Bizarro World Mafia (Day 8) Game over, Mafia win!

[jnd94]

eh wat the hell, might as well lynch before there is a no-lynch

vote- Panicker

[AK_iceman]

Vote Count

• [1] Fircoal -- (panicker)
• [1] autoload -- (Senfive)
• [1] Colaalone -- (Fircoal)
• [10] panicker -- (mandalorian2298, Aimless, I GOT SERVED, XenHu, Anarkistsdream, the1exile, Balsiefen, Colaalone, Syzygy, jnd94)
• [1] trestain -- (spiesr)
• [1] Syzygy -- (Puff)
  
• [4] Not Voting, Everyone Else

10 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

Day Deadline: 12 Apr 2007 6:28 PM Alaska Time, GMT -8.

[AK_iceman]

Panicker (Mafia -- Cop) has been lynched.

Send in your NIGHT choices!

[AK_iceman]

Day Two

the1exile (Town -- Reviver), Fircoal (Town -- Townie), and reverend_kyle (Serial Killer) have been killed.

Lets get the day going!

[Balsiefen]

two townies for a serial killer and a mafia, thats pretty good.
i think we had serial killer+mafia+mafia2/viligante

[Balsiefen]

oh yes, i wont be able b to post for a few days but i'll be back soon

[Fircoal]

BAH! and it's good to know I'm important enough to be killed day 1.

[trestain]

good shout on panicker guys,

i wasn't around for most of day one as i was really busy at work, damn easter lol. will be around from now on though.

[XenHu]

Three deaths hmm?

I personally see the layout as one family+vig+serial killer.

Serial killer's dead now, so if one of the other kills was made by a vig, EASY! We didn't have much to go on Day 1 outside of Panicker, so I'm going to go and look back and see who was opposed to his lynching.

-X

[Senfive]

:shock:

Three deaths hmm?

I personally see the layout as one family+vig+serial killer.

Serial killer's dead now, so if one of the other kills was made by a vig, EASY! We didn't have much to go on Day 1 outside of Panicker, so I'm going to go and look back and see who was opposed to his lynching.

-X

I will save you the trouble. I was opposed to it cause it was a very shaky case. I do how ever trust anark from now on since he reads mafia tells alot better than me.

[XenHu]

ok there has been a hell of a lot of voting so I am going to vote sysygy and see where we go from there

This struck me as odd. When that vote was cast, Syzygy asks Puff:

ok there has been a hell of a lot of voting so I am going to vote sysygy and see where we go from there

And I am going to ask, why Syzygy?

