about the private sector stepping is is dumb and callous. you should not assume I was talking about the private sector. I also addressed this specifically, 2 posts earlier, with a comment "the way we always did it before, before income taxes, beforedepartment of education. I know I am wasting my time, but I have a hard time not picking such low hanging fruit.