To which Puff never answers...
~~~~~~~~~

Mandy was the first to vote Panicker:

So are you implying that you are a cop, Fircoal?

No, I'm implying I have mafia skilz.

wow such a blatent confession

UNVOTE:SENFIVE

VOTE:FIRCOAL

unvote
vote panicker for bandwagoning.

Senfive was against the reasoning for voting Panicker:

From what I read Fircoal made 2 stupid stupid mistakes.

1.)

Oh, good it's better to have idiots than good mafia hunters.

This is dumb cause it implys that he is non town and wants idiots so he lives to pick others off.

2.) Paniker picked up on it by changing his vote with this quote.

So are you implying that you are a cop, Fircoal?

No, I'm implying I have mafia skilz.

wow such a blatent confession

UNVOTE:SENFIVE

VOTE:FIRCOAL

I do not believe that Panicker was bandwagoning in anyway. He stated facts and voted unlike other scummy people after him. *cough* anark *cough*

Fircoal dug himself a hole and I want an explination as to why you would say those retarded things if you were a townie? Maybe I could give you some ridalin.

Then, after a few players questioned him, Senfive got a tad defensive:

People are taking way too much offense to my arguments and I didn't once FOS anyone or vote them. Pointed out there scumminess and they both FOS me and call me names. If you have half a brain you will see my arguments aren't flawed here.

Two of those players are now dead:

I don't consider your argument offensive, I find it flawed.

People are taking way too much offense to my arguments and I didn't once FOS anyone or vote them. Pointed out there scumminess and they both FOS me and call me names. If you have half a brain you will see my arguments aren't flawed here.

They are, though. 1) you can't understand sarcasm (though this uis not neccesarily scummy in your case). 2) ppanicker didn't state facts, he said "wow what a blatent confession", showing he totally misread the post.

Yes, Fircoal says stupid things when he's townie to lighten the mood, but conversely, he's far too good a mafia (the GAME) player to be casght out by saying something like "I'm mafia" (or other similarly obvious statement.

Senfive was clearly pissed off when more people start to vote Panicker:

Unvote

Vote: panicker

If you guys aren't right, I'm going back to my original theory.

Way to throw out a crap logic statement to cover your ass.

That way if someone says well you voted for him also, you can say it wasn't your idea. Why not stick to your own theory's? I am really not liking the stench of scum that you wreak of. Maybe a nice soothing bath and plenty of bed rest will clear that right up.

Of course, then we have Puff, who pops in to say:

I see what people are voting paniker for.

Which looks very scummy in my books Vote paniker

....While failing to answer as to why he voted Syzygy.

After that, a few more players drop in to cast their votes, lynching Panicker.

The rest, as they say, is history.

FOS:Puff, Senfive

-X

[The1exile]

two townies for a serial killer and a mafia, thats pretty good.
i think we had serial killer+mafia+mafia2/viligante

Meh - my role was actually pretty good, pity I never had a chance to use it.

[mandalorian2298]

Well, I did a bit of re-reading and these are my thoughts so far:
The fight between Senfive and Narc became very intense very fast, so it got my attention. Since both of these guys are senior players, one possiblity is that it was a smoke-screen to cover their (probably mafia) connection.
If I counted right, Narc voted 5th so there is a small posibility that he allready scatched paniker as a loss and joined the townies for a lynch to gain little credibility. But at the begining of paniker's bandwagon, Narc was still debating between voting paniker or somebody else (I forgot who, and am to lazy to re-read again ).
Senfive was awfully quick to come to the aid of guy who first voted him (before he switched to Fircoal). Also, Senfive tried to make a case against Fircoal appear stronger then it acctualy was wich is suprising since Senfive played a bunch of these games (wich also means that he played a bunch with Fircoal, and is thus aware of Fircoal's strange ways ).
To conlude that chapter, I just wanted to bring to everyone's attention these detailes that I noticed about Narc/Senfive fight, because it looks that it's still active and will probably influence the rytham of the game. But, since the fight could also be be explained as a result of two agressive characters (a trait that I like to see in a mafia game, since it starts things up ) I don't feel that there is a need for me to FOS them about it, I am just making an observation.

I may be in the minority, but I find the people voting panicker alot more scummy than the people voting fircoal. It seems they are desperately starting a bandwagon to take eyes off fircoal and doing it in an almost desperate manner


oh and unvote manbearpig

Bandwagoning is a charge wothy of a vote. Fircoal's unorthodox behaviour is a fact of life . It seems to me that it was you who desperatly tried to take the eyes from paniker.
FOS reverend_kyle

[mandalorian2298]

I just FOSed a dead guy! I'll go and blush for a while.

[XenHu]

Mandy my friend, RK is dead..



Methinks you need a new pair of glasses.

-X

[mandalorian2298]

Mandy my friend, RK is dead..



Methinks you need a new pair of glasses.

-X

Maybe it's just a clever rouse on rev's part.

[jnd94]

Mandy my friend, RK is dead..



Methinks you need a new pair of glasses.

-X

Maybe it's just a clever rouse on rev's part.

or mabye not

[spiesr]

Guys, with Syzygy's vote we are at Lynch -1 on panicker.

No one drop the hammer on panicker until we hear his roleclaim. Panicker, if you are town, roleclaim please.

The rest of you - we have some time before the deadline; we do not need a lynch for the sake of getting a lynch. Especially if panicker turns out to be the doc or cop.

Followed by...

eh wat the hell, might as well lynch before there is a no-lynch

vote- Panicker

?

[autoload]

Guys, with Syzygy's vote we are at Lynch -1 on panicker.

No one drop the hammer on panicker until we hear his roleclaim. Panicker, if you are town, roleclaim please.

The rest of you - we have some time before the deadline; we do not need a lynch for the sake of getting a lynch. Especially if panicker turns out to be the doc or cop.

Followed by...

eh wat the hell, might as well lynch before there is a no-lynch

vote- Panicker

?

I also found this suspicious...

Vote: jnd94

[Colaalone]

eh wat the hell, might as well lynch before there is a no-lynch

vote- Panicker

?

I saw that and wanted to snap my keyboard.
If panicker wasn't mafia, then JND would be dead within minutes.
Still...
FOS JND

[for dummies]

but he was mafia. So this leaves us with a dilemma: do we lynch jnd because of his bandwagoning, possible skimming of thread, and outright stupidity? Or do we call it an honest mistake and be thankfull that he dropped the hammer on a mafia member?

[autoload]

Or attribute it to a mafia member knowing that one of his own is getting lynched and decides to hammer him to look more townish?

[Colaalone]

Or attribute it to a mafia member knowing that one of his own is getting lynched and decides to hammer him to look more townish?

But if that were true... it seems he would lay the hammer down with more conviction then his last statement seems to have.
(maybe i'll looking to far into it)

[I GOT SERVED]

I'd say that Xen has the most compelling argument as of now.

jnd really didn't make the right move on that last lynch. But since he was mafia, I'm not really angry at him. But he does look rather suspicious...

But right now I'm only gonna say

FOS Puff, Senfive

[Syzygy]

Guys, with Syzygy's vote we are at Lynch -1 on panicker.

No one drop the hammer on panicker until we hear his roleclaim. Panicker, if you are town, roleclaim please.

The rest of you - we have some time before the deadline; we do not need a lynch for the sake of getting a lynch. Especially if panicker turns out to be the doc or cop.

Followed by...

eh wat the hell, might as well lynch before there is a no-lynch

vote- Panicker

?

I also found this suspicious...

Vote: jnd94

It was silly, but doesn't make me believe he (jnd) is mafia.